Cooney, J.A. v Gibbs, J.

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Q 1 'THE FEEEEAL CIYJRT OF AUCTRALIA

I

)

V I I X O R I A D I S T R I C T REGISTRY

l

PIG.

'J

1

O f

1987

IMDUC'THIAL DIVISIOPI

l

3

?TEXMIFZR LrJUISE

GIBBS

G. OHS.

Respondents

KEEL'I J.

3

I have decided to make interim orders. Mr. John.

who

appeared for the respondents Kathleen Matthews and Kathleen Gllbert, did not oppose the making of the orders sought.

Miss M. Hickey, of counsel. who appeared

for the respondents

'I'hereae Jcnklns and J l l l Kenned;r and Dr. Buchanan Q.C., who appeared with Mr. Struqnell of counsel for all of the remalnlng respondents, did not contend that the court lacked

power to make either

of the tslo orders sought but submitted

..

that the court,

in it3 discretion. should refuse to make

either of those orders.

The firrt lntsrlm order that

-.as souqht is:

"An order directing that each

of the second

to Seventeenth

Respondents

perform

and

ubserve the Rules

of the Royal Australian

Nurslng

Federation

oy reframing from

proceeding to hear

and determine the matters

the sub~ect of the

notice dated 22nd

December 1966 summmlng Judith Adnlla Cooney

t o show cause why she should

not be removed

from the office

of Federal Secretary."

Rule 20 of the Royal Australian Nursing Federation's

certified rules includes the following provision:-

"2Q.

Removal

from

office

of Federal

Counclllors and Officers

(a1

The Federal Council may remove from

office any officer or member of the

Federal Council at a meeting of the

Federal Council to which the person

d.

?

concerned has beer. summoned In vrltlng

-1gned by ths Federal Secretary

gr

Federal Presldent

t . 2 show cause wk;

he

or zhe should not be so removed. Pro-Iid?d that no m c h person shall be removed from office Unless he or she

has

been

gu1lty

found

of

misappropr1atlan of the funds of the Assoclatron. a suSstantla1 breach of the rules ~f the A3soclation. or gross mlsbehaviour or gross neglect of duty.

or has

ceased. according to

these

rules. to be eliqlble

to

hold

the

offlce.

The applicant contended that the respondent Gibbs, In

exerclsing the power as

Federal Presldent of the Federation

to call

upon the Federal Secretary

to show cause why she

should not be removed from offlce, wa3 under

a duty to

exercise that power In good faith and not for any ulterlor

or

extraneous

purpose - see

v Jess (1984) 3 FCR 263 at

286-7 per Gray J. and see Tanner

v Maynes (1985) 7 FCR 432 at

441. 455.

Counsel

f o r the respondents did not dispute that

the Federal President was

under a duty to exercise

that power

in accordance wlth that principle.

Mr. Strong and

Mr. Mueller of counsel, who appeared

for the applicant. contended that the Federal President. in

exerclsing the power under rule

20 to summon the applicant to

show cause at a meetlng of the Federal Council to

be held on

30 January 1987, failed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cooney, J.A. v Gibbs, J. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] FCA 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia was presented with an interim application in the case of Cooney, J.A. v Gibbs, J. The applicant, Judith Adilla Cooney, sought interim orders against multiple respondents, including Kathleen Matthews, Kathleen Gilbert, Therese Jenkins, Jill Kennedy, and others, to prevent them from proceeding with a notice dated 22 December 1986, which summoned Cooney to show cause why she should not be removed from the office of Federal Secretary of the Royal Australian Nursing Federation. The respondents were represented by various counsels, and none disputed the court's power to make the orders sought, but argued that the court should exercise its discretion not to make such orders.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Federal President, Gibbs, had a duty to exercise her power to call upon Cooney to show cause in good faith and not for any ulterior purpose, and whether the respondents were required to refrain from publishing or distributing information concerning the matters of the notice to any member other than the first to nineteenth respondents. The applicant argued that Gibbs failed to exercise the power in good faith by not considering the charges laid by members and merely acting as a "rubber stamp." The applicant also contended that if Gibbs had substantial reason to believe that a charge or part of a charge was groundless or maliciously false, she should not summon the person concerned to show cause under Rule 20 in respect of that charge.

The court considered the construction of Rule 20, which empowered and obliged the Federal President to consider any charges laid by members before deciding whether to call upon the applicant to show cause. The court found that the applicant had shown a serious question to be tried regarding the good faith of Gibbs in exercising her power. The court also determined that the balance of convenience favoured the making of the first order sought, as the detriment to Cooney if interim orders were not made included a real possibility of being removed from office at a time when she had been nominated for re-election. Regarding the second interim order, the court concluded that an order should be made but would hear further submissions as to its form.

The court made interim orders directing the respondents to refrain from proceeding with the notice dated 22 December 1986 and to refrain from publishing or distributing information concerning the matters of the notice to any member other than the first to nineteenth respondents. The court will hear further submissions as to the form of the second interim order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established