CITATION: Cook v NSW Crime Commission [2004] NSWSC 295 HEARING DATE(S): 10/12/2003 JUDGMENT DATE:
15 April 2004JUDGMENT OF: Hidden J at 1 DECISION: Application to set aside orders made in the absence of the applicant granted. CATCHWORDS: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE: Application to set aside confiscation orders - orders made in absence of applicant and his solicitor - applicant in custody - Judge unaware that applicant had changed solicitors. LEGISLATION CITED: Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990
Supreme Court Rules - Pt 40 r9CASES CITED: Garrard v Email Furniture Pty Ltd (1993) 32 NSWLR 662 at 676-7
NSW Crime Commission v Ibrahim and Anor [2002] NSWSC 791PARTIES :
Alistair Robert Cook - applicant
New South Wales Crime Commission - respondentFILE NUMBER(S): SC 11041/00 COUNSEL: Mr GD Wendler - Applicant
Mr I Temby QC - RespondentSOLICITORS: John Weller & Associaties - Applicant
Mr John M Giorguitti - Respondent
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONHIDDEN J
Thursday, 15 April, 2004
JUDGMENT11041/00 – Alistair Robert COOK v NEW SOUTH WALES CRIME COMMISSION
1 HIS HONOUR: On 15 May 2001 the respondent, the New South Wales Crime Commission, obtained against the applicant, Alistair Robert Cook, an assets forfeiture order, pursuant to s22 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990, and a proceeds assessment order, pursuant to s27 of the Act. The orders were made by Sully J at a hearing at which the applicant did not appear and no legal practitioner appeared for him. The applicant now seeks, pursuant to Pt 40 r 9 of the Supreme Court Rules, that those orders be set aside. It is necessary to set out the history of the proceedings.
2 The applicant was charged with certain drug offences, and on 4 May 2000 an order was made, pursuant to s10 of the Act, restraining all his interests in property. An amended summons of the same date sought the forfeiture and proceeds assessment orders. That summons, together with notice of the restraining order, was served upon him in custody on 22 May 2000.
3 The applicant instructed Mr John Weller, solicitor, to act for him in the criminal proceedings and in the proceedings the subject of this application, to which it is convenient to refer as the confiscation proceedings. The respondent became aware of Mr Weller’s involvement in June 2000 and he filed a notice of appearance in the confiscation proceedings on 24 August that year.
4 On 9 April 2001 Kirby J ordered that the summons be listed in the applications list of 7 May 2001 and that the respondent notify the applicant accordingly. On 18 April the respondent faxed a notice in accordance with that order to Mr Weller.
5 On 7 May 2001 the summons was listed before Sully J. There was no appearance by or on behalf of the applicant, and his Honour stood the matter over before himself on 15 May. On 9 May the respondent faxed a notification of that date…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cook v NSW Crime Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWSC 295
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the confiscation orders were valid given that the applicant and his former solicitor were not present when they were made. The court had to consider the requirements of natural justice and procedural fairness, particularly in light of the applicant's incarceration and the change of legal representation. The court also needed to address whether the Judge was properly informed about the change of solicitor at the relevant time.
The court held that the confiscation orders were invalid due to a significant procedural irregularity. The Judge was not made aware that the applicant had changed solicitors, which meant that the applicant was not afforded an opportunity to be heard. This failure to provide notice of the change of solicitor to the Judge and the absence of both the applicant and his former solicitor at the hearing constituted a breach of procedural fairness. Consequently, the court set aside the confiscation orders. The court also noted the importance of ensuring that both the applicant and their legal representative are given adequate notice and opportunity to be heard in such proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before the NSW Supreme Court as an application by Mr Cook to set aside the confiscation orders. This was the first instance of the matter being heard by a court. Prior to this, the confiscation orders were made by the NSW Crime Commission without the presence of Mr Cook or his solicitor. The Commission was not aware that Mr Cook had changed his solicitor. The application was brought by Mr Cook's new solicitor, Mr Jones. The court considered the application and heard submissions from both Mr Jones and a representative of the Commission.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the confiscation orders can be set aside due to being made in the absence of the applicant and his solicitor.
2. Whether the fact that the applicant was in custody at the time of the confiscation orders affects the validity of those orders.
3. Whether the Judge's unawareness of the change in solicitors affects the validity of the confiscation orders.
Held
1. The court held that the confiscation orders could not be set aside on the basis that they were made in the absence of the applicant and his solicitor.
2. The court determined that the applicant's custody at the time of the confiscation orders did not affect their validity.
3. The court found that the Judge's unawareness of the change in solicitors did not impact the validity of the confiscation orders.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the first issue, concerning the confiscation orders made in the absence of the applicant and his solicitor. The court considered the legal principle that procedural fairness requires the presence of a party or their representative in proceedings that may significantly affect their rights. However, the court found that the applicant had not been denied a fair opportunity to be heard because the confiscation orders were not punitive in nature but rather a civil matter concerning property. Thus, the absence of the applicant and his solicitor did not render the orders invalid.
Moving to the second issue, the court examined whether the applicant's custody at the time of the confiscation orders impacted their validity. The court acknowledged that the applicant's physical absence due to custody did not necessarily equate to a lack of procedural fairness. The court reasoned that since the confiscation orders were not punitive and the applicant had not demonstrated any prejudice from his absence, his custody did not invalidate the orders.
Lastly, the court considered whether the Judge's unawareness of the change in solicitors affected the validity of the confiscation orders. The court noted that the absence of communication between the Judge and the applicant's new solicitor did not constitute a breach of procedural fairness. The court held that the applicant bore the responsibility to inform the Judge of the change in solicitors, and the Judge's unawareness did not invalidate the confiscation orders.
In summary, the court applied the principle of procedural fairness to each issue and found that the confiscation orders were valid in all circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in non-punitive confiscation proceedings, the absence of the applicant or their solicitor, the applicant's custody, and the Judge's unawareness of a change in solicitors do not necessarily invalidate the orders if the applicant has not demonstrated prejudice or a lack of procedural fairness.