CONTRERAS v POLICE
[2001] SASC 100
Magistrates Appeal
1................ DUGGAN J..... The appellant has appealed against a sentence imposed in the Elizabeth Magistrates Court. The learned magistrate imposed a global penalty pursuant to the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act, 1988 s 18A for a number of offences committed over the period of time from 25 October 1998 to 9 January 2000.
When the matter came before me there was confusion as to the number of offences included in the global penalty. I found it necessary to obtain a report from the learned magistrate and I accept that the appellant was sentenced in relation to nine matters, the details of which are set out in the following table:
| “DATE OF OFFENCE | DETAILS OF OFFENCE |
| 3/3/99 | 1. Illegal use of motor vehicle; 2. Drive under influence of drug; 3. Dangerous driving; 4. Drive disqualified. |
| 17/1/99 | Possess heroin |
| 15/1/99 | Illegal interference with a motor vehicle |
| 18/1/99 | Illegal interference with a motor vehicle |
| 9/1/2000 | False name |
| 25/10/98 | Drive disqualified” |
At the hearing of the appeal Mr Vadasz, for the appellant, submitted that the magistrate’s sentence was confined to the offences which took place on 3 March 1999. The magistrate stated in her report that she sentenced the appellant on all matters referred to in the above table and that she imposed a global sentence in respect of all the listed offences. The endorsement on the consolidated file MCPAR-99-2016 supports this assertion. Although the offences were not listed in the sentencing remarks, as I think they should have been, it is to be inferred from her Honour’s remarks that the offending for which the appellant was being sentenced extended beyond the events of 3 March 1999 and included the other offences in the table. The same inference can be drawn from the remarks which her Honour made at an earlier hearing on 25 February 2000.
Mr Vadasz drew my attention to the court’s Certificate of Record for 25 February 2000 which records that various orders were made in relation to the offences which were committed on days other than 3 March 1999. He said the record suggests that the appellant was convicted without penalty on these offences on 25 February 2000. I agree that the record is somewhat confusing in that it records costs orders on that date, but I accept the magistrate’s explanation that the appellant was not sentenced for any offences until an adjourned date, namely, 29 September 2000.
The appellant entered pleas of guilty to the charges on 25 February 2000. One of the victims of the offences committed on 3 March 1999 then gave victim impact evidence. At the conclusion of this hearing the magistrate released the appellant on bail for a period of six months with his mother as guarantor and subject to various conditions relating to supervision. It was explained to me that the release on bail was by way of a “Griffiths remand” (Griffiths v The Queen (1977) 137 CLR 293). The purpose…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Contreras v Police No. Scciv-00-1121 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 100
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the magistrate correctly identified the offences for which the appellant was being sentenced, whether the sentence was manifestly excessive, and whether the magistrate erred in refusing to suspend the sentence. The court also needed to address the magistrate's comments about the potential consequences of breaching the Griffiths remand and whether these comments constituted an error of sentencing principle. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the penalty for the offence of dangerous driving was correctly imposed and whether sufficient allowance was made for the time the appellant spent in custody prior to sentencing.
The court found that there was confusion regarding the number of offences included in the global penalty, but accepted the magistrate's explanation that the sentence was imposed for all the offences listed. The court also noted an error of sentencing principle in the magistrate's comments about the potential consequences of breaching the Griffiths remand. Furthermore, the court found that insufficient allowance was made for the time the appellant spent in custody prior to sentencing. Given these findings, the court decided to set aside the sentence and consider the sentencing discretion afresh. The court imposed a new head sentence and non-parole period, taking into account the four months the appellant spent in custody, and also imposed a fine for the offence of dangerous driving.
The final orders of the court were to set aside the original sentence imposed by the magistrate, impose a new head sentence of imprisonment for one year and eight months, fix a non-parole period of nine months, impose a fine of $400 for the offence of dangerous driving, and disqualify the appellant from holding a driver’s licence for a period of 12 months. The fees and levies imposed by the magistrate would remain as part of the sentence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi