Contreras and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

Contreras and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2023] AATA 24 (17 January 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2018/4734, 2018/4736, 2021/1083, 2021/1084, 2021/1085

Re:Julio Contreras

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

Date:17 January 2023

Place:Sydney

Each of the decisions the subject of review is affirmed.

..................................[sgd]......................................

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – whether Respondent has present liability to pay compensation for the Applicant’s medical conditions – initially accepted liability for bilateral lateral epicondylitis – whether the bilateral lateral epicondylitis caused chronic pain syndrome in the period specified and contributed to a significant degree to major depression – whether major depression was caused by the claims process – whether the Respondent has present liability to pay compensation for bilateral lateral epicondylitis, C5-6 disc bulge and canal stenosis with cord compression, and bilateral shoulder pain -- reviewable decisions affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Kirkpatrick v The Commonwealth [1985] FCA 440; [1985] 9 FCR 36
Renouf v Comcare [2019] AATA 1055

Swindale v Comcare [2019] AATA 2426

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

17 January 2023

Introduction

  1. The Applicant, Mr Contreras, was employed as a mail sorter by the Respondent, the Australian Postal Corporation, from 7 September 2001. After completing night shift on 24 February 2016, he went to see Dr Dharmaratnam, his General Practitioner (GP). He has not worked since, apart from a brief period in 2016 when he attempted modified duties on reduced hours.

  2. He was born in Chile in September 1956 and arrived in Australia in 1987. He had a couple of jobs and a period of unemployment before starting work for the Respondent. He and his wife were assisted by an interpreter during the hearing.

  3. The relevant legislation is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act).  Section 5B provides:

    (1)  In this Act:

    disease means:

    (a)  an ailment suffered by an employee; or

    (b)  an aggravation of such an ailment;

    that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee.

    (2) In determining whether an ailment or aggravation was contributed to, to a significant degree, by an employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee, the following matters may be taken into account:

    (a)the duration of the employment;

    (b)the nature of, and particular tasks involved in, the employment;

    (c)any predisposition of the employee to the ailment or aggravation;

    (d)any activities of the employee not related to the employment;

    (e)any other matters affecting the employee’s health.

    This subsection does not limit the matters that may be taken into account.

    (3)  In this Act:

    significant degree means a degree that is substantially more than material.

    The proceedings

  4. There are five proceedings before the Tribunal: 2018/4734, 2018/4736, 2021/1083, 2021/1084, and 2021/1085.

  5. Proceedings 2018/4734 arise from the Applicant’s claim for compensation lodged on 29 February 2016 for pain in the left wrist while sorting in the large…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Contreras and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for compensation by the Applicant against the Australian Postal Corporation (the Respondent). The Applicant sought compensation for bilateral lateral epicondylitis, chronic pain syndrome, major depression, C5-6 disc bulge and canal stenosis with cord compression, and bilateral shoulder pain. The Respondent initially accepted liability for the bilateral lateral epicondylitis but disputed whether this condition caused chronic pain syndrome and contributed significantly to major depression, and whether the major depression was caused by the claims process. The Respondent also disputed that the C5-6 disc bulge, canal stenosis with cord compression, and bilateral shoulder pain were work-related. The decision was made by Senior Member Mrs J C Kelly.

The legal issues before the court were to determine whether the Respondent had a present liability to pay compensation for the Applicant's various medical conditions. Specifically, the court was required to ascertain whether the bilateral lateral epicondylitis, accepted as work-related, caused chronic pain syndrome and significantly contributed to major depression. Furthermore, the court had to determine if the major depression was a consequence of the claims process itself. Finally, the court needed to decide whether the C5-6 disc bulge and canal stenosis with cord compression, and bilateral shoulder pain were work-related injuries for which the Respondent was liable to pay compensation.

The Senior Member found that while the Applicant suffered from bilateral lateral epicondylitis, the evidence did not support the claim that this condition caused chronic pain syndrome or significantly contributed to major depression in the period claimed. The Applicant's medical records prior to February 2016 did not indicate work-related arm or wrist pain, and the initial presentation of pain was described as mild soreness. The Senior Member inferred that the Applicant's perception of bullying in relation to his claim, following the lodging of his initial claim and the manager's supplementary statement, likely contributed to his psychological distress. Regarding the C5-6 disc bulge, canal stenosis with cord compression, and bilateral shoulder pain, the Senior Member concluded, based on the evidence of Associate Professor McGill and Associate Professor Fearnside, that these conditions were not work-related.

Consequently, the Senior Member affirmed each of the reviewable decisions. This meant that the Respondent was found not to have present liability to pay compensation for chronic pain syndrome, major depression as a consequence of the work injury, the C5-6 disc bulge and canal stenosis with cord compression, or the bilateral shoulder pain. The Respondent's liability was limited to the accepted bilateral lateral epicondylitis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant claimed that he loved his job with the Respondent and never had an issue until February 2016, apart from an incident in 2013 when he felt that he had been bullied by his team leader. He also claimed that he did not have any psychological symptoms until February 2016. He described the development of symptoms in his right forearm sometime in late 2014 or early 2015. He started to use his left arm to rest his right arm which resulted in symptoms developing in his left arm during the course of 2015 and early 2016 until in February 2016 he felt the same symptoms in both forearms.The evidence The earliest clinical record for the Applicant from subpoenaed material from several general medical practices was 29 November 2013. There is no medical record before 24 February 2016 which mentioned the Applicant reporting work-related pain in either wrist or arm. There were occasions when he was unable to go to work because of illness / got a medical certificate: 29 November 2013, 26 March 2014, 28 May 2014, 25 August 2014, 17 December 2014, 11 September 2015, and 15 September 2015 The Applicant did visit a doctor complaining of pain in other parts of his body on a number of occasions. On 26 March 2014, the Applicant reported that he had a sore throat, headache, body aches and pains, shoulder pains, mild fever and a cold. On 28 May 2014, the Applicant was experiencing neck pain, especially while trying to look back. On 17 November 2014, he had back pain which started suddenly while he was lawn mowing. On 11 September 2015, he had a sore back and aches and pains all over, although the reason for the visit was an unrelated condition. On 15 September 2015, he felt tired, had body aches, sore arms and shoulder, and musculoskeletal pains, having helped his son move house two days ago. On 12 February 2016, he had mild pain in the groin. The first contemporaneous record of work-related injury to the arms or wrists is the clinical note made by the GP on 24 February 2016. While sorting mail the Applicant ‘noticed some soreness in his left wrist’. The GP recorded:0/E: Tenderness in lat epicondyleROM restricted in wristTenderness + in dorsal surface of the wrist The diagnosis was lateral epicondylitis. An imaging request was printed for ultrasound to left elbow/left wrist. The GP and the Applicant completed a WorkCover NSW – certificate of capacity on the same day. The diagnosis was lateral epicondylitis, wrist injury. Only the left wrist was referred to. A surgery consultation on 26 February 2016 appeared to refer only to one elbow/wrist. The Applicant completed a Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation on 29 February 2016 for pain in his left wrist. He claimed that he first noticed it at 3am on 23 February 2016. His manager completed his part of the form on 1 March 2016. The form was stamped ‘RECEIVED 07 MAR 2016 COMPENSATION’. Also on 1 March 2016, the manager prepared a supplementary statement. Before going to that statement, I note that there seemed to be some confusion about dates because the Applicant was working night shift. I understand that the manager refers to the date a shift finished.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the claims for for C5-6 disc bulge and canal stenosis with cord compression (2021/1083) and bilateral shoulder pain (2021/1084), the evidence of Associate Professor McGill and Associate Professor Fearnside lead me to conclude that those conditions are not work-related.Conclusion For the above reasons, each of the decisions the subject of review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Gollan summarised the Respondent’s primary case as being based on the proposition that the Applicant and his wife both concocted a false narrative in relation to the history of chronic pain for up to three years before 24 February 2016. His secondary case was that there were other physical causes of the Applicant’s pain.Consideration The Applicant worked very hard for the Respondent for sixteen years. He was proud that his hard work had enabled him to support his family, including educating his children to university level. He took very little leave. This is the first time he has claimed workers’ compensation. His medical records show that until 24 February 2016 his health was generally good. It is not in dispute that he now suffers major depressive disorder and is unfit for work. The cause of this condition is in issue. It is also not in dispute that on 24 February 2016 he suffered bilateral lateral epicondylitis. The effect of this condition is in issue. The resolution of the issues depends on whether I accept that the Applicant suffered pain in his left and right upper limbs as a result of his work for a period of one to three years before 24 February 2016 as he claimed. That history is essential to the opinions of Associate Professor Champion and Dr Ho. To accept that history, I must accept that the Applicant did not seek medical treatment for pain in either upper limb until a point when he ‘collapsed’ because of pain while working on 24 February 2016. The GP’s contemporaneous record does not support the pain being so debilitating as to cause the Applicant to collapse. It records that the Applicant ‘noticed some soreness in his left wrist’. I find that the Applicant reported the pain in his left wrist to his manager about midnight on 23 February 2016 and was moved to sort small letters until the end of his shift at 6am on 24 February 2016 when he told his manager he was going to the doctor. He was able to continue to work until the end of his shift. He did complain about that later but whether he complained at the time, I do not know. The contemporaneous records demonstrate that soon after 1 March 2016 when the manager prepared the supplementary statement in which he did not accept that the Applicant suffered an injury at work on 23 or 24 February 2016, the Applicant felt he was being bullied in relation to his claim. That claim has continued and evolved ever since. I infer that it was not a coincidence that the first reference to the right arm was on 3 March 2016, after that report was prepared. An ultrasound was requested, although no examination or symptoms were recorded. It is clear from the first report of Associate Professor McGill who saw the Applicant within a month of the injury, that the injury had severely adversely affected the Applicant’s psychological health. It was also clear to the doctors who saw him within the next 18 months, including Dr Kannangara, Dr Ho, Mr O’Neill and Dr Anderson. Unfortunately, the Applicant’s psychological condition did not improve when the Respondent accepted liability for the bilateral lateral epicondylitis on 6 April 2016.