Contor v Bickey

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Contor v Bickey & Anor [2016] QSC 91

PARTIES:

IAN CHEYNNE CONTOR     

(Plaintiff)

v

VICKY-ANN JOYCE BICKEY

(First Defendant)

and

ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED
(ABN 15 000 122 850)

(Second Defendant)

FILE NO:

S33 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Mackay      

DELIVERED ON:

27 April 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Townsville

HEARING DATE:

4 March 2016

JUDGE:

North J

ORDER:

1.    Judgement for the defendants against the plaintiff.

2.    That within 14 days of the publication of these reasons the parties are to file and serve written submissions upon the issue of costs.

3.  That in the event no party files submissions upon  costs the order be:

(a)  The plaintiff pay the second defendant’s costs of and incidental to the action to be assessed on the standard basis, such costs to include reserved costs if any.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ROAD ACCIDENT CASES – LIABILITY OF DRIVERS OF VEHICLES – FAILURE TO LOOK OUT – CAUSATION – CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE - INTOXICATION

LEGISLATION

Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld)

CASES

Chapman v Hearse (1961) 106 CLR 112

Gould and Birbeck and Bacon v. Mount Oxide Mines Ltd. (In liq.) (1990) 169 CLR 279

Hammond v Pascoe & Brisbane City Council  [1992] QCA 380

Imbree v McNeilly (2008) 236 CLR 510

March v E & M H Stramore Pty Ltd & Anor (1990-1991) 171 CLR 506

Pennington v Norris (1956) 96 CLR 10

.

Prodrebersek v Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd (1985) 59 ALJR 529

Romeo v Conservation Commission of The Northern Territory (1998) 192 CLR 431

Wynebergen v Hoyts Corporation Pty Ltd (1997) 72 ALJR 65

COUNSEL:

P Cullinane for the Plaintiff

M Liddy for the Defendants

SOLICITORS:

Macrossan and Amiet for the Plaintiff
McInnes Wilson Lawyers for the Defendants

  1. The plaintiff, a motor cycle rider, sustained severe injuries when the motor cycle he was riding collided with a Holden Commodore sedan driven by the first defendant.  Among the injuries he sustained was a severe injury to his right lower leg resulting in its subsequent amputation.  The parties have settled issues relating to the assessment of the quantum of damages suffered by the plaintiff at $800,000.00.  Liability is in issue.

  2. In his amended statement of claim the plaintiff alleges:[1]

    [1] Filed 26 October 2015, document 8.

    “5.At approximately 7.15pm on 5 October 2012 at Coningsby near Mackay in the State of Queensland, the Plaintiff, as he rode the motorbike in a northerly direction on the Bruce Highway performed a right hand turn into Kochs Road and then proceeded in a southerly direction on the Bruce Highway for a short distance before coming to a stop to the left of the fog line on the Bruce Highway after which time he did the following:-

    (a)Looked at his acquaintance Norton George Watson who was stopped and attending to his stationary motorbike on the opposite side of the Bruce Highway directly opposite to the Plaintiff at which time the Plaintiff received an indication from Norton George Watson by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Contor v Bickey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Contor sued Bickey for damages arising from a motor vehicle accident on the Bruce Highway. The plaintiff, Contor, was a motorcyclist who collided with the defendant, Bickey, who was driving a car. The primary legal issues the court needed to address were whether Bickey was negligent in causing the accident and, if so, whether Contor's intoxication or other actions contributed to the incident.

The court found that Bickey was negligent in failing to look out for oncoming traffic before entering the highway. This was a crucial point of liability as it established that Bickey's actions directly contributed to the accident. The court further considered whether Contor's intoxication or failure to properly execute the U-turn contributed to the accident. The plaintiff admitted to consuming alcohol before the accident but maintained that he did not feel its effects. The court noted that Contor's intoxication could have impaired his ability to make sound decisions and execute the U-turn correctly.

In determining the outcome, the court concluded that Bickey was primarily liable for the accident due to his failure to properly look out for oncoming traffic. However, the court also found Contor to be contributorily negligent, as his intoxication and actions leading up to the accident contributed to the incident. This finding of contributory negligence reduced the damages Contor could recover from Bickey. Ultimately, the court ruled in favour of Bickey, awarding judgment against Contor.

The final orders included a judgment in favour of the defendant, with the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of the action. The court also set a deadline for the parties to file and serve written submissions on the issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Judgement for the defendants against the plaintiff.

2. That within 14 days of the publication of these reasons the parties are to file and serve written submissions upon the issue of costs.

3. That in the event no party files submissions upon costs the order be:

(a) The plaintiff pay the second defendant’s costs of and incidental to the action to be assessed on the standard basis, such costs to include reserved costs if any.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The plaintiff was cross-examined about a Notice of Accident form that he completed sometime after the accident as part of his claim for damages.[8] In the form in a box which asked, “Describe what happened,” the following has been typed in:“My last memory before the accident was riding my motorcycle north on the Bruce Highway having just left the petrol station at Coningsby.One of my fellow riders, Norton Watson, who was in front of me had pulled off left to the highway and stopped.I remember executing a turn to travel in the opposite direction on the highway with the intention of riding back to where Norton was.I don’t remember anything after that until lying on the ground in the aftermath of the accident with Norton Watson talking to me.”[8] Notice of Accident claim form dated 12/12/2012, exhibit 4.The Evidence of the Witnesses On the day in question the plaintiff attended a funeral in North Mackay after which, with other members of the Indigenous Riders Motorcycle Club he attended a wake held at the North Leagues Club. He recalled arriving at about 3 o’clock and staying for two to two and a half hours. During that time he drank bourbon and Coke from a glass consuming probably about four. One of the other members of the club present was Norton Watson who was drinking Hahn light beer from stubbies. They were not drinking together so he was unable to give any estimate of how much Watson drank but he said that Watson did not appear to be affected by alcohol. After the wake members of the motorcycle club went to the club’s clubhouse situated in Glenella. At the clubhouse the plaintiff again drank bourbon and Coke. He recalled having two or three, again drinking spirits mixed with Coca-Cola in a glass. He gave evidence that Watson was drinking Hahn light beer from stubbies at the clubhouse. The plaintiff said that it was “maybe” six o’clock when they left the clubhouse with the intention to travel north to his home at Mt Martin which is near Mirani, north of Mackay. The plaintiff said he was travelling in a group of four with Norton and two others. Each motor cyclist was travelling alone without pillion passengers. When asked how he felt he said he “felt good”[9] and he said that he did not feel affected by alcohol.[10] He said that the group stopped at a service station at Coningsby to fuel up. After that the group continued the journey north when he noticed that Watson pulled over to the left side of the road which is the left of the northbound lane, whereupon he, the plaintiff, did a U-turn to go back to see if Watson was all right. After performing the U-turn he was on the outside of the southbound lane and approximately 50 to 100 metres past Watson. He then proceeded to travel slowly southbound to a point to the left of the southbound lane opposite to where Watson was stopped on the left of the northbound lane. When he arrived at the point opposite to Watson and his bike he observed that Watson was off his bike looking at the motor. Then after receiving a “thumbs up” from Watson he said that he activated his right indicator and looked over his shoulder to see if traffic was travelling in a northerly direction[11] and then looked over his right shoulder twice to the lane with the southbound traffic.[12] He saw a car in the distance.[13] Specifically he saw “a dull set of headlights”[14] but was unable to gain an impression or to judge the distance, offering as an explanation that the headlights were dull.[15] He said that he then looked in the opposite direction, towards the traffic that would have been travelling in the northbound lane and he went to execute a movement to head north[16] whereupon “once I went to execute to move into the southbound lane to go into the northbound lane” the accident occurred.[17] When asked how far into the southbound lane he was when this happened he said he thought “it was just over the fog line … just past the fog line.”[18] He described his speed as not very fast, the bike was in first gear so he was “just rolling”.[19] When asked he said that probably the first half of his motorcycle had entered the southbound lane when the collision occurred.[20] When cross-examined he said he could recall that where he executed the U-turn on the highway before travelling south he did so at a point where a road entered the highway from the right (for northbound traffic).[21] When pressed with his statement[22] and how it was that his evidence was more detailed than he could provide at the time he made the statement he said that subsequent to making that statement he had remembered more detail.[23] He confirmed that his recollection was that he executed the U-turn and then progressed south on the left hand side of what is described as “the fog line” shown in the photographs and that he travelled at a relatively slow speed but that he came to a stop before he commenced the turn into the southbound lane with the intention of travelling into the northbound lane.[24] He could recall stopping and putting his feet on the ground before commencing the manoeuvre into the southbound lane.[25] He was stopped on the opposite side of the road from Norton for three to four minutes before commencing the manoeuvre,[26] while he wasn’t actually talking to him, Norton was looking at his bike and they were on opposite sides of the highway. He was waiting for instructions from Norton to see “how he was with his bike”[27] and during this he was sitting stationery on his bike.[28] He said that he sat on the side of the road opposite Norton for three to four minutes with the right turn indicator of his motor cycle activated.[29] When pressed in cross-examination he reiterated that he was unsure, due to the dull headlights, how far away the vehicle he observed was, apparently travelling in the southbound lane towards him.[30][9] T 1-12 l 17.[10] T 1-12 l 25.[11] T 1–15 l 1-5.[12] T1-15 l 14.[13] T1-15 l 14.[14] T1-15 l 20 & 22.[15] T1-15 l 27 & 30.[16] T1-15 l 35.[17] T1-15 l 40.[18] T1-15 l 45.[19] T1-16 l 5.[20] T1-19 l 40.[21] T1-22 l 20 ff.[22] Exhibit 4, see paragraph [9] above.[23] T1-23 l 45.[24] T1-24 l 1-11.[25] T1-24 l 25.[26] T1-24 l 35.[27] T1-25 l 7.[28] T1-25 l 14.[29] T1-25 l 45.[30] T1-26 l 27-37.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.