Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Whitehaven Coal Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION v WHITEHAVEN COAL LIMITED [2014] FCCA 2657
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Admitted contraventions of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – whether proposed by consent declarations and orders should be made – whether in all the circumstances the agreed penalties are appropriate – whether Court should give effect to the settlement reached by parties – whether the Court should order penalty to be paid to the applicant.
Legislation:
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s.546
Cases cited:
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285
Ministry for Industry, Tourism and Resources v Mobil Oil Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72
Applicant: CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING & ENERGY UNION
Respondent: WHITEHAVEN COAL LIMITED
File Number: SYG 1015 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Emmett
Hearing date: 30 October 2014
Date of Last Submission: 10 November 2014
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 18 November 2014

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicant: Ms Kathryn Presdee (Slater & Gordon)
Solicitors for the Respondents: Mr Drew Pearson (Herbet Smith Freehills)
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1015 of 2013

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING & ENERGY UNION

Applicant

And

WHITEHAVEN COAL LIMITED

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Pursuant to joint submissions, the parties seek that the Court make the following declarations and orders:

    “THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

    1. The respondent breached section 26 of the Whitehaven Open Cut Operation (Tarragonga) Enterprise Agreement 2010 and thereby contravened section 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), which is taken to constitute one single contravention pursuant to section 557(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

    2. The Respondent failed to notify the Chief Executive Officer of the Commonwealth Services Delivery Agency (Centrelink) before it dismissed each of the employees for reasons of an economic, technological, structural or similar nature and thereby contravened section 530(4) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) which is taken to constitute one single contravention pursuant to section 557(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

    AND THE COURT ORDERS THAT

    1. A pecuniary penalty of $19,000 is imposed on the Respondent pursuant to section 546 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in respect of the contravention referred to in the declarations made in Order 1 above.

    2. A pecuniary penalty of $1,000 is imposed on the Respondent pursuant to section 546 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in respect of the contravention referred to in the declarations made in Order 2 above.

    3. The above penalties are to be paid to the Applicant in accordance with section 546(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) within 30 days of the date of this order.

    4. The proceedings be otherwise dismissed.

    5. There be no order as to costs.”

  2. The orders are sought on the basis of a Statement of Agreed Facts. I make findings as referred to in that Statement of Agreed Facts which provides as follows:

    “Background

    1. Whitehaven Coal Mining Limited (Whitehaven

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Whitehaven... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 2657
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) brought proceedings against Whitehaven Coal Mining Limited (Whitehaven) in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned Whitehaven's implementation of a restructure at its open-cut coal mines in New South Wales, which resulted in redundancies. The parties presented a Statement of Agreed Facts to the court, upon which the decision was based.

The court was required to determine whether Whitehaven had breached its obligations under the relevant enterprise agreements by failing to adequately consult with employees and the CFMEU before implementing the restructure and redundancies. Specifically, the court needed to consider the differing notification and consultation clauses within the Rocglen, Tarrawonga, and Maintenance Agreements, and whether Whitehaven's actions met the requirements of these clauses, particularly concerning the timing of notification and the nature of consultation. A further issue was whether Whitehaven had contravened the *Fair Work Act 2009* by failing to notify the Chief Executive Officer of Centrelink of the redundancies.

Emmett J found that Whitehaven had breached clause 26 of the Tarrawonga Agreement, which required consultation with employees as to the nature of major workplace changes and their likely consequences. The court determined that Whitehaven made a "definite decision" to implement the restructure on 21 March 2013, but did not notify or consult with the affected employees or the CFMEU until the following morning, after the decision had been finalised and preparations for implementation were underway. This timing meant that the consultation process, as contemplated by the agreement, did not occur prior to the decision being made. However, the court noted that the Rocglen and Maintenance Agreements did not impose a positive obligation to consult prior to a definite decision being made, only to notify. Regarding the *Fair Work Act 2009*, Whitehaven admitted to failing to notify Centrelink of the redundancies, as required by the Act, due to a lack of awareness of the obligation.

Whitehaven accepted that there was a genuine economic need for the redundancies. The court noted that Whitehaven had paid all statutory and contractual entitlements to the redundant employees and had also reached a confidential monetary settlement with the CFMEU in respect of claims for compensation for the failure to consult. Whitehaven also admitted liability for the failure to notify Centrelink.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The orders are sought on the basis of a Statement of Agreed Facts. I make findings as referred to in that Statement of Agreed Facts which provides as follows:“Background1. Whitehaven Coal Mining Limited (Whitehaven) operates open cut coal mines. In March 2013, it operated the Tarrawonga, Rocglen and Werris Creek mines located in the Gunnedah Basin in New South Wales (the Mines). 2. The Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) is an organisation of employees registered under the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 and represented employees at the Mines.Coal Market Conditions in late 2012 / early 20133. In November and December 2012, as part of enterprise bargaining sessions, the CFMEU and employees at the Mines were informed that Whitehaven was facing challenging market conditions and that:a. its operations needed to be reviewed in order to survive; b. there would be a review of production and maintenance manning levels and shift structures;c. there would need to be a review of equipment requirements; d. there would need to be a review of all costs;e. Rocglen and Sunnyside (another mine Whitehaven was operating that was placed into care and maintenance in October 2012) profitability (EBITDA) went from a profit of approximately $28 per tonne in January 2012 to a loss of approximately $14 per tonne in September 2012; andf. Tarrawonga profitability (EBITDA) went from a profit of approximately $41 per tonne in January 2012 to a loss of approximately $7 per tonne in November 2012. 4. On 26 February 2013, the Whitehaven Group released its financial results for the half year ending 31 December 2012. In that period, the Whitehaven Group recorded a net loss after tax of $47 million, down from a profit of $19.9 million in the previous corresponding period. Amongst the key factors underpinning the result were:a. substantially lower average coal prices. Coal prices averaged US$92 per tonne during the half year ending 31 December 2012, compared to US$108 in the previous corresponding period; andb. unfavourable foreign exchange impacts.5. In light of these financial results, in February 2013, local management at the Mines, which included Mr Wilkinson who at the time was employed as the General Manager for Open Cut Operations and Mr Wood who at the time was employed as the Coal Operations Manager, upon instructions from senior management, were required to give consideration to proposals and options as to how costs could be reduced across all areas of open cut production. 6. However, irrespective of any planning of options and proposals, a final decision could only be made by Mr Jamie Frankcombe (Executive Manager – Open Cut Operations), who in turn would need to obtain the approval and authorisation of Mr Tony Haggarty, the outgoing Managing Director / CEO, and by Mr Paul Flynn, the incoming Managing Director / CEO (the Senior Executives). It was the decision of the incoming CEO, Mr Flynn, which would be final. 7. During February and March 2013, one proposal which was considered to reduce costs was to amend the mine plan for each Mine by amending the “strip ratio”. The mine plan identifies the particular “strips” or areas of the mine that are to be mined and the sequence in which they will be mined. It also specifies the amount and type of machinery, equipment and personnel required to mine each strip. One of the key aspects of a mine plan is the “strip ratio”, which represents the amount in cubic metres of overburden that must be removed per tonne of coal. For example, if the strip ratio is 8:1, this means 8 cubic metres of overburden has to be removed per tonne of coal being extracted. A higher strip ratio generally represents higher production costs per tonne of coal.8. A change in the “strip ratio” would reduce costs because Whitehaven would mine coal which required less effort to extract and was thus cheaper to mine. Coal which was harder (and thus more costly) to mine would not be mined while the market price of coal was low. A reduction in the “strip ratio” would also require fewer personnel and less equipment to extract the coal but could maintain the existing coal production rates. 9. During early March 2013, local management at the Mines explored a proposal which would involve a reduction in the “strip ratio”. In exploring this proposal, local management gave consideration to the impact of the reduced “strip ratio” upon the number of staff required and the level of equipment that would need to be operated. A financial evaluation of the expected cost savings from the planned changes were that the Whitehaven Group would save somewhere between $27.6 million (based on the direct cost saving associated with reduced equipment and personnel needs) and $49.8 million (based on the changes in the mine plan). This proposal was discussed with the Senior Executives, who indicated that local management team should take steps to finalise the proposal, but that a final decision would be made by Mr Flynn. Neither the CFMEU nor the employees were consulted at any stage of the development of this proposal.10. By this time, Whitehaven was in a position where it was losing $2 million per week and trading conditions were continuing to deteriorate.11. In the late afternoon of Thursday 21 March 2013, the local management team spoke with Mr Frankcombe via the telephone. Mr Frankcome said:“I believe everyone [in the Senior Executive] is in approval [of the plan that has been developed], but we should have a decision from Paul [Mr Flynn] later tonight, but please plan to go ahead with the restructure tomorrow morning.”12. Following this conversation, the local management team commenced making preparations to notify employees of the decision to implement a restructure. 13. At 2.19 am on Friday 22 March 2013, Mr Frankcombe and local management received an email from Mr Flynn conveying his approval of the proposal. 14. It was at this point that Whitehaven made the final and definite decision that it intended to implement major workplace change.The Enterprise Agreements15. At all relevant times:A. the Mine Operators at Rocglen Mine were covered by the Whitehaven Open Cut Operations (Production) Collective Agreement 2009 (the Rocglen Agreement). A copy of this agreement is attached and marked ‘A’; B. the Mine Operators at Tarrawonga were covered by the Whitehaven Open Cut Operations (Tarrawonga) Enterprise Agreement 2010 (the Tarrawonga Agreement). A copy of this agreements is attached and marked ‘B’; andC. Maintenance employees were covered by the Whitehaven Open Cut Operations (Maintenance) Employee Collective Agreement 2009 (the Maintenance Agreement). A copy of this agreement is attached and marked ‘C’.16. The Rocglen and Maintenance Agreements contained obligations upon Whitehaven to notify employees of a “definite decision” to introduce major workplace change. Specifically, clause 28 of both the Rocglen and Maintenance Agreements required Whitehaven to notify affected employees when it made a “definite decision” to introduce major workplace change but did not require any consultation regarding such change. These Agreements did not impose any positive obligation upon Whitehaven to consult with affected employees prior to the making of a “definite decision”. 17. The notification and consultation obligations of the Tarrawonga Agreement were different. Clause 26 of the Tarrawonga Agreement required Whitehaven to notify employees once a decision had been made and to consult with employees as to the nature of the changes. It provided:‘If Whitehaven makes a decision that it intends to implement any major workplace change which is likely to have a significant effect on Employees, it will notify Employees and consult with them as to the nature of the change and the likely consequences for affected Employees.Employees may seek to be and be represented during this consultation.Whitehaven will promptly consider the views expressed by Employees or their representatives as part of this consultation process about the planned change.This consultation process will not give cause for any delay to the implementation of the change, which may be implemented by Whitehaven as soon as practicable after notification of the change….’18. Whitehaven interpreted clause 26 of the Tarrawonga Agreement, and understood it to mean, that Whitehaven was obliged to notify affected employees once a “definite decision” had been made regarding the restructure but that its obligation to consult did not in any way prevent the implementation of this restructure. In other words, Whitehaven considered that it was entitled to notify employees once a definite decision had been made to implement the redundancies and to consult with employees after that decision had been made if, as Whitehaven believed, it was imperative to implement the restructure as soon as possible. Events of 22 March 201319. At or about 7:30 am on the morning of Friday 22 March 2013 local management addressed all day shift employees. They informed employees that Whitehaven had experienced significant financial losses as a result of a high Australian dollar and a low coal price Whitehaven needed to reduce its costs and intended to do this by changing the mine plans and reducing equipment and personnel needs. 20. On the morning of 22 March 2013, the CFMEU were also notified via email and telephone of the restructure and its immediate implementation.21. Following this notification, local management then spoke individually with all day shift employees, including the Mine Operators at Tarrawonga, to advise if their position had been made redundant.22. At 4.30 pm on 22 March 2013, local management informed all night shift employees of the Restructure in the same terms as set out in paragraph 18 above. Following this notification, local management spoke individually with all night shift employees, including Mine Operators at Tarrawonga, to advise if their position had been made redundant.23. The employees whose positions were made redundant were paid in lieu of the required notice period and left site on 22 March 2014. Whitehaven arranged for an employment consultant to assist such employees to find future employment and agreed to provide a letter detailing the employee’s training and experience if requested. 24. Between 22 and 26 March 2013, local management then undertook further discussions with the CFMEU where it considered and responded to issues raised by the CFMEU.25. The CFMEU has not disputed that there were a genuine economic need for the redundancies, but sought compensation for the affected employees in respect of the failure to adequately consult. 26. Whitehaven has paid to each affected redundant employee all entitlements owing to them. In addition, Whitehaven has settled the claims which the CFMEU commenced on behalf of some affected employees by paying a confidential monetary settlement to each of them. 27. By its admission of liability in the present proceedings, Whitehaven accepts that there was no opportunity given to the 14 employees covered by the Tarrawonga Agreement and the CFMEU to discuss the proposed changes to the mine plan, including the restructure and resulting redundancies, with them prior to the restructure being implemented.Failure to Notify the CEO of Centrelink28. At least 26 employees were made redundant by Whitehaven on 22 March 2013. 29. Whitehaven did not notify the Chief Executive Officer of the Commonwealth Services Delivery Agency (Centrelink) that it intended to dismiss more than 15 employees before doing so on 22 March 2014. 30. Whitehaven did not notify Centrelink because it was unaware of the requirement to do so.31. Whitehaven is unaware of any loss suffered as a result of its failure to notify Centrelink. No previous contraventions32. Whitehaven has not previously engaged in conduct in contravention of sections 50 or 530 of the Fair Work Act 2009 or any other workplace relations legislation.Entitlements and Compensation paid to employees33. As noted above, all employees whose positions were made redundant were paid severance pay in accordance with the terms of their relevant enterprise agreement. 34. Further, as noted above, all employees listed in paragraph 6 of the Further Amended Statement of Claim were paid an additional amount of compensation as part of a confidential settlement arrangement between the CFMEU and Whitehaven.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.