Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 125

File number: QUD 174 of 2017
Judge: RANGIAH J
Date of judgment: 23 February 2018
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – where employees’ salaries were reduced following reduction in shift lengths – finding that employees were underpaid – finding that employer contravened enterprise agreement
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 50

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 16.07(2)

Cases cited:

Amcor Limited v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 222 CLR 241

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1294

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 149

Kucks v CSR Limited (1996) 66 IR 182

Date of hearing: 27 October 2017
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 56
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr CA Massy
Solicitor for the Applicant: Hall Payne Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr I Neil SC with Ms J Alderson
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ashurst Australia

ORDERS

QUD 174 of 2017
BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

Applicant

AND:

HAIL CREEK COAL PTY LTD

Respondent

JUDGE:

RANGIAH J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 FEBRUARY 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.On or before 4.30 pm on Thursday, 8 March 2018, the applicant is to file and serve its submissions on penalty and any supporting evidence.

2.On or before 4.30 pm on Wednesday, 21 March 2018, the respondent is to file and serve its submissions on penalty and any supporting evidence.

3.On or before 4.30 pm on Friday, 23 March 2018, the applicant is to file and serve its reply (if any).

4.On or before Friday 23 March 2018, the parties are to confer and attempt to reach agreement regarding the proposed orders for compensation and declaratory relief.

5.On or before 4.30 pm on Friday 23 March 2018, if unable to reach agreement on the proposed orders for compensation and declaratory relief, the parties are to file and serve their submissions and any supporting evidence in relation to those matters.

6.The matter is listed for hearing in Brisbane for half a day commencing at 10.15 am on Monday 26 March 2018.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

RANGIAH J:

  1. In this proceeding, the applicant claims that the respondent (the Employer) contravened s 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FWA) by failing to pay a number of employees the full salary payable under an enterprise agreement known as the Hail Creek Agreement 2011 (the Enterprise Agreement). 

  2. More particularly, the applicant alleges that the Employer has failed to pay the employees the full amounts of “Roster Allowance” payable under Item 4 of Annexure 1 of the Enterprise Agreement.  The Employer contends that it has paid all that it is required to pay. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hail Creek... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd was heard before the Fair Work Commission and concerns whether the Employer was entitled to reduce the salaries of certain employees following a reduction in their shift lengths. The Employer operates an open-cut coal mine in central Queensland and operates 24 hours a day, seven days a week, necessitating day and night shifts. The Enterprise Agreement between the Employer and the applicant, which was approved by the Fair Work Commission in 2011, applies to the Employer and certain employees based at the mine site who work in operator and maintainer roles. Some operators and maintainers are rostered to work day shifts. Others are rostered to work a combination of day and night shifts. On 21 September 2015, the Employer implemented changes to the roster patterns for some maintainers and operators by reducing the lengths of their shifts from 12.5 hours to 12 hours. The rostered finishing time for their day shifts was changed from 7 pm to 6.30 pm, and for night shifts from 7 am to 6.30 am. The Employer then reduced the amount of Roster Allowance paid to the Affected Employees. The case concerns whether or not the Enterprise Agreement allowed the Employer to reduce the amount of Roster Allowance when it reduced the shift lengths.

The key legal issues in the case were whether the Enterprise Agreement allowed the Employer to reduce the amount of Roster Allowance when it reduced the shift lengths and whether the Employer contravened the Enterprise Agreement by doing so. The court considered the language of the Enterprise Agreement, the context in which it was made, and the purpose of the agreement in determining whether the Employer was entitled to reduce the salaries of certain employees following a reduction in their shift lengths. The court also considered whether the Employer had breached the Enterprise Agreement by reducing the salaries of certain employees following a reduction in their shift lengths. The court found that the Employer had contravened the Enterprise Agreement by reducing the salaries of certain employees following a reduction in their shift lengths. The court found that the Employer was not entitled to reduce the salaries of certain employees following a reduction in their shift lengths.

The court's reasoning was that the Enterprise Agreement allowed the Employer to change its roster systems for operational reasons, but it envisaged that such systemic change would be infrequent, since consultation was required. Further, under cl 10.1, employees may be required to change between the type of shifts or shift rosters they work. The amount of Roster Allowance changes with changes in shift rosters. The Enterprise Agreement emphasises that the hours the employees are required to work are not fixed. Clause 10.2, which has the heading “Indicative Hours”, states that “an employee’s Total Salary represents payment for the performance of their role, not for the hours attending work”. Clause 10.2 also states that “indicative” numbers of hours to be worked by a full-time employee are contained in the “roster descriptions” in Annexure 1. Clause 10.2 goes on to say that Total Salary has been determined on the basis that an employee may need to work reasonable hours in addition to the hours indicated in Annexure 1 in order to perform their role. Item 2 of Annexure 1 indicates that an employee’s Role Base Salary includes compensation for additional hours that are worked during employment. The court found that the Employer had contravened the Enterprise Agreement by reducing the salaries of certain employees following a reduction in their shift lengths.

The orders made by the court were that the applicant is to file and serve its submissions on penalty and any supporting evidence on or before 4.30 pm on Thursday, 8 March 2018. The respondent is to file and serve its submissions on penalty and any supporting evidence on or before 4.30 pm on Wednesday, 21 March 2018. The applicant is to file and serve its reply (if any) on or before 4.30 pm on Friday, 23 March 2018. The parties are to confer and attempt to reach agreement regarding the proposed orders for compensation and declaratory relief on or before Friday 23 March 2018. If unable to reach agreement on the proposed orders for compensation and declaratory relief, the parties are to file and serve their submissions and any supporting evidence in relation to those matters on or before Friday 23 March 2018. The matter is listed for hearing in Brisbane for half a day commencing at 10.15 am on Monday 26 March 2018.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 4.30 pm on Thursday, 8 March 2018, the applicant is to file and serve its submissions on penalty and any supporting evidence.

2. On or before 4.30 pm on Wednesday, 21 March 2018, the respondent is to file and serve its submissions on penalty and any supporting evidence.

3. On or before 4.30 pm on Friday, 23 March 2018, the applicant is to file and serve its reply (if any).

4. On or before Friday 23 March 2018, the parties are to confer and attempt to reach agreement regarding the proposed orders for compensation and declaratory relief.

5. On or before 4.30 pm on Friday 23 March 2018, if unable to reach agreement on the proposed orders for compensation and declaratory relief, the parties are to file and serve their submissions and any supporting evidence in relation to those matters.

6. The matter is listed for hearing in Brisbane for half a day commencing at 10.15 am on Monday 26 March 2018.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I will describe the facts of the case and the relevant legislation before considering the parties’ competing submissions. The facts The facts of the case fall to be determined from a Statement of Agreed Facts and admissions made in the Amended Defence. The parties do not rely on affidavits or other evidence to establish any other facts. The Employer operates an open-cut coal mine in central Queensland known as the “Hail Creek Mine”. The Employer may carry on operations at the mine 24 hours per day, seven days per week. This requires that a day shift and a night shift be worked each day. The applicant and the Employer are parties to the Enterprise Agreement, which was approved by the Fair Work Commission in 2011. The Enterprise Agreement was considered by the Full Court in Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 149 in the context of a dispute about sick leave, but that case is not relevant to the present issue. The Enterprise Agreement applies to and covers the Employer and those of its employees based at the mine site who work in operator and maintainer roles. Some operators and maintainers are rostered to work day shifts. Others are rostered to work a combination of day and night shifts. On 21 September 2015, the Employer implemented changes to the roster patterns for some maintainers and operators by reducing the lengths of their shifts from 12.5 hours to 12 hours. The rostered finishing time for their day shifts was changed from 7 pm to 6.30 pm, and for night shifts from 7 am to 6.30 am. The Statement of Agreed Facts identifies 20 employees (the Affected Employees) whose roster patterns were affected by the changes. The Employer then reduced the amount of Roster Allowance paid to the Affected Employees. For one group, the amount of Roster Allowance was reduced by $4,500 per annum and for another group the amount was reduced by $4,200 per annum. The case concerns whether or not the Enterprise Agreement allowed the Employer to reduce the amount of Roster Allowance when it reduced the shift lengths. Clause 7.1 of the Enterprise Agreement provides:7.1 Full-time and Fixed Term EmployeesFull-time and fixed term Employees will be paid an annualised salary that includes provision for all ordinary hours averaged over a roster cycle, overtime penalties, loadings and all other payments or allowances (Total Salary).The Total Salary is comprised of a Role Base Salary, a Market Allowance, a Commute Allowance and a Roster Allowance where applicable. Annexure 1 sets out the salary structure.... Clause 7.6 of the Enterprise Agreement provides:7.6 Method of PaymentAn Employee’s Total Salary following adjustment if required for a salary sacrificing arrangement, will be paid monthly into bank accounts of the Employee’s choice.... Clause 10.1 of the Enterprise Agreement provides:10.1 RostersEmployees will be required to work the hours that are reasonably necessary to perform their role. Employees may be required to work shifts of up to 12 1/2 hours duration.Hail Creek may carry out its operations 24 hours per day, 7 days per week. Hail Creek will implement and change roster systems to meet the needs of the operation and in consideration of the health and safety needs of Employees. Prior to the introduction of any new roster system, Hail Creek will consult with the Employees directly affected, as far as is practicable, and will give prompt consideration to the matters raised by the Employees.Employees may be required to perform a handover for communication and work continuity. Recognition for this requirement is included in the Employee’s Total Salary.Employees may be required to change between day shift, shift work, shift work and day work or from one form of shift or shift roster to another.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Employer points out that in cl 10.2 of the Enterprise Agreement there is a reference to an indicative number of hours to be worked by a full time employee being contained “in the roster descriptions in Annexure 1”. It contends that each roster is described by reference to two features, namely the pattern of work and the indicative number of hours. The Employer submits that by describing each roster by reference to, not just the pattern, but also the hours, the hours form part of the description. It submits, that, accordingly, when the number of hours to be worked under a roster is reduced below the indicative hours in the Table, it no longer answers the description of the relevant item in the Table.Consideration The construction of an industrial instrument is a text based activity, but the industrial context is also important: Amcor Limited v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 222 CLR 241 at [2], [65]-[67], [77]. In Kucks v CSR Limited (1996) 66 IR 182, Madgwick J discussed the relevance of the industrial context at 184:It is trite that narrow or pedantic approaches to the interpretation of an award are misplaced. The search is for the meaning intended by the framer(s) of the document, bearing in mind that such framer(s) were likely of a practical bent of mind: they may well have been more concerned with expressing an intention in ways likely to have been understood in the context of the relevant industry and industrial relations environment than with legal niceties or jargon. Thus, for example, it is justifiable to read the award to give effect to its evident purposes, having regard to such context, despite mere inconsistencies or infelicities of expression which might tend to some other reading. And meanings which avoid inconvenience or injustice may reasonably be strained for. For reasons such as these, expressions which have been held in the case of other instruments to have been used to mean particular things may sensibly and properly be held to mean something else in the document at hand. Before turning directly to the question of construction of Item 4 of Annexure 1 of the Enterprise Agreement, it is necessary to emphasise some matters of context. Under cl 7.1 of the Enterprise Agreement, the Total Salary payable to maintainers and operators consists of four components. Three of those components (Role Base Salary, Market Allowance and Commute Allowance) are fixed amounts. The only component susceptible to change is Roster Allowance. Clause 10.1 allows the Employer to change its roster systems for operational reasons, although it envisages that such systemic change will be infrequent, since consultation is required. Further, under cl 10.1, employees may be required to change between the type of shifts or shift rosters they work. The amount of Roster Allowance changes with changes in shift rosters. The Enterprise Agreement emphasises that the hours the employees are required to work are not fixed. Clause 10.1 provides that employees will be required to work the hours that are reasonably necessary to perform their roles. Clause 10.2, which has the heading “Indicative Hours”, states that “an employee’s Total Salary represents payment for the performance of their role, not for the hours attending work”. Clause 10.2 also states that “indicative” numbers of hours to be worked by a full time employee are contained in the “roster descriptions” in Annexure 1. Clause 10.2 goes on to say that Total Salary has been determined on the basis that an employee may need to work reasonable hours in addition to the hours indicated in Annexure 1 in order to perform their role. Item 2 of Annexure 1 indicates that an employee’s Role Base Salary includes compensation for additional hours that are worked during employment.