Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 522

Citation: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 522
Parties: CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION v ANGLO COAL (DAWSON SERVICES) PTY LTD
File number: QUD 198 of 2014
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 23 May 2014
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – interlocutory application seeking reinstatement of employee miner – employee applicant union’s lodge president at the mine – employee terminated for taking sick leave after annual leave application rejected – alleged contraventions of Part 3-1 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – principles in Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57 – concession by respondent that aspects of applicant’s case raised serious questions for determination – proposed undertaking by respondent to provide pay and benefits without work in lieu of reinstatement until substantive hearing - whether balance of convenience favours reinstatement pending determination of substantive hearing – whether social and psychological benefits of work – strength of applicant’s case for final relief – whether tendency for reinstatement to undermine discipline at workplace – whether evidence of breakdown of confidence and trust – alleged inconvenience to applicant in relation to employee’s discharge of union duties – balance of convenience favours interlocutory order for reinstatement
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Pt 3-1 ss 340, 346, 352 and 545
Cases cited: Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57 applied
Australian Postal Corporation v Stephens [2011] FCA 947 cited
Automotive, Foods, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Eaton Electrical Systems Pty Ltd (2005) 139 IR 260 cited
Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union known as The Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v McCain Foods (Aust) Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1126 cited
Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Phillips Engineering Aus Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 611 cited
Blackadder v Ramsey Butchering Services Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 539 cited
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 971 cited
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BPH Coal Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 1218 cited
National Tertiary Education Union v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2013] FCA 451 cited
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Inc (2011) 286 ALR 257; [2011] FCAFC 156 cited
Date of hearing: 20 May 2014
Place: Brisbane
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 31
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms EP White
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr CA Massy of Hall Payne
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr I Neil SC
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ms S Chapman of Ashurst Australia

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

QUD 198 of 2014

BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION
Applicant

AND:

ANGLO COAL (DAWSON SERVICES) PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 MAY 2014

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

SUBJECT TO THE USUAL UNDERTAKINGS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd involved an interlocutory application seeking the reinstatement of an employee miner, Mr Stephen Byrne, who was terminated for taking sick leave after his application for annual leave was rejected. The applicant union, Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, argued that the termination was a contravention of Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The court had to decide whether the balance of convenience favoured the reinstatement of the applicant pending the determination of the substantive hearing. The court also considered the social and psychological benefits of work, the strength of the applicant's case for final relief, and whether reinstatement would undermine discipline at the workplace.

The court found that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of interlocutory relief sought by the applicant. The evidence before the Court was supportive of the applicant's submissions concerning the social and psychological benefits of work to Mr Byrne. The court noted that employment has a greater significance beyond a means of gaining income, and it provides a social context for daily activity and can provide satisfaction and stimulation. The court also found that the proposed undertaking by the respondent to provide pay and benefits without work in lieu of reinstatement until the substantive hearing would avoid any financial hardship to Mr Byrne.

The court ordered that until the hearing and determination of this application, or further order, the Respondent reinstate Stephen Byrne to his former employment on the same terms and conditions that applied prior to 12 May 2014. The entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Until the hearing and determination of this application, or further order, the Respondent reinstate Stephen Byrne to his former employment on the same terms and conditions that applied prior to 12 May 2014.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Both parties have filed a number of affidavits in this proceeding. The evidence filed on behalf of the applicant is extensive compared with that filed on behalf of the respondent. Although the respondent has filed three affidavits (two sworn by Ms Rebecca Taumalolo, an employee relations specialist employed by the respondent, and one sworn by Ms Shannon Chapman, a solicitor acting on behalf of the respondent), it does not appear to be in dispute that the affidavits of Ms Taumalolo did not go to the questions before the Court in relation to the interlocutory application (T, 20 May 2014, p 3, ls 9-29).Evidence filed by the applicant The applicant has filed three affidavits upon which it relies in this proceeding. They are:·the affidavit of Mr Graeme Thompson, an employee of the respondent, sworn 14 May 2014;·the affidavit of Mr Stephen Byrne sworn 14 May 2014; and·the affidavit of Dr Vahid Farahmand sworn 14 May 2014.Affidavit of Graeme Thompson In his affidavit sworn 14 May 2014 Mr Thompson deposes, in summary, as follows:·He is a colleague of Mr Byrne at the mine and an employee of the respondent.·He is a member of the applicant union.·As part of his employment at the mine he was directed to attend a meeting with the respondent on 22 April 2014. He appointed Mr Byrne as his representative and support person for that meeting, which he and Mr Byrne attended together.·The meeting was attended by Ms Amanda Baker (the respondent's Human Resources Manager for the mine) and a representative of the respondent known as "Hutchie".·For the first 20 or 30 minutes of the meeting Mr Byrne was coughing, sniffling, wheezing and appeared sick.·Towards the end of the meeting, after about 20 or 30 minutes of discussion, Ms Baker told Mr Byrne that he was ill and should go home. Mr Byrne said that he could complete the balance of his shift but could not work the following night shift.·Ms Baker advised Mr Byrne to seek medical advice as he appeared ill.·Mr Byrne completed office duties for the balance of his shift.·Mr Byrne did not attend the night shift he was next rostered to work.Affidavit of Stephen Byrne In his affidavit sworn 14 May 2014 Mr Byrne deposes (in summary) that:·he commenced employment with the respondent at the mine on 1 August 2011;·he is a member of the applicant union;·in May 2012 he became a shift delegate for his crew;·in November 2012 he was elected to the position of Lodge President at the mine;·between April 2013 and November 2013 enterprise agreement negotiations took place between the respondent, the applicant union, the Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union (AMWU) and the Electrical Trades Union (ETU) for a replacement enterprise agreement. He and Mr Glenn Power led the negotiations on behalf of the CFMEU;·shortly after a proposed agreement was voted down by union members, the applicant union and other unions applied for a Protected Action Ballot. The Fair Work Commission made an order that a Protected Action Ballot be conducted;·Union members voted in favour of taking protected industrial action;·shortly after employees at the mine took protected action in the form of a 12 hour "stop work" the respondent put a revised offer to the union negotiators. The proposed agreement was narrowly approved by the workforce;·he suffers from severe asthma and has advised the respondent, through its various representatives, on numerous occasions, of his medical condition;·on 20 April 2013, while at his home, he decided to clean his oven using a cleaner containing caustic soda. Whilst cleaning he began having difficulty breathing, and felt unwell;·for some time after he had finished cleaning the oven he did not feel well and had difficulty breathing. He was unable to sleep throughout the evening due to difficulty breathing. In the early hours of 21 April 2013 his wife called an ambulance to take him to hospital. While in the ambulance on the way to the Rockhampton hospital the ambulance officers twice provided him with adrenalin to assist him to breathe;·he was in the intensive care unit at Rockhampton hospital for three days, and then remained in hospital until 27 April 2013;·while in hospital his wife contacted his then supervisor Mr Ben O'Donnell and later Mr Troy Deeth. His wife advised the respondent of what had happened to him and that he expected to be in hospital and absent from work for some period. His wife also made an application for annual leave for the period in which he was absent. The application was granted;·at the mine it is not uncommon for employees who are unwell to apply for annual leave rather than taking sick leave. This is because each year the respondent company allows workers to cash out their untaken sick leave. Employees are not permitted to cash out their untaken annual leave;·he is also aware that unplanned absenteeism is a performance metric which is measured by the company. As a consequence he and his colleagues endeavour to take annual leave when sick so as to improve the rates of unplanned absenteeism;·in the week commencing 21 April 2014 his shifts were as follows:oMonday 21 April - day shift.oTuesday 22 April - day shift.oWednesday 23 April - "pyjama day" (shift change day).oThursday 24 April - night shift (commencing 6.45 pm on 23 April).oFriday 25 April - night shift (commencing at 6.45 pm on 24 April).·On Monday 21 April 2014 he was suffering the symptoms of a head cold. He had been suffering these symptoms for several days without improvement. He became concerned about the night shifts for which he was rostered on the Thursday and Friday of that week as the weather was cold at the time. Typically, cold night air can exacerbate his head colds and asthma because the head cold had started to "turn into a chest cold", causing him to cough. He therefore decided to approach his supervisor Mr Gavin Horn.·He advised his supervisor that he was not feeling well and that he did not think it was a good idea to work the two night shifts. He then asked his supervisor if it would be possible to tale annual leave on those two nights. Later in the shift the supervisor returned to him and advised that his request for annual leave had been refused.·At the start of his shift on 22 April 2014, he approached the superintendent Mr Andrew Lawn and asked for a reason why his annual leave request was refused. A conversation took place between he and Mr Lawn about the leave quota. He explained that the annual leave was sought due to his feeling ill, to which Mr Lawn advised that there would be ramifications for not coming in.·Over the course of the shift he began to feel more ill.·At 3 pm he had a meeting with Ms Amanda Baker, the Human Resources Manager, and Mr Graeme Thompson. During the course of the meeting Ms Baker stated that he did not look well and asked if he was all right. Mr Byrne stated that he was not feeling well, had a head cold that he could not shake, and thought he would need Thursday and Friday of that week off as he was concerned about working a night shift and did not want a repeat of the events of April 2013.·Ms Baker advised that he should go home. Mr Byrne stated that he would finish that shift.·At about midday on 23 April 2014 he left the camp to return to his home in Gracemere, approximately two and a half hours from the mine. He attended upon Dr Farahmand at about 3 pm on that day. Dr Farahmand advised that he should not attend work on Thursday and Friday evening, and prescribed some antibiotics for him to take. Dr Farahmand also issued him with a certificate certifying that he was unfit for duty on Thursday and Friday of that week.·At about 4.45 pm he telephoned his supervisor Mr Gurney and advised he was unfit and would not be attending work for the night shifts on Thursday and Friday of that week.·Shortly after this time he became concerned that the wording of the medical certificate made it appear as though he would never be fit for work again. He sent a text message to Ms Baker to advise that he was unwell and would not be attending work. During the text message exchange, he raised his concern about the medical certificate and Ms Baker confirmed it should be corrected.·On 24 April 2014 and 25 April 2014 he stayed at home and did not attend work.·On Tuesday 29 April 2014 he attended upon Dr Farahmand again to see whether he would be fit for his next shift on 30 April 2014. Dr Farahmand examined him and determined that he was fit to return to work. Because of his concerns with the initial medical certificate he requested that that Dr Farahmand provide him with a medical certificate stating that he was fit to return to work. Dr Farahmand did this.·On Wednesday 30 April 2014 he returned to work as rostered and participated in a return to work interview with his supervisor, Mr Russell Gurney. He provided Mr Gurney with a copy of his medical certificates and advised him that he was now feeling better. Mr Gurney directed him to return to work as per normal.·At approximately 2 pm on Wednesday 22 April 2014 he was advised to attend a meeting with Mr Lawn and Ms Kaitlyn Britton, the Human Resources Officer. (It is not clear to me whether Mr Byrne actually means Wednesday 30 April 2014) Mr Lawn stated that it was an issue that he took sick leave after his application for annual leave was refused. Mr Lawn handed him a letter advising that he had been stood down on full pay pending an investigation.·He then left the mine in accordance with the letter.·On 1 May 2014 he was required to attend a further meeting with Mr Lawn. He attended this meeting with the Lodge Secretary, Mr Heath Timmins.·At the commencement of the meeting Mr Lawn handed him a piece of correspondence from the respondent under the hand of Mr Aaron Puna, the General Manager. The correspondence advised that the respondent considered that he had engaged in misconduct and asked him to show cause as to why disciplinary action should not be taken against him.·The correspondent sought a response by 5 May 2014. A return date of 9 May 2014 was subsequently agreed.·On 9 May 2014 he attended a meeting with Mr Tony Power, the mine Operations Manager, and Ms Baker. Mr Heath Timmins attended as his representative.·Mr Power advised that the purpose of the meeting was for him to provide a response to the show cause correspondence.·He (Mr Byrne) read out a response and provided Mr Power and Ms Baker with a copy.·After he had provided the response, Ms Baker advised that she did not agree with specific parts of his response but did not specify which parts. After stating that Ms Baker saw him on Tuesday and knew he was sick, Ms Baker stated that she did not know he had previously applied for annual leave.·On 12 May 2014 he was required to attend a meeting with Mr Power, Ms Lead Brosnan and Ms Kaitlin Britton.·Mr Power advised that the respondent had decided to terminate his employment and provided correspondence to that effect.·He is married with two children aged 10 and 13.·He is the sole source of income for his family apart from a carer's allowance that his wife receives each fortnight from Centrelink of $118. This is due to the fact his 13-year old son is a special needs child and his wife is therefore required to care for him and is unable to work.·He has a number of debts which require repayments of $1,100 per week, being:otwo car loans - total debt of approximately $100,000;oa home loan - total debt of approximately $298,000; andoa credit card - total debt of approximately $20,000.·He is also responsible for his family's household expenses on a weekly basis including groceries, petrol, power bills and recreational expenses.·If he does not regain employment with the respondent he will be unable to support his family in the ways set out above.·He has worked in the coal mining industry in Queensland since 1993 and considers himself a career coal miner. If he is not able to resume his vocation soon he is concerned he will not be able to obtain other work elsewhere because he is not qualified for any other work.·He would miss the camaraderie of working at the mine.·The 326 members of the Moura Lodge who work at the Dawson mine are supported and represented by himself as President, Heath Timmins as Lodge Secretary and two others who are each Lodge Vice Presidents. He is the only representative from D crew.·He cannot perform his role as Lodge President or as the applicant's delegate for D crew unless he is employed at the mine.·If he is not reinstated it would make it very difficult for the Lodge to adequately represent that applicant's members at the mine. This is particularly so because it is difficult for the applicant to attract and retain Lodge Officials for fear of retribution from the respondent.Affidavit of Dr Vahid Farahmand

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In opposing any order for reinstatement of Mr Byrne, Mr Neil SC for the respondent submitted, in summary, as follows:·There is evidence before the Court as to the reason for Mr Byrne's termination, namely the letter annexed to the affidavit of Ms Taumalolo.·In the ordinary course, Mr Byrne's reinstatement, following upon his dismissal on the ground of misconduct, would naturally have a tendency to undermine discipline at the mine by reference to the capacity of the respondent to enforce its own rules and its conception of the conduct that it requires of its employees.·Dismissal of Mr Byrne for misconduct must necessarily have damaged, if not severed, the relationship of trust and confidence between the respondent as employer and Mr Byrne as employee.·Any financial hardship to Mr Byrne pending final determination of the substantive application would be avoided by payment of equivalent salary and benefits by the respondent to him pursuant to the undertaking the respondent has offered in lieu of reinstatement.·Although Mr Byrne holds the office of the applicant's lodge President at the mine, there was no impediment to him continuing to hold that position if he were not reinstated. Further there were other elected union officers who could discharge union duties at the mine.·To the extent that there was an inconvenience to the applicant in respect of Mr Byrne's position as the only union delegate in D crew should he not be reinstated, the respondent was prepared to transfer another union delegate to D crew.·Mr Byrne's desire to enjoy the social environment provided by his workplace is a relevant, but not decisive, factor.·As it is likely that a trial of the substantive proceedings could take place at the end of July 2014, Mr Byrne would be out of the workplace for only approximately 10 weeks leading up to trial. This would be only minimally disruptive of any social benefits he receives from the workplace.·Even if the Court were minded to reinstate Mr Byrne, it could only be to a position no less favourable than that in which he was employed prior to the termination of his employment. The respondent is empowered by the Dawson Mines Collective Enterprise Agreement 2014 to stand down employees, including Mr Byrne. More relevantly, it is entitled to direct Mr Byrne not to attend work, and it has already put Mr Byrne on notice that it would so direct him if he were reinstated.·If there was a likelihood of judgment in the substantive matter being reserved there is no reason the applicant could not either renew the present application for interlocutory relief or make a fresh application at the trial.Consideration In this case I am persuaded that the balance of convenience favours the grant of the interlocutory relief sought by the applicant. I have formed this view for the following reasons. First, the evidence before the Court is supportive of the applicant's submissions concerning the social and psychological benefits of his work to Mr Byrne (in particular paras 84 and 85 of his affidavit). As the applicant correctly submits, there is ample authority supporting the relevance of this evidence. I note for example the comment of Moore J in Automotive, Foods, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Eaton Electrical Systems Pty Ltd (2005) 139 IR 260 at 266:While important, employment is more than a means of gaining income. To varying degrees it has a greater significance. It provides a social context for daily activity and can provide satisfaction and stimulation.