Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 15  

Review of: Application by Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2019] FWCA 8471
File number(s): VID 427 of 2020
Judgment of: RANGIAH, O'CALLAGHAN AND WHEELAHAN JJ
Date of judgment: 16 February 2022
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – enterprise agreements – application for judicial review of a decision of the Fair Work Commission to approve an enterprise agreement – jurisdictional error – whether the enterprise agreement was genuinely agreed to – whether the explanation given to employees satisfied s 180(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) –where there was no evidence before the Commission that all differences between the enterprise agreement and the existing agreements had been explained to the employees – the Commission’s satisfaction that “all reasonable steps” had been taken to explain the terms of the enterprise agreement and their effect requires the Commission’s evaluative judgment – evaluation of evidence was a matter for the Commission – no jurisdictional error demonstrated.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – enterprise agreements – whether undertakings can be accepted under s 190 of the Fair Work Act to address concerns about pre-approval steps – construction of s 190 – undertakings can so be accepted to approve an enterprise agreement – no jurisdictional error demonstrated.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 172, 173, 173-178B, 179, 180(5), 180(5)(a) and (b), 185, 186, 186(1), 186(2)(a), 187, 188(1), 188(1)(a) and (b), 188(2), 190 and 190(2).

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 20(1A)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Explanatory Memorandum, Fair Work Bill 2009 (Cth)   

Cases cited:

ALDI Foods Pty Limited v Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees Association [2017] HCA 53; 262 CLR 593

Application by Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2019] FWCA 8471

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2016] FCAFC 169; 247 FCR 138

Buck v Bavone [1976] HCA 24; 135 CLR 110

CFMMEU v Karijini Rail Pty Ltd [2020] FWCFB 958

CFMMEU v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2020] FWCFB 1918

CFMMEU v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2019] FWCFB 3585

CFMMEU v Specialist People Pty Ltd [2019] FWCFB 7919

Coal Miners’ Industrial Union of Workers of Western Australia v Amalgamated Collieries of Western Australia [1960] HCA 68; 104 CLR 437

Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union v Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 148

Dafallah v Fair Work Commission [2014] FCA 328; 225 FCR 559

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu [1999] HCA 21; 197 CLR 611

One Key Workforce Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union [2018] FCAFC 77; 262 FCR 527

MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 17; (2021) 390 ALR 590

R v Australian Stevedoring Industry Board; Ex parte Melbourne Stevedoring Co Pty Ltd [1953] HCA 22; 88 CLR 100

R v Connell; Ex parte Hetton Bellbird Collieries Ltd [1944] HCA 42

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCAFC 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd, the applicants sought judicial review of a decision by the Fair Work Commission (FWC) to approve an enterprise agreement. The applicants argued that the FWC had erred in its decision, particularly in relation to whether the agreement was genuinely agreed to by the employees and whether the employer had explained the terms of the agreement appropriately. The employer, Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd, defended the FWC's decision, asserting that no jurisdictional errors had been made.

The primary legal issues centred on whether the FWC had correctly applied the statutory requirements for approving an enterprise agreement under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Specifically, the applicants contended that the FWC failed to consider all material and detrimental differences between the existing agreements and the new enterprise agreement, thus not satisfying the statutory requirements for genuine agreement under section 180(5) of the Act. Additionally, the applicants argued that the FWC incorrectly interpreted section 190 of the Act by permitting the acceptance of undertakings to address concerns about the pre-approval process. The employer maintained that the FWC's decision was correct and that the applicants had not demonstrated any jurisdictional error.

The court found in favour of the applicants. It held that the FWC’s satisfaction that "all reasonable steps" had been taken to explain the terms of the enterprise agreement and their effect required the FWC’s evaluative judgment, which the court found was not adequately supported by the evidence. The court found that the FWC’s approval of the enterprise agreement was based on an incomplete evaluation of the evidence, as there was no evidence that all differences between the existing agreements and the new enterprise agreement had been explained to the employees. Consequently, the court concluded that the FWC had erred in its decision, leading to the quashing of the FWC's approval and a requirement for the FWC to re-determine the application according to law.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I would grant the relief sought by the applicants.Factual background The employer provides maintenance services to power stations in the Latrobe Valley in Victoria. In 2018, the employer proposed to make a new enterprise agreement. At that time, there were five employees who would be covered by the proposed new agreement. The proposed new enterprise agreement was intended to replace two existing enterprise agreements, namely:·the Mechanical Maintenance Solutions P/L (MMS) Latrobe Valley Power Stations (AMWU and CFMEU) Greenfields Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 2012–2016 (the Greenfields Maintenance Agreement); and·the Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd (MMS) Latrobe Valley (Victoria) Power Industry and Electrical (ETU) Greenfields Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the Greenfields Electrical Agreement).(Collectively, the Existing Greenfields Agreements.) On 15 February 2018, the employer issued a notice of representational rights to the employees, and bargaining commenced for the proposed new agreement. The employer appointed a consultant, Ryan Murphy, to assist in the conduct of bargaining with the employees. The proposed new agreement was put to a vote on 4 May 2018, and four of the five employees voted to approve it. The New Enterprise Agreement was signed on 6 May 2018 by the managing director of the employer, and on 7 May 2018 by an employee representative. On 7 May 2018, the employer applied to the Commission for approval of the New Enterprise Agreement. The application stated that Mr Murphy had met with each of the five employees and explained the terms of their agreement and their effect. It indicated that Mr Murphy had explained each clause and answered questions that arose, and that each employee was provided with a copy of the agreement. The application stated that all the employees had sufficient literacy to understand the content and effect of the agreement. It is apparent that Mr Murphy gave the explanation verbally to each employee, but not in writing. On 14 December 2018, the Commission approved the New Enterprise Agreement. The first applicant sought permission to appeal. On appeal, the principal issue was that the employee who signed the New Enterprise Agreement had not been appointed in writing to act as a bargaining representative so that his authority to sign was unexplained. A Full Bench of the Commission quashed the decision of 14 December 2018 and remitted the application for re-determination: Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2019] FWCFB 3585. In the new hearing, Mr Murphy provided a statement dated 23 July 2019 elaborating upon the explanations of the New Enterprise Agreement he had provided to the employees. He stated that between 28 February and 4 May 2018, there were a number of discussions held with employees about the proposed agreement and that he was directly involved in some of those discussions. Mr Murphy stated that on 5 April 2018, he took the employees through a clause-by-clause analysis of the revised version of the proposed agreement. He continued:I also explained how the Agreement differed in any material or significant way to the: Greenfields Agreement; the Manufacturing Award; the CFMEU Yallourn Power Station and Open Cut Agreement – Victoria; the AMWU Yallourn Power Station and Open Cut Agreement – Victoria; and the Workshop Agreement…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 13 December 2019, the Commission made a decision approving the New Enterprise Agreement: see Application by Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2019] FWCA 8471 (the Approval Decision). The applicants have applied under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) for orders quashing the Approval Decision and requiring the Commission to determine the application for approval according to law. The applicants submit that the Commission fell into jurisdictional error in deciding that it was satisfied that the requirements of ss 186(2)(a), 188(1)(a) and 180(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act) were satisfied; and in construing s 190 of the Act as permitting the Commission to accept certain undertakings offered by the employer. The employer submits that no such errors have been demonstrated and, further, that relief should be refused for discretionary reasons. For the reasons that follow, I would grant the relief sought by the applicants.Factual background The employer provides maintenance services to power stations in the Latrobe Valley in Victoria. In 2018, the employer proposed to make a new enterprise agreement. At that time, there were five employees who would be covered by the proposed new agreement. The proposed new enterprise agreement was intended to replace two existing enterprise agreements, namely:·the Mechanical Maintenance Solutions P/L (MMS) Latrobe Valley Power Stations (AMWU and CFMEU) Greenfields Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 2012–2016 (the Greenfields Maintenance Agreement); and·the Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd (MMS) Latrobe Valley (Victoria) Power Industry and Electrical (ETU) Greenfields Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the Greenfields Electrical Agreement).(Collectively, the Existing Greenfields Agreements.) On 15 February 2018, the employer issued a notice of representational rights to the employees, and bargaining commenced for the proposed new agreement. The employer appointed a consultant, Ryan Murphy, to assist in the conduct of bargaining with the employees. The proposed new agreement was put to a vote on 4 May 2018, and four of the five employees voted to approve it. The New Enterprise Agreement was signed on 6 May 2018 by the managing director of the employer, and on 7 May 2018 by an employee representative. On 7 May 2018, the employer applied to the Commission for approval of the New Enterprise Agreement. The application stated that Mr Murphy had met with each of the five employees and explained the terms of their agreement and their effect. It indicated that Mr Murphy had explained each clause and answered questions that arose, and that each employee was provided with a copy of the agreement. The application stated that all the employees had sufficient literacy to understand the content and effect of the agreement. It is apparent that Mr Murphy gave the explanation verbally to each employee, but not in writing. On 14 December 2018, the Commission approved the New Enterprise Agreement. The first applicant sought permission to appeal. On appeal, the principal issue was that the employee who signed the New Enterprise Agreement had not been appointed in writing to act as a bargaining representative so that his authority to sign was unexplained. A Full Bench of the Commission quashed the decision of 14 December 2018 and remitted the application for re-determination: Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Mechanical Maintenance Solutions Pty Ltd [2019] FWCFB 3585.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The employer submits that s 190 of the Act cannot be construed such that undertakings cannot remedy concerns about the pre-approval process. The employer submits that there is no warrant for reading such a limitation into the provision.ConsiderationWhether the Commission erred in failing to consider all material, detrimental differences between the Existing Greenfields Agreements and the New Enterprise Agreement Section 186(1) provides, relevantly, that if an application for approval of an enterprise agreement is made under s 185, the Commission must approve the agreement if the requirements set out in ss 186 and 187 are met. The corollary is that the Commission must not approve an agreement if those requirements are not met, except in a case where the Commission accepts an undertaking under s 190. Section 186(2) requires that the Commission must be satisfied, relevantly, that an enterprise agreement has been “genuinely agreed to” by the employees covered by the agreement. Section 188(1)(a) provides that an enterprise agreement has been “genuinely agreed to” if the Commission is satisfied that the employer covered by the agreement complied with a number of provisions including, relevantly, s 180(5). Section 180(5) requires that, before requesting that the relevant employees approve an enterprise agreement:(5) The employer must take all reasonable steps to ensure that:(a)the terms of the agreement, and the effect of those terms, are explained to the relevant employees; and(b)the explanation is provided in an appropriate manner taking into account the particular circumstances and needs of the relevant employees. Accordingly, the Commission cannot (subject to ss 188(2) and 190) approve an enterprise agreement unless it is satisfied that the employer took all reasonable steps to ensure that the terms, and the effect of those terms, were explained to the relevant employees; and that the explanation was provided in an appropriate manner taking into account the particular circumstances and needs of those employees. The applicants argue that the Commission could not, as a matter of law, have been satisfied that the employer took all reasonable steps to ensure that the effect of the terms of the New Enterprise Agreement were explained to the relevant employees without considering whether “the full extent of the differences” between the Existing Greenfields Agreements and the New Enterprise Agreement were explained. The applicants’ counsel clarified in oral argument that the only differences relied upon are those that were material and detrimental to the employees. The Commission found that Mr Murphy (the consultant engaged by the employer) had explained some of the differences between the Existing Greenfields Agreements and the New Enterprise Agreement to the employees. What is in issue is whether the Commission was required, but failed, to consider whether the employer had taken all reasonable steps to ensure that all the differences that were material and detrimental were explained.