Construction Forestry Maritime Mining and Energy Union v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction Forestry Maritime Mining and Energy Union v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1376

File number: VID 429 of 2019
Judge: O’CALLAGHAN  J
Date of judgment: 26 August 2019
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory application seeking order requiring production of a document – whether document “mentioned” in pleadings – application dismissed
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 20.31
Cases cited:

Apotex Pty Ltd v ICOS Corporation (No 2) [2017] FCA 589

Dubai Bank Ltd v Galadari (No 2) [1990] 1 WLR 731

King v GIO Holdings Ltd [2001] FCA 1487

Mann v Board of Health (Australian Capital Territory) (1996) 67 FCR 383

Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 10) [2016] FCA 970

Rubin v Expandable [2008] 1 WLR 1099

Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 1630

Turner v Bulletin Newspaper Co. Pty Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 69

Date of hearing: On the papers
Date of last submissions: 8 August 2019
Registry: Victoria
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 25
Counsel for the Applicant: P Boncardo
Solicitor for the Applicant: Gordon Legal
Counsel for the Tenth, Eleventh and Twelfth Respondents: R P P Dalton QC and R W Sweet
Solicitor for the Tenth, Eleventh and Twelfth Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

VID 429 of 2019
BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MARITIME, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

Applicant

AND:

MCCONNELL DOWELL CONSTRUCTORS (AUST) PTY LTD

First Respondent

DAVID SPACKMAN

Second Respondent

ALEKS NEVSKI (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

O’CALLAGHAN  J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 AUGUST 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application of the tenth to twelfth Respondents dated 19 July 2019 be dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’CALLAGHAN J:

Introduction

  1. By an interlocutory application dated 19 July 2019, the tenth to twelfth respondents seek an order that the applicant (the CFMMEU) produce a recording of a conversation, and any transcript of a recording of a conversation, that they contend is “mentioned” in a pleading.

  2. The critical question – whether a document is “mentioned” in a pleading – arises in circumstances where it is not identified in terms, but where the tenth to twelfth respondents contend that on the face of the pleading the inference must be drawn that it exists, and that it was relied on for the purposes of preparing the pleading.  They submit that although the CFMMEU’s pleaded particulars do not mention in terms any recording of a conversation or any transcript of it, the precision and length of the conversation alleged in the particulars of the claim mean that the irresistible inference to be drawn is that such a recording or transcript must exist, such that the pleading makes a “direct allusion” to the recording or transcript or incorporates it by reference to its contents.  In those circumstances, the tenth to twelfth respondents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction Forestry Maritime Mining and Energy Union v McC... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1376
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Construction Forestry Maritime Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU) filed an Amended Statement of Claim alleging that on 14 March 2019, Mr. Tzimas exercised his right to investigate suspected breaches of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) at a Laverton building site. McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd, the head construction contractor, disputed this right and called the police. The CFMMEU further alleged that Senior Constable Yeomans and Constables Thomas and Zoltowski informed Mr. Tzimas that he was trespassing and had to wait for WorkSafe before gaining further access, forming the basis for subsequent contraventions of the Fair Work Act. The tenth to thirteenth respondents, including the police officers, served a request for further and better particulars to clarify the conversation between Mr. Tzimas and the police officers. The CFMMEU provided specific details of the conversation in their response.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the document containing the particulars of the conversation between Mr. Tzimas and the police officers was "mentioned" in the pleadings, as required by the Federal Court Rules 2011. The respondents argued that the document was not mentioned and thus should not be produced. The CFMMEU countered that the document was sufficiently described in the pleadings. The court had to determine whether the document's particulars were adequately referenced in the pleadings to warrant its production.

The court found that the document containing the particulars of the conversation was not sufficiently "mentioned" in the pleadings. The court noted that while the conversation was summarised in the Amended Statement of Claim, the specific document detailing the conversation was not explicitly referenced or described in the pleadings. Therefore, the court concluded that the document did not fall within the scope of what was "mentioned" in the pleadings, leading to the dismissal of the interlocutory application for production. The court held that the document was not adequately referenced in the pleadings to warrant its production.

The court ordered that the interlocutory application of the tenth to twelfth respondents dated 19 July 2019 be dismissed. The decision was based on the finding that the document containing the particulars of the conversation was not "mentioned" in the pleadings, as required by the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application of the tenth to twelfth Respondents dated 19 July 2019 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In my view, for reasons that I shall briefly set out below, the application for production should be dismissed.The facts In its Amended Statement of Claim, the CFMMEU alleges that on the morning of 14 March 2019, Mr Tzimas entered a building site at Laverton in Victoria and exercised a right to investigate suspected breaches of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) (the OHS Act). McConnell Dowell, the head construction contractor, disputed this asserted right and called the police. The tenth respondent, Senior Constable Yeomans, and the eleventh and twelfth respondents (Constable Thomas and Constable Zoltowski respectively), were the police officers who attended the call out. At [99] of the ASOC, the CFMMEU alleges:Mr Tzimas then spoke with police officers including Senior Constable Yeomans, Constable Thomas and Constable Zoltowski about his entry rights under the OHS Act, during which conversation, Senior Constable Yeomans informed Mr Tzimas that:(a)he and other officials could make a request to attend the site, say that they were there and serve a notice;(b) McConnell Dowell then had a right to refuse that request;(c) she understood he did not have any right to be on the site;(d) Mr Tzimas was trespassing;(e) Mr Tzimas had to wait for WorkSafe before he could gain any further access;(f)Mr Tzimas was not to proceed any further than where he was because he was trespassing (the Right to Refuse Entry Representation). The Right to Refuse Entry Representation founds allegations of the following contraventions of the Fair Work Act made by the CFMMEU:(a)Yeomans contravened s 503 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act), which prohibits misrepresentations about things authorised by Part 3-4 of the FW Act;(b)Yeomans contravened s 502 of the FW Act, which relates to hindering or obstructing a person who holds an entry permit; and(c)Zoltowski and Thomas were persons involved in Yeomans’ contravention of s 502, and thus by operation of s 550 of the FW Act, have themselves contravened s 502 of the FW Act. On 4 June 2019, the solicitors for the tenth to thirteenth respondents served a request for further and better particulars, [3] of which sought particulars of [99] of the ASOC (the Request) in the following terms:Give particulars of the entire conversation between Mr Tzimas and police officers including Senior Constable Yeomans, Constable Thomas and Constable Zoltowski, including which persons spoke during the conversation, what they said and the order in which they said it. By letter dated 25 June 2019, the CFMMEU’s solicitors provided particulars in response to the Request (the Particulars). The letter relevantly provides, and the Particulars are, as follows:We refer to your request for further and better particulars served 4 June 2019 in the above matter. For convenience, we have adopted as headings the paragraph numbers which you have used. We respond as follows:…Paragraph 995.This paragraph conforms to r 16.04 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCRs).6.In any event, we note that the relevant aspects of the conversation containing the matters relied on was in the following terms:SC Yeomans: So while you wait for WorkSafe, my understanding is that you have to be outside the gate until they, WorkSafe, come.Tzimas:There’s nothing written to say that you have to be inside or outside the gate. If they’ve got a dispute like they were dispute out arguments yesterday, we waited outside the gate. If they‘ve got a dispute like they were disputing our arguments yesterday, we waited inside the site and WorkSafe attended inside the site. We didn’t have to leave site and wait for WorkSafe in the interim. So there’s nothing written down in law or in practice to say that the minute WorkSafe is contacted I need to leave site and wait for them to attend.SC Yeomans: So you’re not given - you’re not given access to here, you’ve been refused access here.Tzimas: Yeah.SC Yeomans: To my understanding that’s trespass.Tzimas: Is it.SC Yeomans: Yeah.Tzimas:Well when you’ve got a legal federal permit and followed all the steps according to the Act it actually then becomes them illegally hindering and obstructing an ARREO. So they’re not – they’re refusing to talk to me.SC Yeomans: So they’re not obstructing you. Tzimas: They are.SC Yeomans: You’re following the procedure of contacting WorkSafe which you’ve said you’ve done. And until they come in terms of your right being here, my understanding is that you don’t have any.…SC Yeomans: Yeah so it might be a delay of maybe an hour or two until WorkSafe get here.Tzimas:Yeah, that’s a delay that they’re working unsafely and in that potentially someone dies.…SC Yeomans: But you’ve also got to follow on with the fact that you’re standing on property that you’re not allowed to be on at this moment. Okay that’s all we’re asking. Stand over at the gate, your other mate is standing out there. I don’t understand why you’re in here.…SC Yeomans: Well you’ve got to wait for WorkSafe before you can gain any further access to this area, you’ve said it yourself.Tzimas:Yeah but we’ve got a right - so when we attend site usually this is what happens right. When we attend site we present ourselves to management, take all reasonable like steps to make our presence known which we did. Present someone with the ARREO, show ‘em our permit, go through the issues. If they want to hinder and obstruct us then we contact WorkSafe but in the meantime while WorkSafe are getting here we’ve got a right to advise our members that they’re working unsafely.…SC Yeomans: I’ve asked – we’ve asked – we said to you to go step out there until WorkSafe – you can’t proceed with any of what you want to do until WorkSafe arrive.…SC Yeomans: But don’t proceed any further than here all rights. Tzimas:Not a problem.SC Yeomans: Because at this point you’re trespassing.Tzimas: I’m happy to wait here.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.