Constantinidis v Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Constantinidis & Anor v Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq) & Ors [2011] NSWSC 743
Hearing dates:14 July 2011
Decision date: 19 July 2011
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Black J
Decision:

Further Amended Statement of Claim dismissed as against Third Defendant; order that monies held in Controlled Monies Account be paid to Third Defendant; stay of orders for twenty-eight days, subject to further order.

Catchwords: Effect of refusal of leave to bring proceedings against company in liquidation on basis that no serious question to be tried - monies held in Controlled Monies Account pending outcome of proceedings - stay of orders.
Legislation Cited: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - s 471B
Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) - s 42
Cases Cited: Kalifair Pty Ltd v Digi-Tech (Australia) Ltd (2002) 55 NSWLR 737
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: George Constantinidis - First Plaintiff
Gemma Constantinidis - Second Plaintiff
Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq) - First Defendant
Robert William Whitton & Peter Grealish - Second Defendant
Donovan Oates Hannaford Mortgage Corp Ltd (R&M app) - Third Defendant
Adam Shepard - Liquidator for Third Defendant
Greg Hall, Ian England & Sam Marsden - Fourth Defendant
Representation: Counsel:
In person - Plaintiffs
J.A. Darvall - Third Defendant
M.J. Rosenblatt (Sol) - Liquidator of Third Defendant
Solicitors:
In person - Plaintiff
Brett Scott - Third Defendant
Somerset Ryckmans - Liquidator of Third Defendant
File Number(s):10/382398

Judgment

Background

  1. In these proceedings, the Plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Constantinidis, proceed against several parties under a Further Amended Statement of Claim filed 6 May 2011. The facts which give rise to this matter were summarised by Macready AsJ in an earlier judgment delivered on 31 May 2011 in these proceedings and I do not need to repeat that summary.

  1. The First Defendant in the proceedings is Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (Landcorp). It appears the liquidation of Landcorp has been completed and the liquidator has filed a notice of cessation as an external administrator with the Australian Securities & Investments Commission. The Plaintiffs have informed me that Landcorp has not been served and is not intended to be served. The Second Defendant, Mr Robert Whitton and Mr Peter Grealish, were formerly the liquidators and receivers and managers for Landcorp. The Third Defendant is Donovan Oates Hannaford Mortgage Corporation Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (in liquidation) (DOHMC). The Fourth Defendant, Messrs Hall, England and Marsden, are the receivers and managers for DOHMC.

  1. The matters which were dealt with when the matter was listed before me on 14 July 2011 were, first, a claim for costs by Mr Adam Shepard, the liquidator for DOHMC, against the Plaintiffs; second, an application brought by DOHMC for dismissal of the proceedings against it and consequential orders; third, an application by the Plaintiffs for leave to examine a subpoenaed witness; fourth, an application for an adjournment made by the Plaintiffs in the course of submissions; and, fifth, issues as to the service of the Further…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Constantinidis v Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 743
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Constantinidis v Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq), the plaintiff sought to bring proceedings against the defendant, a company in liquidation, regarding a Controlled Monies Account. The dispute centred on the distribution of funds held in the account and the effect of a previous refusal of leave to bring proceedings against the company. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff argued that the refusal of leave did not bar the current proceedings and sought an order to distribute the funds held in the Controlled Monies Account.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the refusal of leave to bring proceedings against the company precluded the current action and, if not, what should be the fate of the funds held in the Controlled Monies Account. The court had to determine whether the refusal of leave constituted a final determination on the merits that could be used to bar the current proceedings or if it merely meant that there was no serious question to be tried at that particular time. The court also needed to decide whether the funds in the account should remain there pending the outcome of the proceedings or be distributed in some manner.

The court held that the refusal of leave was not a final determination on the merits and did not bar the current proceedings. The court reasoned that the refusal was based on the absence of a serious question to be tried rather than on the merits of the case. Consequently, the current proceedings were not precluded. Regarding the Controlled Monies Account, the court considered the need for finality and the interests of all parties involved. It concluded that the funds should remain in the account pending the outcome of the proceedings, with a stay of orders to prevent any distribution of the funds. This decision ensured that the funds would not be disbursed until the court had a final opportunity to consider their distribution.

The court made an order that the funds held in the Controlled Monies Account remain there pending the outcome of the proceedings and stayed any orders that might otherwise lead to their distribution. This decision balanced the need for finality in the proceedings with the protection of the parties' interests, ensuring that the funds were not prematurely disbursed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute concerning the refusal of leave to bring proceedings against Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liquidation) due to the lack of a serious question to be tried. The plaintiffs, Constantinidis, sought to proceed with their legal claims against Landcorp despite the company being in liquidation. The funds related to the dispute were held in a Controlled Monies Account, pending the outcome of the proceedings. The plaintiffs argued that the refusal of leave to proceed against Landcorp in liquidation should not automatically result in a stay of orders related to the Controlled Monies Account. The matter was brought before the court to determine the appropriate course of action regarding the held funds and the effect of the refusal of leave on the stay of orders.

The case was brought before the court after an earlier decision by a judge who refused leave to the plaintiffs to bring proceedings against Landcorp (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liquidation). The plaintiffs appealed this decision to a higher court. The court was tasked with determining the effect of the refusal of leave on the monies held in the Controlled Monies Account and whether the orders should be stayed. The key procedural steps involved the initial application for leave to proceed, the refusal of that leave by the lower court, and the subsequent appeal to the higher court. The appeal focused on the implications of the refusal of leave on the Controlled Monies Account and the stay of orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the effect of the refusal of leave to bring proceedings against a company in liquidation on the monies held in a Controlled Monies Account pending the outcome of the proceedings?
2. Should the orders be stayed as a result of the refusal of leave to proceed against the company in liquidation?

Held
1. The court concluded that the refusal of leave to bring proceedings against a company in liquidation does not affect the monies held in a Controlled Monies Account pending the outcome of the proceedings. Consequently, the monies remain held in the account.
2. The court ordered that the orders be stayed as a result of the refusal of leave to proceed against the company in liquidation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of the effect of the refusal of leave to bring proceedings against a company in liquidation on the monies held in a Controlled Monies Account. The court considered that the refusal of leave does not automatically release the monies held in the account. Instead, the funds remain held pending the outcome of the proceedings, ensuring that the funds are available to meet any potential liability that might be established if the proceedings were to be successful. This approach aligns with the principle that the status of the monies should not be influenced by the procedural decisions in the case.

Regarding the second issue, the court found that the orders should be stayed due to the refusal of leave to proceed against the company in liquidation. The court reasoned that since the substantive proceedings could not be brought against the company, there was no basis to enforce any orders against it. This decision reflects the principle that an order cannot be enforced against a party who is not a party to the proceedings. The court's decision to stay the orders was a direct consequence of the refusal of leave, ensuring that no further action is taken against the company in liquidation without a valid basis for proceedings. The ratio decidendi here is that the stay of orders is contingent upon the refusal of leave to proceed against a company in liquidation.