Constable v Harding & Australian Associated Motor Insurers

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Registry: Brisbane

Number: S 8804 of 1997

Before Justice Wilson

[Constable v Harding & Anor]

Plaintiff:  SPENCER WILLIAM CONSTABLE      

AND

First Defendant:       LEONARD HARDING

AND

Second Defendant:    AUSTRALIAN ASSOCIATED MOTOR INSURERS LIMITED (ACN 004 791 744)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT : WILSON J

Delivered:     2 February 2000

CATCHWORDS:     NEGLIGENCE – CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE – APPORTIONMENT OF RESPONSIBILITY AND DAMAGES – ROAD ACCIDENT CASE – Liability of driver of vehicle – turning across traffic – failure to give adequate signal – assessment of quantum of damages for future economic loss where injured plaintiff generates income through a proprietary limited company

Husherv Husher [1999] HCA 47; Conley v Minehan [1999] NSW CA 432

Counsel:  Mr MJ Taylor for the plaintiff
  Mr KN Wilson for the defendants

Solicitors:                  Noel Woodall and Associates for the plaintiff
  Dunhill Madden Butler for the defendants

Hearing date:            4, 5, 6 October 1999

  1. In this action the plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident on 29 May 1995 on the David Low Way at Marcoola on the Sunshine Coast.  The accident occurred when the Harley Davidson motor cycle he was riding collided with a Ford Econovan driven by the first defendant.  Both liability and quantum are in issue.

  1. The accident occurred at approximately 5 pm on a Monday afternoon.  It was a fine day and still daylight. 

  1. The accident occurred on the highway north of the Surfair Hotel.  The road was marked for one lane of traffic in either direction broken by a white centre line down the centre of the road.

  1. The plaintiff was travelling in a northerly direction.  As he approached the accident scene he came around a bend and then on to a straight stretch about 350 metres in length to the accident scene.  The accident occurred at the entrance of the first defendant’s property which was on the eastern side of the highway. 

  1. Lorraine Avenue intersected with the highway on its eastern side at a point between the end of the bend and the first defendant’s property.  The distance from the northern kerb of Lorraine Avenue to the centre of the first defendant’s driveway was 50 metres. 

  1. There was a bus shelter on the western side of the highway opposite the Lorraine Avenue intersection.  For a short distance on either side of the shelter there was an additional kerbside lane.

  1. The plaintiff was following a Holden Commodore driven by Pauline Neal.  The two vehicles travelled around the bend to which I have referred.  The speed limit was 80 kilometres per hour and the Commodore was travelling at about the speed limit.  When the vehicles came on to the straight section of road, the plaintiff overtook the Commodore.  According to Mrs Neal, whose evidence I accept, the bike’s speed as it overtook her was not excessive.  The plaintiff estimated his speed at 80-85 kilometres per hour.  The bike moved in front of the Commodore to a position described by Mrs Neal in cross-examination as about two…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Constable v Harding & Australian Associated Motor Insurers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QSC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Constable claimed damages for injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident caused by Harding. The accident occurred on May 29, 1995, on the David Low Way at Marcoola, Sunshine Coast, when Constable's motorcycle collided with a Ford Econovan driven by Harding. Both liability and quantum were in issue. Constable claimed damages for personal injury, while Harding and his insurer, Australian Associated Motor Insurers, were the defendants.

The primary legal issues the court had to decide were the extent of each party's liability for the accident and the quantum of damages to be awarded to Constable. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether Harding was negligent in his actions leading up to the accident, and if so, to what extent. Similarly, the court needed to assess Constable's contributory negligence, if any, and how it should affect the apportionment of damages.

The court found Harding negligent for failing to give an adequate signal before turning and for not checking his rear vision mirror until he started turning. Harding was found to be 60% responsible for the damages, while Constable was found to be 40% responsible for not keeping his motorcycle sufficiently under control to deal with the van's unexpected movement. The court assessed the damages for pain and suffering and loss of the amenities of life at $30,000, with interest on $20,000 of that amount at 2% per annum, totalling $1,865. Special damages, including interest, were allowed at $2,000. For future economic loss, the court awarded a global sum of $25,000. After apportionment for contributory negligence, the court ruled that Constable should receive $54,321 in damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 29 May 1995, Spencer William Constable was riding his Harley Davidson motorcycle on the David Low Way at Marcoola on the Sunshine Coast. He collided with a Ford Econovan driven by Leonard Harding. The accident occurred as Constable was overtaking a Holden Commodore driven by Pauline Neal and Harding was turning right into his property. Constable was injured in the accident and Harding was alleged to be negligent for not giving an adequate signal before turning and for not checking his rear vision mirror until he commenced to turn. Constable was also found to be negligent for not keeping his motorcycle sufficiently in control to deal with any unexpected movement of the van. The court apportioned liability at 60% to Harding and 40% to Constable. Constable suffered a grade two compound fracture of the mid shaft of the right tibia, a comminuted fracture of the right distal fibula, and a back problem as a result of the accident. He also experienced adjustment problems consisting of unhappiness, frustration, and irritability.

The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane before Justice Wilson. The plaintiff, Constable, claimed damages for personal injuries sustained in the accident. Both liability and quantum of damages were in issue. The case was heard over three days from 4 to 6 October 1999. Prior to this hearing, Constable had undergone two surgeries on his leg and had experienced a loss of working capacity. The court considered evidence from Constable, his wife, three orthopaedic surgeons, an occupational therapist, and video evidence of Constable's activities on building sites.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What was the extent of Constable's contributory negligence in the accident?
2. What was the appropriate apportionment of responsibility between Constable and Harding?
3. What was the quantum of damages for Constable's pain and suffering, loss of amenities of life, special damages, and economic loss?
4. How should the economic loss be calculated given Constable's involvement in a proprietary limited company?

Held
1. Constable was found to be 40% contributorily negligent in the accident.
2. The court apportioned responsibility at 60% to Harding and 40% to Constable.
3. The court awarded Constable $20,000 for past pain and suffering, $10,000 for future pain and suffering, $1,865 in interest on the pain and suffering damages, $2,000 for special damages including interest, $2,000 for loss of services from Griffiths v Kerkemeyer including interest, $25,000 for past economic loss, and $4,670 in interest on the past economic loss. For future economic loss, the court awarded a global sum of $25,000.
4. The court calculated Constable's economic loss based on his potential earnings from his proprietary limited company, considering his role and the likelihood of transitioning to a more managerial position.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court first assessed the extent of Constable's contributory negligence, concluding that he was 40% responsible for the accident. Constable was the following vehicle and should have been more vigilant and controlled his motorcycle better to handle any unexpected movements by Harding's van. Harding was found to be 60% responsible for not indicating before turning and for not checking his rear vision mirror until he commenced the turn. The court then moved to apportion responsibility, reflecting the respective contributions to the accident. Regarding damages, the court awarded Constable compensation for pain and suffering, special damages, loss of services, and economic loss. The video evidence provided by the defendants showed Constable engaging in physically demanding activities, which led the court to adjust the medical experts' initial assessments of his disabilities downwards. For economic loss, the court applied the principles from Husher v Husher and Conley v Minehan, focusing on the plaintiff's control over his earning capacity and the realistic expectations of his income but for the accident. The court determined that Constable could have withdrawn his labour from the company and would likely have transitioned to a more managerial role. The award was based on the pre-accident income levels and adjusted for contingencies and tax considerations.