Conquip Holdings Pty Ltd v S & A Restaurant Corp

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Conquip Holdings Pty Ltd v S & A Restaurant Corp [2000] FCA 256

TRADE MARKS – application for removal on ground of non-use – marks for restaurant services and associated goods comprising or including the name “Bennigan’s” – respondent the operator of a large United States restaurant chain under that name – applicant the operator of an Australian restaurant “Bennigans” – whether applicant a “person aggrieved” – whether bona fides of applicant relevant – if relevant, whether applicant lacking in bona fides – whether prima facie case – whether non-use – whether discretion not to remove should be exercised – assertion that requirement to use name would be “commercially unreasonable” by reason of large expenditure on the kind of restaurants operated by respondent – removal of non distinctive marks after ten years under Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 88(2)(d) – whether provision applies to mark registered under Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth)

Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) ss 23(1)(b), 24, 25
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 88(2)(d), 92

The Ritz Hotel Ltd v Charles of the RitzLtd (1988) 15 NSWLR 158 at 193 applied
Kraft General Foods Inc v Gaines Pet Foods Corporation (1996) 65 FCR 104 at 112 applied
Powell v Birmingham Brewery Co Ltd [1894] AC 8 at 12 applied
Estex Clothing Manufacturers Pty Limited v Ellis and GoldsteinLtd (1967) 116 CLR 254 at 258 applied
Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd v G F Heublein and Bro Incorporated (1960) 103 CLR 422 at 433 applied
Paine v Daniel (1893) 10 RPC 217 at 232 mentioned
Bright Times Music Corp v Harrisons Music Ltd 420 F Supp 177 (1976) mentioned
Moorgate Tobacco Co Ltd v Philip Morris Ltd (No 2) (1984) 156 CLR 414 applied
Settef SpA v Riv-Oland Marble Co (Vic) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 IPR 402 at 417 applied
J Lyons & Co. Ltd’s Application [1959] RPC 120 at 130 mentioned
Hermes Trade Mark [1982] RPC 425) mentioned
Paragon Shoes Pty Ltd v Paragini Distributors (NSW) Ltd (1988) 13 IPR 323 mentioned

CONQUIP HOLDINGS PTY LTD v S & A RESTAURANT CORP
NO. VG 602 OF 1998

HEEREY J

15 MARCH 2000
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VG 602 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

CONQUIP  HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ACN 057 055 044)
Applicant

AND:

S & A RESTAURANT CORP
Respondent

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 MARCH 2000

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal from the decision of the Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks given on 25 August 1998 be allowed

2.The said decision of the Deputy Registrar be set aside.

3.The application by the applicant for the removal of trade mark registration no. 376352 from the Register of Trade Marks be granted.

4.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding before the Deputy Registrar.

5.The Registrar of Trade Marks remove from the Register of Trade Marks each of registered trade marks nos. 376352, 376353, 376354, 376355, 376356, 594459 and 594460.

6.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Conquip Holdings Pty Ltd v S & A Restaurant Corp and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Conquip Holdings Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against S & A Restaurant Corp, challenging the validity of several trade mark registrations held by S & A in Australia. The case was heard and decided by a court, which examined the evidence presented by both parties regarding the use of the trade marks in Australia. The central issue before the court was whether S & A had genuinely used the contested trade marks in Australia within the required periods, as stipulated by trade mark law. S & A argued that despite not establishing or franchising a restaurant under the name Bennigan’s in Australia, the trade marks were still in use due to various forms of advertising and discussions with potential franchisees. The court found that the evidence provided by S & A did not demonstrate that the trade marks were actually used in Australia, as the publications and discussions did not reach Australian audiences and there was no evidence of Australian awareness or use. The court concluded that S & A had not used the marks in the relevant periods, and therefore, the registrations should be removed from the Register of Trade Marks. The court also considered the discretion not to remove the marks for non-use, ultimately deciding against exercising this discretion in favour of S & A.

The court's decision was based on the lack of concrete evidence of trade mark use in Australia, aligning with the legal requirement for continuous and genuine use of trade marks. The court dismissed S & A's arguments regarding commercial impracticality and residual reputation, finding that the significant investment required to open a Bennigan’s restaurant did not excuse non-use under the law. Consequently, the court granted Conquip's application for the removal of the trade marks from the register and ordered the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings. The decision underscores the necessity for trade mark holders to demonstrate actual use in the market to maintain their registrations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal from the decision of the Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks given on 25 August 1998 be allowed

2. The said decision of the Deputy Registrar be set aside.

3. The application by the applicant for the removal of trade mark registration no. 376352 from the Register of Trade Marks be granted.

4. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding before the Deputy Registrar.

5. The Registrar of Trade Marks remove from the Register of Trade Marks each of registered trade marks nos. 376352, 376353, 376354, 376355, 376356, 594459 and 594460.

6. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of this proceeding, including reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

S & A Restaurant Corp, a United States-based company, holds trade mark registrations in the United States and other countries, including Australia. The company did not establish, franchise, or sell goods under the name "Bennigan’s" in Australia. The evidence presented by S & A to establish use in Australia included US advertisements and news stories, which were not shown to have circulated in Australia, and discussions with Rydge/Radisson in 1992-1993 about potential Australian franchises. S & A provided financial information to Rydge/Radisson but did not establish a restaurant or offer goods under the Bennigan’s name in Australia.

The matter came before the court following an application by Conquip Holdings Pty Ltd to remove the trade mark registrations held by S & A Restaurant Corp. The application was first heard by the Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks, whose decision was appealed to the court. The appeal was allowed, and the court set aside the Deputy Registrar's decision, granted the application for the removal of the trade mark registrations, and ordered the Registrar of Trade Marks to remove the specified trade marks from the Register of Trade Marks.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

S & A is the proprietor of or the applicant for a large number of trade mark registrations in the United States and other countries including Australia. S & A’s evidence as to trade mark use in Australia S & A did not suggest that it has ever established or franchised a restaurant under the name Bennigan’s (or any other name) in Australia or sold or offered to sell any goods in this country under or by reference to that name. The evidence proffered by S & A to establish use in Australia falls into the following categories.(i) US advertisements and news stories Reference is made to Bennigan’s restaurants in articles in the Louisville News (11 March 1994), the Wauwatosa News Times (24 March 1994), Nations Restaurant News (14 February 1994), Charleston Daily Mail (26 January 1994), Ad Week (24 January 1994), Restaurants Resorts and Hotels (1 January 1994), Modern Food Service News (December 1993) and Nations Restaurant News (1 March 1993). Employment advertisements appeared in Nations Restaurant News (25 July and 22 August 1994). There is no evidence that any of these publications reached Australia or that any Australian resident ever read them.(ii) Discussions with Rydge/Radisson 1992-1993 Mr Evans deposed that in late 1992 and early 1993 S & A was approached by “a group of prospective franchisees interested in operating Bennigan’s restaurants under licence in Australia”. On 19 January 1993 a Mr John S Rydge of Rydge Consulting Group wrote to S & A as follows:“Mr. James W. McCarthyS & A Restaurant Corp12404 Park Central DriveDALLAS TX 75251-1699Dear Jim, I am returning herewith the Confidentiality Undertaking signed by:(a) Myself as Managing Director of Rydge Consulting Group Pty. Limited.(b) David Boward – Managing Director of Radisson Hotels Pty. Limited.(c) Paul D’Arcy – Finance Director of Radisson Hotels P/L.At this early stage of negotiations we will restrict any information supplied to us to this senior group. As time passes and assuming we are moving forward positively I will wish to add selected executives to the signatories and will complete additional forms for them as and when appropriate.I look forward to receiving the P & L information we discussed, to enable us to proceed with our evaluations and proposals to your corporation.On another issue, I would like to receive copies of the current menu for both Bennigan’s and Steak & Ale. Much of the discussion here revolves around the acceptability in Australia of the standard menus for both Steak & Ale and Bennigan’s and what variations, if necessary, might be required. Could you please forward this request to Steve’s secretary and ask her to expedite examples to me soonest.Best Regards,sgdJohn S. Rydge.” Mr McCarthy replied by letter to Mr Rydge dated 19 January 1995.“Mr. John S. RydgeManaging DirectorRydge Consulting Group Pty. Ltd.6 Venetta Road, GlencrieN.S.W. 2157AustraliaRe: Bennigan’s P & L’sDear John:Thank you for returning the signed Confidentiality Undertaking. I have enclosed the Bennigan’s P & L information which you requested. I am also sending this information by overnight delivery in the event the facsimile copy is not legible. I look forward to hearing from you. Best regards.Sincerely,SgdJames W. McCarthyVice President andGeneral Counsel”

Decision

Reasons for decision

The news stories and advertisements referring to S & A’s Bennigan’s restaurants are not shown to have circulated in Australia. Nor is there any evidence that anyone in Australia was aware of them: cf Continental Liqueurs at 429-430. Conclusion on non-use I conclude that neither in the 1992-1995 period nor the 1995-98 period did S & A use the marks in suit in Australia. I accept that it did not intend to abandon the marks, and hoped to use them in Australia one day, but it did not use them in the relevant periods.Discretion not to remove mark It is accepted that under the 1955 Act the Registrar, and thus the Court on appeal, has discretion not to remove a mark for non-use. Such a discretion is now explicitly provided for in s 101(3) of the 1995 Act. Shanahan in Australian Law of Trade Marks and Passing-off (second edition at 275) notes that “the public interest in the integrity of the register will generally demand the removal of an unused mark”. Similarly in J Lyons & Co. Ltd’s Application [1959] RPC 120 at 130 Evershed J treated the discretion as a matter requiring “exceptional circumstances”. After the passage just quoted Shanahan goes on to give some examples of the exercise of discretion, namely where the mark, although unused in the statutory sense, is nonetheless well known because of the retention of some “residual reputation” from earlier use, or from advertising or publicity coming from abroad (see Hermes Trade Mark [1982] RPC 425). Similarly there might be refusal of removal where the mark had in fact been used but an assignment or licence had not been recorded: Paragon Shoes Pty Ltd v Paragini Distributors (NSW) Ltd (1988) 13 IPR 323. It is not suggested that any comparable circumstances could be relied upon by S & A in the present case. The prime argument relied upon for the exercise of the discretion is that it would have been “commercially unreasonable” in the light of Conquip’s attack on the marks for S & A to have traded itself or secured a franchisee to trade under the marks whilst the validity of the marks remained unresolved. This argument of course would only extend to the time after Conquip’s application for removal of the marks in March 1995. This would be after the end of the 1992-95 period. However in relation to both pre and post March 1995 there is a circumstance which is said to excuse or explain S & A’s non-use, namely that its marks are “not for a product which can be protected by small transactions”. Mr Steed estimates that it would cost S & A over US $1 million plus the cost of land to open a Bennigan’s restaurant in Australia and that a franchisee would be required to invest a minimum of between US$1.1 million and $2.2 million, again plus the cost of land. This argument would not be applicable to S & A’s marks for goods. If it so wished, it could have sold or offered for sale in Australia relatively small quantities of goods under or by reference to its marks. As to its marks for services, and in particular restaurant services, the fallacy of the argument is that it treats the legal protection conferred by the registered marks as coterminous with the kind of the business which, for reasons of commercial judgment, S & A prefers to conduct. As long as its restaurant services marks remain on the register, S & A could and doubtless would prevent anybody in Australia conducting any restaurant under that name even if it cost far less than US$1 million plus the cost of land to establish. By the same token, if S & A had wanted to establish use to protect its mark it could have made some licensing arrangement with a restaurant of any kind, even if it were much more modest than S & A’s preferred model.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by S & A to demonstrate the use of the trade marks in Australia, including references to US advertisements, news stories, and discussions with potential Australian franchisees. The court found that the evidence did not establish any actual use of the trade marks in Australia or awareness of such use by Australian residents. Therefore, the court concluded that S & A did not use the trade marks in Australia during the relevant periods.

Regarding the court's discretion to not remove the trade marks for non-use under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), the court acknowledged that it has such discretion. The court referred to precedents where the discretion had been exercised in exceptional circumstances, such as when a mark was well-known due to residual reputation or advertising from abroad. However, the court found that S & A's argument that it would have been commercially unreasonable to use the trade marks while the validity of the marks was being contested did not justify exercising the discretion. The court noted that S & A could have taken other actions, such as making licensing arrangements with smaller restaurants, to establish use of the trade marks.

The court also considered the factors it should take into account when exercising the discretion not to remove the trade marks for non-use. The court noted that the public interest in the integrity of the register generally demanded the removal of unused marks. It found that the circumstances in this case did not warrant the exercise of the discretion, as S & A's argument was based on its commercial preferences rather than exceptional circumstances. Therefore, the court decided not to exercise the discretion and ordered the removal of the trade marks from the Register of Trade Marks.