Connor v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

CONNOR & ANOR v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE & ANOR

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle

31 August 2004

POLICE - TRIBUNALS AND OTHER AUTHORITIES

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION

Application pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 63.02 - plaintiffs applied for two prescribed promotional positions in the SA Police - no selection was made for one of these positions - whether plaintiffs are entitled to make an application to the Police Review Tribunal pursuant to s 55(2) of the Police Act for a review of a decision that no selection be made - application dismissed.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 r 63.02; Police Act 1998 (SA) s 10(1), s 53(1), s 54, s 54(1), s 55, s 55(1), s 55(2), s 55(3), s 64; Police Regulations 1999 s 33, s 33(2), s 33(3), s 33(5), s 38, referred to.

CONNOR & ANOR v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE & ANOR
[2004] SASC 258

Civil

  1. DOYLE CJ           Mr Connor and Mr Schlein have applied pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 63.02 for a determination of the question of whether they are entitled to make an application to the Police Review Tribunal pursuant to s 55(2) of the Police Act 1998 (SA) (“the Act”). The application each of them has made is for a review of a decision made by the Commissioner of Police (on the advice of a selection advisory committee) (“the committee”) that no selection decision be made in relation to a prescribed promotional position in the South Australia Police (“SA Police”).

    Background and legislation

  2. Mr Connor and Mr Schlein are stationed at the Drug and Organised Crime Investigation Branch of SA Police. Mr Connor and Mr Schlein were two of fourteen applicants for two positions of Detective Senior Sergeant in the Branch. These positions are prescribed promotional positions: see s 53(1).

  3. Section 54 of the Act provides:

    “54An appointment to a prescribed promotional position may not be made unless selection processes have been conducted in accordance with the regulations for the purpose of filling the position.”

  4. Section 64 of the Act provides:

    “64Members of S. A. Police, police cadets and police medical officers must be appointed and promoted in accordance with procedures prescribed by the regulations.”

  5. The Regulations referred to in s 54 and s 64 of the Act are the Police Regulations 1999 (“the Regulations”). Part 8 of the Regulations relates to appointment to promotional positions in SA Police. Regulation 33 sets out the selection process for appointment and relevantly provides as follows:

    “33(1)      This regulation applies to an appointment to a position in S.A Police of or above the rank of senior constable and of or below the rank of Assistant Commissioner. …

    (3)The Commissioner may appoint an advisory committee of at least three persons, one of whom may be the Commissioner, to assist in determining the suitability of applicants to fill the position.

    (4)If the Commissioner is a member of the committee, the Commissioner will determine, with the advice and assistance of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Connor v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Connor v Commissioner of Police, the plaintiffs sought two prescribed promotional positions within the SA Police. Although the plaintiffs were not selected for one of these positions, they applied to the Police Review Tribunal for a review of the decision not to make a selection, pursuant to section 55(2) of the Police Act. The Commissioner of Police opposed this application, and the matter was brought before the court. The primary issue for the court to decide was whether the plaintiffs were entitled to apply to the Police Review Tribunal for a review of the decision that no selection was made for one of the prescribed promotional positions.

The court examined the language of section 55(2) of the Police Act and noted that it only applies to a selection decision that is a selection for an appointment. The court found that section 55(1) imposes an obligation to give notice only if a member is selected for appointment, and there is no obligation to give notice of a decision not to make an appointment. Consequently, the court concluded that the right to a review of the decision does not arise in such cases. The court rejected the argument that section 55(1) could be treated as purely procedural, and instead held that it limits the circumstances in which a right of review is conferred. The court further found that the provisions of sections 56 and 57 of the Police Act, which regulate the procedure before the Tribunal, are capable of applying to a decision that there is no suitable applicant for a position.

The court dismissed the plaintiffs' application, ruling that they were not entitled to make an application to the Police Review Tribunal for a review of a decision that no selection was made for one of the prescribed promotional positions. The court found that the statutory provisions clearly indicate that the right to a review only arises in cases where a member is selected for appointment, and not in cases where no selection is made. The court concluded that considerations of good management or related to the purpose of the Act were not strong enough to overcome the clear statutory provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ
Mr Grant, counsel for the defendant, submits that s 55(2) applies only to a selection decision that is a selection for an appointment. He relies on the provisions of s 55(1) for that argument, treating it as a condition of substance on the creation of a right of review under s 55(2). He argues also that there would be practical difficulties in the Tribunal reviewing a decision not to make an appointment. The Tribunal could not simply compare the unsuccessful applicant with the successful applicant, (as it would when reviewing a selection for appointment), but would have to undertake a review of all applicants for the position. It would not be appropriate to appoint a successful applicant in such a case (that is one who showed that the decision not to make an appointment was flawed), without reviewing the whole field. It was not in a position to do so. That was the role of the advisory committee. He also argued that the Regulations could not affect the meaning of the Act.Conclusion The right to apply to the Tribunal for review of a selection decision under s 55(2) can be exercised “when such a notice is given”, subject to compliance with s 55(3). The term “such a notice” refers to the notice specified in s 55(1), which is notice of a selection decision. It is clear from s 55(1) that the “selection decision” referred to is a decision that a member of SA Police has been selected for appointment. There is an obligation to give notice only if a member is selected for appointment. There is no obligation to give notice of a decision not to make an appointment. There is no requirement in the Act or Regulations that notice be given if no selection is made for a position. While notice of a decision to make no selection has been given in this instance, it is not a notice that the Commissioner was required to give. It is not a notice for the purposes of section 55(2), hence the right to a review of the decision does not arise. I am not satisfied that s 55(1) can be treated as purely procedural, and not as limiting the circumstances in which a right of review is conferred. I agree with Mr Heywood-Smith that there is no obvious reason not to confer a right of review in a case like the case before me. I am inclined to agree with him that it would be consistent with good management to provide for a right of review in a case like this, but I realise that there may be practical or management reasons, of which I am unaware, to think otherwise. Considerations of good management, or related to the purpose of the Act, are not strong enough in my opinion to overcome the fairly clear statutory provisions. I do not accept the submission by Mr Grant that the terms of s 56 and s 57 are inconsistent with the construction advanced by Mr Heywood-Smith. These provisions, regulating the procedure before the Tribunal, are capable of applying to a decision that there is no suitable applicant for a position, although I agree with Mr Grant they refer mainly to a decision to select one applicant rather than another.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ