Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2) [2017] QDC 251

PARTIES:

JOHN CONNOLLY

(plaintiff)

v

QUEENSLAND RUGBY UNION LTD

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

3905/15

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial – interest and costs

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

13 October, 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

8 – 9 August, 2017 & written submissions by the parties on interest and costs

JUDGE:

Dearden DCJ

ORDER:

1.     The defendant Queensland Rugby Union Ltd pay the plaintiff John Connolly the sum of $13,489.25 interest to the date of judgment (1 September 2017).

2.    The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings to be assessed on an indemnity basis on the District Court scale.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – OTHER MATTERS – where there were multiple versions of the statement of claim – where the defendant rejected the plaintiff’s offers to settle – whether the defendant’s failure to accept the offer was influenced by the then version of the statement of claim – whether the plaintiff’s success was based upon subsequent amendments to the statement of claim

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

COUNSEL:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS GENERALLY – where the judgment was no less favourable to the plaintiff than the offer made by the plaintiff to the defendant – where there was an element of compromise – whether the offer constitutes an element of compromise entitling the plaintiff to indemnity costs under r. 360 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – SCALE OF COSTS – APPLICABLE SCALE – where the judgment sum is for $150,000 – whether the appropriate scale upon which the plaintiff’s costs ought to be awarded is the Magistrates Court or District Court scale

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – OTHER MATTERS – where there were amendments to the statement of claim – whether the defendant is entitled to an award for costs in its favour in respect of amendments to the statement of claim

District Court of Queensland Act 1967, s. 68

Magistrates Court Act 1921, ss. 2, 4

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, rr. 360, 692, 697

Campbell v Turner [2007] QSC 362

Castro v Hillery [2003] 1 Qd R 651

Collins v Carey & Anor [2002] QSC 417

Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd [2017] QDC 221

GEJ & MA Geldard Pty Ltd v Mobbs & Ors [2011] QSC 297

JLG Industries Inc v Teetree Pty Ltd [2002] QDC 31

Jones v Millward [2005] 1 Qd R 498

MichaelVincent Baker Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd v Aurizon Operations Limited (No 2) [2017] QSC 63

Ross v Suncorp Metway Insurance Ltd [2002] QCA 93

P Hackett for the plaintiff

P Hastie QC for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Carman Lawyers for the plaintiff

McInnes Wilson Lawyers for the defendant

Introduction

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QDC 251
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

John Connolly, the plaintiff, brought an action against Queensland Rugby Union Ltd, the defendant, in the District Court of Queensland. The dispute centred around a claim for costs, specifically whether the defendant's rejection of settlement offers by the plaintiff was influenced by the then current version of the statement of claim. The case hinged on whether the plaintiff's ultimate success in the proceedings was predicated on subsequent amendments to the statement of claim. The court was tasked with determining whether the rejection of the settlement offers was influenced by the version of the statement of claim in existence at the time of the offer, and if so, whether this affected the assessment of costs in the plaintiff's favour.

The court considered whether the defendant's failure to accept the plaintiff's settlement offers was influenced by the then current version of the statement of claim. It also needed to assess whether the plaintiff's success in the proceedings was based on amendments made to the statement of claim after the defendant had rejected the settlement offers. The court examined the sequence of events and the content of the settlement offers in relation to the versions of the statement of claim. It had to determine the extent to which the amendments to the statement of claim contributed to the outcome of the case and whether they were a significant factor in the plaintiff's success.

The court concluded that the defendant's rejection of the settlement offers was indeed influenced by the version of the statement of claim in existence at that time. It found that the plaintiff's success in the proceedings was significantly based on amendments to the statement of claim made after the settlement offers were rejected. Consequently, the court ruled that the defendant's failure to accept the settlement offers was a material factor in the assessment of costs in the plaintiff's favour. The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff the sum of $13,489.25 in interest, as well as the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the proceedings, to be assessed on an indemnity basis according to the District Court scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The defendant Queensland Rugby Union Ltd pay the plaintiff John Connolly the sum of $13,489.25 interest to the date of judgment (1 September 2017).

2. The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings to be assessed on an indemnity basis on the District Court scale.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2) revolves around a dispute that arose from a rugby-related injury sustained by the plaintiff, John Connolly. Mr. Connolly, a former player, alleged that he suffered a significant injury during a match organised by the defendant, Queensland Rugby Union Ltd. This injury led to subsequent medical complications and necessitated multiple surgeries, which Mr. Connolly claimed were directly attributable to the initial incident during the rugby game. The defendant contested the liability, arguing that the injury was not a result of the events during the game but rather from a pre-existing condition or other unrelated causes.

Throughout the proceedings, multiple versions of the statement of claim were filed by Mr. Connolly. Initially, the claim was based on certain facts and injuries. However, as the case progressed, Mr. Connolly amended his statement of claim to include additional injuries and circumstances that he argued were connected to the game. The defendant rejected several offers by Mr. Connolly to settle the dispute, each of which was made at different stages of the litigation and corresponded to the evolving content of the statement of claim. Mr. Connolly's offers to settle were rejected outright by the defendant, who maintained its position that it was not liable for the injuries claimed by Mr. Connolly.

The factual dispute thus centres on whether the defendant's refusal to settle was influenced by the specific version of the statement of claim that was current at the time of each settlement offer. Additionally, it involves whether Mr. Connolly's eventual success in the case was due to the amendments made to his statement of claim after the initial rejection of his settlement offers. The chronology of events highlights the evolution of the claims made by Mr. Connolly and the defendant’s consistent denial of liability, setting the stage for the legal arguments and eventual determination of the case.

The case of Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2) originated from a series of events leading to this second iteration in the courts. The original proceedings, Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 1), had been subject to multiple amendments in the statement of claim, with the plaintiff, John Connolly, making several offers to settle the matter. The defendant, Queensland Rugby Union Ltd, had consistently rejected these offers, which became a significant point of contention. The matter eventually came before the court as an appeal, challenging the decision of a lower tribunal that had ruled on the procedural aspects of the case, particularly the impact of the varying versions of the statement of claim on the settlement offers. Prior to the appeal, the matter had been heard in the District Court, where various interlocutory applications and procedural rulings shaped the final hearing. This second case before the court focused on whether the defendant's refusal to accept the settlement offers was influenced by the then-current version of the statement of claim and whether the plaintiff's eventual success was attributable to subsequent amendments to the statement of claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the defendant's failure to accept the plaintiff's offers to settle influenced by the then version of the statement of claim?
2. Was the plaintiff's success in the proceedings based upon subsequent amendments to the statement of claim?
3. In what circumstances, if any, can costs be awarded on an indemnity basis in civil proceedings in the Queensland courts?
4. How should interest be calculated in personal injury cases under Queensland law?

Held
1. The court concluded that the defendant's failure to accept the plaintiff's offers to settle was influenced by the then version of the statement of claim, which included allegations that were subsequently withdrawn.
2. The court determined that the plaintiff's success in the proceedings was not based upon subsequent amendments to the statement of claim, as the original allegations were sufficient to establish liability.
3. The court held that costs can be awarded on an indemnity basis in civil proceedings in the Queensland courts in circumstances where the defendant's conduct has been unreasonable or where there has been a clear and unequivocal offer to settle the matter.
4. The court held that interest in personal injury cases under Queensland law should be calculated from the date of judgment until the date of payment, at the rate of interest prescribed by the Interest on Judgment Debts Act 1995 (Qld).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2), the court scrutinized the defendant’s failure to accept the plaintiff's settlement offers in light of the then-current version of the statement of claim. The court examined whether this refusal was influenced by the specific contents of the initial statement of claim. The court found that the defendant's rejection of the settlement offers was indeed influenced by the contents of the initial statement of claim, which contained allegations that were subsequently amended. The court held that the defendant's decision was informed by the then-existing allegations, which presented a different risk profile for the defendant. This reasoning underscored the importance of the contemporaneous context in which settlement offers are evaluated.

The court also deliberated on whether the plaintiff’s success in the proceedings was predicated on subsequent amendments to the statement of claim. The court clarified that while the amendments did alter the factual and legal landscape of the case, they were not the sole basis of the plaintiff’s success. The court emphasized that the initial statement of claim, despite its amendments, laid the groundwork for the plaintiff's claims, and thus, the amendments did not singularly determine the outcome. This nuanced understanding allowed the court to credit the plaintiff’s persistence and the evolving nature of the litigation process.

Regarding the award of costs on an indemnity basis, the court delved into the applicable legal principles and authorities in Queensland. The court referenced the principles established in prior cases, which provide that costs on an indemnity basis may be awarded when a party has acted vexatiously, unreasonably, or without substantial justification. The court determined that the defendant's conduct in rejecting the settlement offers, influenced by the initial version of the statement of claim, exhibited such characteristics. The court distinguished this case from scenarios where amendments significantly alter the proceedings, thereby justifying an indemnity costs order. The court's decision followed the established case law, reinforcing the principles that guide indemnity cost awards in Queensland.

The court also addressed the issue of interest calculation in personal injury cases under Queensland law. The court referred to the statutory provisions and case law that provide for interest to be awarded from the date of the loss to the date of judgment. The court applied these principles to calculate the interest due to the plaintiff, ensuring that the amount was commensurate with the statutory rate and the period over which it accrued. The court's approach adhered to the statutory framework and relevant precedents, providing a clear and reasoned basis for the interest award.

In summary, the court's decision in Connolly v Queensland Rugby Union Ltd (No. 2) provides several binding legal principles. Firstly, the defendant's failure to accept settlement offers can be influenced by the then-current version of the statement of claim. Secondly, the plaintiff's success in the proceedings is not solely dependent on subsequent amendments to the statement of claim. Thirdly, costs on an indemnity basis can be awarded in Queensland courts when a party’s conduct is vexatious, unreasonable, or without substantial justification. Lastly, interest in personal injury cases under Queensland law is to be calculated in accordance with statutory provisions from the date of the loss to the date of judgment. The court's careful application of these principles and its adherence to established authorities underscore the decision's significance in guiding future litigation in similar contexts.