Connolly and Connolly v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

Connolly and Connolly v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2016] QIRC 104

PARTIES:  

Connolly, Trevor and Cheryl
(Applicants)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2013/174

PROCEEDING:

Application for Costs

DELIVERED ON:

11 October 2016

HEARING DATE: 

3 August 2016

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Thompson

ORDER:

The Regulator is ordered to pay the Applicants an amount of $10,610.90 for costs relating to matter WC/2013/174 within 21 days of the release of this decision.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - APPLICATION FOR COSTS - Legislation - Regulator ordered to pay Applicants an amount of $10,610.90 for costs relating to matter WC/2013/174 within 21 days of the release of this decision.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 558
Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Regulation 2014, s 132

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999
Uniform Civil Procedures (Fees) Regulation 2009
Industrial Relations Act 1999, s 335
Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, r 70
John Henry Edwards AND Q-COMP (WC/2012/52) - Decision - <

APPEARANCES:

Mr P. Sergeyev, of Colwell Wright Solicitors, for the Appellant.
Mr S. Sapsford, Counsel directly instructed by Workers' Compensation Regulator, Respondent

Decision (No. 2)

  1. On 2 June 2016 an application was lodged on behalf of Trevor and Cheryl Connolly (Applicants) with the Industrial Registrar for a determination of costs in accordance with an Order made by the Commission on 22 January 2015.

  2. The application was made as a consequence of the failure of the Workers' Compensation Regulator (Regulator) and the Applicants to reach an agreement as to the quantum of costs payable to the Applicants in matter WC/2013/174.

  3. The application identified the quantum sought by the Applicants as $19,389.81 and included documentation in terms of an assessment of legal costs undertaken by Hartwell Legal Costs (dated 27 March 2015).

  4. Further attached was correspondence generated by the Regulator (dated 27 October 2015) which confirmed an offer in terms of costs in the amount of $10,905.60.

  5. On 29 January 2016 Solicitors acting on behalf of the Applicants rejected the proposal of the Regulator and put forward a slightly amended costs claim of $19,436.51.

  6. A Directions Order was issued on 9 June 2016 requiring the parties to file and serve an outline of argument and supporting material by 4.00 pm on Wednesday 29 June 2016 with any outlines in reply and supporting material to be filed by 4.00 pm on Wednesday 20 July 2016.

  7. The matter was set down for hearing at 10.00 am on 3 August 2016.

    Written Submissions

    Applicants

  8. The Applicant's calculation of the costs payable were set out in their written submissions as follows:

Item Description Amount
1 Instructions to sue $825.00
5(a) Preparation for trial $2,505.00
6(d) To conference with witnesses (6 hours) $1,086.00
6(e) To advise on evidence $201.00
6(f) On trial or hearing - first day $1,120.00
6(g) On each subsequent day (3 days) $2,250.00
8(a) Attendance of solicitor $2,250.00
11(a)(i) Instructions for disclosure - allowance to party requesting disclosure

$284.00

11(a)(ii) Instructions for…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Connolly and Connolly v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QIRC 104
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Connolly and Connolly, the applicants, against Simon Blackwood, the Workers' Compensation Regulator, who is the respondent. The dispute centres around the awarding of costs in proceedings before the Industrial Commission of Queensland. The applicants sought an order for costs from the Industrial Commission, which was denied by the Regulator. The applicants then appealed to the Industrial Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issue was whether the Industrial Commission had the authority to award costs to the applicants beyond what was permitted under sections 132(2)(a) and 132(2)(b) of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld). The applicants argued that the Commission had the discretion to award costs beyond these sections, while the Regulator contended that the legislation limited the allowable costs to those specified in the sections.

The Industrial Court found that the legislation clearly limited the types and amount of costs that could be awarded. Section 132(3) provided the only discretion regarding the quantum of costs, which did not apply to the present application. The court concluded that the applicants' argument that the Commission could award costs beyond what was permitted by the Act was incorrect. The court also noted that there was no evidence to support the applicants' claim that certain witnesses were "professional witnesses" under the Uniform Civil Procedure (Fees) Regulation 2009 (Qld).

The Industrial Court dismissed the applicants' application for costs and ordered the Regulator to pay the applicants $10,610.90 for costs relating to matter WC/2013/174 within 21 days of the release of the decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Regulator is ordered to pay the Applicants an amount of $10,610.90 for costs relating to matter WC/2013/174 within 21 days of the release of this decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further there was no evidence that established Ogilvie as a "professional witness".Conclusion The legislature had seen fit to limit costs which may be awarded to a successful party in proceedings before the Industrial Magistrate or Industrial Commission. The only discretion allowed in relation to the quantum of costs is provided for by s 132(3) which is not relevant to the present application. Accordingly there is no power for the Commission to award the Applicant's costs they seek.Orders The Regulator seeks an order that this application for costs be dismissed and that costs incurred in defending this application be awarded to the Regulator.Applicants in Reply The Applicant's took exception to the Regulator's submission regarding ss 132(2)(a) and 132(2)(b) in that only costs referred to in these sections are permitted to be awarded by the Commission because in their view s 132 does not state that is the case. Further the submissions around the "specific items" advanced by the Regulator were disputed with reliance again on the earlier submissions of the Applicants. Additionally there was dispute in terms of the Regulator's position on the Hartwell Legal Costs. On the issue of Jahnke's evidence it was crucial to the outcome of the substantive matter regardless of whether it had been explicitly mentioned by the Commission or otherwise. Given that the evidence of Trevor Connolly was also criticised by the Commission, the Applicants submit that any evidence having effect on discrediting Jahnke as a witness was vitally important. The Commission had at paragraphs 149, 158 and 185 of the substantive decision raised issues regarding Jahnke being a witness of credit and in particular in paragraph 149 stated: With respect to the definition of a "professional witness" it is the Uniform Civil Procedures (Fees) Regulation 2009 that defines such a person "as a witness, who attends court to give evidence of a professional nature". The word "professional" is not specifically defined and should be interpreted in accordance to the natural meaning of the word. It had been established at the trial that Ogilvie was an investigator employed by IGV, therefore deriving her income from the employment and therefore in the case a "professional witness". The Applicants submit that the Commission may award costs of the IVG and that those costs are recoverable in full.Regulator in Reply On the primary submission of the Applicant's their position that "Rule 132 of WCRR does not provide a limit on the amount that is recoverable with respect to the outlays and disbursement, and it is submitted that such costs are recoverable in full" it was said to be not consistent with the wording of the Act and Regulation where the following is outlined: Scale E has no provision for "outlays and disbursement" making the Applicant's submission contrary to the legislation. The Regulator does not cavil with the general proposition outlined by the Applicants regarding the presumption at general law that costs follows the event and the onus is upon the Regulator to establish a basis for departure from such presumption. However these proceedings relate not to the award of costs but rather the general quantum of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established