JUDGMENT No. ........ ........ 1070 1.42 ,. ., o.,oGveu
IN THE F W R A L COURT OF AUSTRALIA 1 BE: REUTER v. COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION:
BETWEEN : LAWRENCE ROBERT CONNELT! Applicant
AND : COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION Respondent
CORAM: Burchett J.
PLACE: PerthDATE : 2 December 1992
Well, I think the appropriate thing to do is to dismiss
this present application on the footing that it is premature
| W' | to attempt to decide whether there will in fact be any real problem occasioned by the calling of Mr Connell to give evidence. We do not know at this stage precisely how his evidence, if he is to proceed to give it, will fit in with the exigencies of two other proceedings which apparently have already been fixed for dates involving a total overlap. It is apparent that those who have not changed the existing times for hearing have not as yet been persuaded that such an | |
| ||
| In the circumstances, it seems to me that the normal course ought to be followed, by which I mean that those representing Mr Connell should approach the solicitors by whom the subpoena was issued to ascertain when his attendance will be required. I have been informed that it is expected his evidence in chief will take a period of approximately one hour; having regard to that, it may well be that his attendance under the subpoena will be quite brief. With the ordinary co-operation between the representatives of the | ||
| L | parties, it is likely that there will in fact be no great problem. If a problem does develop, it is a problem which courts are used to dealing with, and an appropriate application will be able to be made during the running of the cases to any one or more of the three persons acting as judge or magistrate in the various proceedings. Accordingly, the present application is dismissed. I will make no order as to costs. | |
| L/ | &R G E N W then applied for leave to file and serve a fresh | |
| ||
| reasons I have just delivered. I think that is an inappropriate application. It seems to me that the appropriate application - if you run into real problems - is not to set aside the subpoena, but to ask the judge dealing with the matter to exercise a discretion as to when your client is called. It is a different thing. |
I certify that this and the preceding two (2) pages are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment herein of his Honour Mr Justice Burchett.
(3-- - -
Associate : D & 'Lb-$-, Date: 2 December 1992
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr N.P. Gentilli
of Messrs Jackson
McDonaldSolicitors for the Applicant: Messrs Jackson
McDonaldCounsel for the Respondent: Mr E.M Heenan…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Connell v Commissioner of Taxation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] FCA 1090
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the subpoena should be set aside due to a potential scheduling conflict. The court had to determine whether it was appropriate to address the issue at the preliminary stage of the proceedings or if it should wait until the conflict actually arose.
The court held that it was premature to decide whether there would be any real problem with the scheduling conflict. The court reasoned that the appropriate course of action was for the applicant's representatives to contact the solicitors who issued the subpoena to determine the exact requirements for Connell's attendance. Given that Connell's evidence was expected to take about an hour, it was likely that the attendance under the subpoena would be brief. The court concluded that any scheduling issues could be resolved through co-operation between the parties and, if necessary, addressed during the proceedings before the relevant judge or magistrate. Therefore, the application to set aside the subpoena was dismissed.
The court made no order as to costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Connell applied for leave to set aside the subpoena on the grounds that it would cause him inconvenience due to overlapping court dates. The application was heard by Burchett J in the Federal Court of Australia in Perth on 2 December 1992. The court dismissed the application, holding that it was premature to decide whether there would be any real problem. Burchett J suggested that Mr Connell's representatives should first approach the solicitors who issued the subpoena to ascertain the exact timing of his attendance. The judge also noted that if any problems arose, appropriate applications could be made during the running of the cases to the judge or magistrate dealing with the matter.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the subpoena should be set aside due to potential scheduling conflicts with other court proceedings.
2. Whether it is appropriate to seek an order from the judge or magistrate to exercise discretion over when the applicant is called to give evidence if problems arise.
Held
1. The court dismissed the application to set aside the subpoena due to potential scheduling conflicts with other court proceedings, finding it premature to decide if there would be any real problem.
2. The court declined to grant leave to apply for an order from the judge or magistrate to exercise discretion over when the applicant is called to give evidence, if problems arise, considering such an application to be inappropriate.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court determined that it was premature to decide whether the scheduling conflicts would pose a real problem, given the uncertainty about how the applicant's evidence would fit with other proceedings. Burchett J noted that the representatives of the parties should first approach the solicitors who issued the subpoena to ascertain when the applicant's attendance would be required. The court also highlighted that if a problem does arise, it is one that courts are accustomed to dealing with, and an appropriate application can be made during the proceedings. The judge found that setting aside the subpoena was an inappropriate application, and instead suggested that if real problems occur, the appropriate action would be to ask the judge to exercise discretion as to when the client is called. This decision adheres to the principle that scheduling conflicts and logistical issues are typically managed during the course of proceedings rather than preemptively.