CONFIDENTIAL and CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

[2013] AATA  81

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/4724

Re

CONFIDENTIAL

APPLICANT

And

CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member

Date 19 February 2013
Place Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

....................................[Sgd]...................................

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member

IT IS NOTED THAT PUBLICATION OF THIS DECISION IS APPROVED BY THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL PURSUANT TO S 110X(4)(H) OF THE CHILD SUPPORT (REGISTRATION AND COLLECTION) ACT 1988 (CTH).

 

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – Departure prohibition order – No grounds requiring revocation of departure prohibition order – No grounds for exercising discretion to revoke departure prohibition order – Use of the Guide – Decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 72D, 72I, 72K

CASES
Onder & Child Support Registrar and Sari (No 2) (2011) 250 FLR 345
Re O’Neill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant is the father of K. He and K’s mother are divorced. Pursuant to a child assessment agreement registered in 2003, the applicant was liable to pay child support payments to the mother until K was 18 years of age. The applicant made timely and appropriate fortnightly payments until October 2008 but, from 1 November 2008 to 20 November 2012, his payments were in arrears by $61,410.41 and the Child Support Registrar (CSR) assessed him as having a child support debt of $74,124.34. This included a penalty component of $12,713.93.

  2. From 2008 to 2012, the applicant travelled outside Australia on several occasions including to France from where he returned on 15 June 2012. On 27 June 2012, the CSR imposed, under s 72D of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”), a Departure Prohibition Order (DPO) on the applicant which had the effect of prohibiting him from departing Australia for a foreign country. On 21 September 2012, the CSR refused to revoke the DPO. The applicant sought review of that decision on 18 October 2012.

    ISSUES AND LEGISLATION

  3. The Objects of the Act are set out in s 3 thereof and read:

    3 Objects of Act

    1The principal objects of this Act are to ensure:

    (a)that children receive from their parents the financial support that the parents are liable to provide; and

    (b)that periodic amounts payable by parents towards the maintenance of their children are paid on a regular and timely basis; and

    (c)that Australia is in a position to give effect to its obligations under international agreements or arrangements relating to maintenance obligations arising from family relationship, parentage or marriage.

    2It is the intention of the Parliament that this Act shall be construed and administered, to the greatest extent consistent with the attainment of its objects, to limit interferences with the privacy of persons.

  4. Provision is made for revocation of a DPO in s 72I of the Act which, in so far as relevant, reads:

    72I Revocation and variation of departure…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CONFIDENTIAL and CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of CONFIDENTIAL and CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR, the applicant sought revocation of a departure prohibition order (DPO) imposed by the Child Support Registrar (CSR) under ss 72I(1) or (3) of the Child Support (Registration and Recovery) Act 1988. The applicant contended that the DPO should be revoked on the basis that he had no assets or income apart from his disability support pension (DSP), and that he lacked the capacity to meet his child support liability. The applicant argued that the CSR had unreasonably refused his request to travel to Japan with his new girlfriend, and that the DPO amounted to punishment and house arrest.

The primary issue for the court was whether there were grounds under ss 72I(1) or (3) of the Act to revoke the DPO. The court found that the applicant's financial circumstances did not justify revocation of the DPO. The applicant had a significant ongoing involvement in a timber business which provided him with financial resources. The applicant's child support liability was not irrecoverable and he was capable of meeting his child support obligations. The court was not satisfied that the DPO should be varied to allow the applicant to travel to Japan. The decision under review was affirmed.

The court held that the applicant's financial situation and the terms of the Guide did not provide grounds for revoking the DPO under s 72I(1) of the Act. The applicant's child support liability was not completely irrecoverable given his involvement in the timber business. The court also found that the DPO should not be varied to allow the applicant to travel to Japan under s 72I(3) of the Act. The decision of the CSR was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In this matter, the Tribunal is not dealing with the matter of whether or not the DPO should have been made by the CSR.[1] The issue for determination is whether the DPO should be revoked under ss 72I(1) or (3) of the Act. EVIDENCE[1] See Re O’Neill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545 [26].The applicant The applicant gave the following evidence. He has been unemployed since 2008 and has been in receipt of the disability support pension (DSP) under the Social Security Act 1991 since October 2010. He and his wife were divorced in 2003. Following this, he worked with and then lived in a de facto relationship with Ms P until December 2010. He is now associated with another woman whom he variously described as his new girlfriend and his partner. He said that her parents live in Japan and that his reason for seeking revocation of the DPO was to enable him to travel there with her, at her expense, to meet them. He described them as aged and not well enough to travel to Australia. He said that his offer to post a bond, to be provided by his new girlfriend, with the CSR as security for his return to Australia had been rejected. The applicant worked as a tiler with his father and in 1996 commenced business as a sole trader manufacturing timber products. In 2004, he commenced an association with Ms P who became an investor in the timber business which was incorporated in 2005 as ABC Pty Ltd. He and Ms P were sole directors and shareholders in the company and were its only full time employees. The business was very successful, especially when it expanded to include international marketing of its products. Stresses attributed by the applicant to his involvement in Family Court proceedings with his wife from 2003 to 2008, as well as a workplace injury, forced him to stop work in 2008. He has not been in remunerative work since. The applicant resigned as a director of the company in September 2008 and, in March 2010, transferred his shares to Ms P. He was unsure how that transaction came about but said that Ms P had his power of attorney in relation to financial matters. He received no payment for his interest in the company and explained that he was financially “screwed” by her as he had been by his wife. He agreed that Ms P still uses his name in business documentation, bank records and on the business website. Though he denied any involvement with the business, he stated he provides assistance, without charge, to Ms P when she requires it. He explained that he does this because he has greater expertise than she does in the technical aspects of the timber business. He shares the same Post Office mail box as the company but collects only his personal mail from it. The applicant said that he has no savings, no assets except for personal items and no income apart from his DSP. He agreed that he had made all required child support payments until October 2008 and that $44.04 automatically has been deducted each fortnight for child support payments from his DSP. He voluntarily paid an additional $50 per fortnight in child support from November 2011 after he was advised that, by so doing, he would avoid a DPO. He ceased that voluntary payment when the DPO was imposed in June 2012. The applicant agreed that his reduced rate of child support payments since October 2008 meant that he had accumulated a liability. He did not dispute the respondent’s calculations of that debt and agreed that a non-payment penalty, as stated by the respondent, had been added to the debt.

Decision

Reasons for decision

That decision is consistent with the principal object of the Act to ensure that children receive from their parents the financial support that the parents are liable to provide.[6] The Act also provides that it is to be construed and administered, to the greatest extent consistent with the attainment of its objects.[7] That object is also relevant to the discretion in s 72I(3) of the Act. Given the financial circumstances of the applicant, I am satisfied that it is not desirable that the DPO be revoked. As to the variation of the DPO, I have noted the terms of the Guide which provides that a DPO should be varied only to correct errors on the face of the order and that a DPO should not be varied to allow the departure from Australia of a child support debtor. There is no material which points to an error on the face of the DPO and I am satisfied that it should not be varied. [6] See s 3(1)(a) of the Act and para 3 (above).[7] See s 3(2) of the Act and para 3 (above).DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant submitted that he had no assets and no income apart from his DSP; that he had no capacity to meet the child support liability alleged against him by the CSR; that irrelevant matters had been relied on and relevant matters had not been considered by the CSR in calculating that liability; that the liability was irrecoverable because of his financial situation; that the CSR was acting unreasonably in refusing his request to travel to Japan with his new girlfriend especially when he had proposed that a bond be provided to ensure his return to Australia; and that the CSR decision amounted to punishment of him with a consequence that he was being treated like a criminal and was effectively being held under “house arrest”. CONSIDERATION I have noted the matters raised by the applicant in his submissions. As noted above, concern here is not with the merits of the decision to impose the DPO. As to his request to travel to Japan, reference was made during the hearing to the prospects of his applying for a Departure Authorisation Certificate (a DAC).[5] I have also noted his submissions concerning the consequences of a DPO being made and have referred below to the significance of the Objects of the Act in that regard. [5] A DAC may be sought under s 72K of the Act. I had concerns with the applicant’s evidence and do not accept that he was a witness of truth in aspects of it. In particular, that is the case with his explanations of arrangements with Ms P and of his recent association with the timber business. His assertion that he had no role in the business for some years following the sale is not consistent with the continued use of his name in bank accounts, with payments of administration charges to his Visa Gold account, with the continued use of the same postal address as the business and with the extent of travel with Ms P as recently as February to April last year. Inconsistency also arises in his claim that he was “screwed” financially by Ms P and yet remains willing to provide, free of charge, technical advice to assist Ms P with her business. The applicant clearly played a significant role in settling the arrangements for the auction of the business assets and I note the statement by the Director of Quaid Auctioneers that he initially introduced himself as an employee of the business. The applicant had difficulty in giving an accurate account of his accommodation arrangements. He gave various accounts of these arrangements until he settled on the split arrangement between his new girlfriend’s home and the unit owned by Ms P. Ms P provides that accommodation without cost to the applicant and he resided, on his evidence, in the unit at the business premises for long periods free of charge even though he claimed to have no role in the running of the business. I am satisfied that the applicant continues to have an involvement in the business which he established and I accept the analysis of the SSAT that this provided him with a financial resource which places him in a situation where he is capable of meeting his child support obligations. I accept the submissions of Ms Smith that, under s 72I(1)(a) of the Act, the applicant has a child support liability of $688.06 per fortnight as well as a child support debt, including penalty components, of $79,657.74 as at 6 February 2013, which is due and payable by him. Given his child support liability of $688.06 per fortnight, I accept Ms Smith’s submission that his current payment rate of $44.04 per fortnight is not a satisfactory arrangement in order for the applicant’s liability to be wholly discharged under s 72I(1)(b) of the Act. I am also satisfied that, under s 72I(1)(c) of the Act, the applicant’s liability is not completely irrecoverable because of the availability to him of financial resources associated with the business. It follows that I am not required, under s 72I(1) of the Act, to revoke the DPO.