[2015] QCA 64
COURT OF APPEAL
HOLMES JA
Appeal No 10232 of 2014
SC No 9012 of 2006
SALVATORE CONDO
MARIA CONDO Applicants
v
TIEN NGUYEN
TUOI DANG Respondents
BRISBANE
THURSDAY, 23 APRIL 2015
JUDGMENT
HOLMES JA: The applicants seek a stay of a judgment given for equitable compensation arising out of what the trial judge found to be an agreement between them and the respondents, by which the applicants were to transfer a half interest in their property at Esk to the respondents in exchange for their undertaking the running of the property, establishing a vineyard on it and committing the sum of $140,000 to improvements and maintenance.
The parties had compromised parts of their claims, each agreeing by deed not to require the other to account for moneys received and profits made from the sale of agricultural produce from the land. The trial judge struck out a paragraph of the amended defence and counterclaim which included an allegation by the applicants that the respondents had not accounted to them for income generated from their use of the property, on the ground that it was the subject of the deed of compromise.
The trial judge preferred the evidence of the respondents, and found that they had proved expenditures totalling some $217,000 made by them in reliance on the applicants’ assurance that they would transfer a one-half share in the property to them. She awarded equitable compensation in that amount, with interest. The judgment is appealed on the grounds which are, that the trial judge erred in failing to have proper regard to evidence going to the proper measure of equitable compensation and that she erred in applying the principles of equitable compensation in calculating the compensation to be paid. Other grounds of appeal have previously been abandoned.
In February this year, the respondents sought security for the costs of the appeal. They had by that stage served bankruptcy notices with which the applicants had failed to comply. On the hearing of the security for costs application before Gotterson JA, it emerged that three of the five grounds of appeal were abandoned and that the live issue was whether the trial judge should have ordered compensation of $217,000 (the amount expended in reliance on the assurance) or $140,000 (the amount the subject of the agreement to transfer the half interest in the property).
I should say, however, that Mr Hall here today argued that there may still be a surviving argument in respect of the $140,000, that the compromise would not preclude an accounting of the profits that the respondents had made on the farm, in order to set it off against the $140,000. He distinguishes between taking an account of profits for that purpose, and taking an account in order to confer a separate remedy. I am unconvinced that that argument has any prospect of success, and it does not seem, I must say, particularly consistent with the way matters were put before Gotterson JA.
At any rate, Gotterson…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Condo v Nguyen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] QCA 64
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal considered the arguments regarding the measure of equitable compensation and the application of the compromise agreement. The court noted that the respondents had conceded a liability to pay $140,000, which was the amount agreed upon for the transfer of the property interest, but had not paid any part of it. The court found that the appeal had a potential merit in that the compensation should not have exceeded the $140,000 amount. However, the court was also concerned about the applicants' likelihood of bankruptcy, which could significantly diminish the prospects of the appeal proceeding. The court found that a partial stay of the judgment would not prevent the bankruptcy proceedings from continuing for the balance of the judgment, rendering the stay ineffective. Therefore, the court refused the application for a stay of the judgment.
The Court of Appeal concluded that the balance of convenience weighed against the granting of a stay, and the respondents were awarded their costs of the application. The court found that the argument for taking an account of profits without breaching the compromise agreement was unconvincing, and therefore, the appeal did not have a sufficient prospect of success to warrant a stay of the entire judgment.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.