HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Mason C.J., Wilson, Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ.
COMPTROLLER OF STAMPS v. ASHWICK (VIC.) No. 4 PTY. LTD.
10 December 1987
Decision
MASON C.J., WILSON, DAWSON, TOOHEY AND GAUDRON JJ. This is an appeal from a decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Kaye, Murphy and Tadgell JJ.) upholding an objection to an assessment of stamp duty upon an instrument of transfer. The assessment was made by the appellant in reliance upon s.32 and Heading VI of the Third Schedule of the Stamps Act 1958 (Vict.) ("the Act").
2. The instrument in question was dated 7 November 1984 and was executed by Carlton and United Breweries Limited ("C.U.B.") and the respondent. By it C.U.B. transferred land to the respondent for a consideration expressed as follows:
"The Transferee is entitled to the transfer of the land as a shareholder in the Transferor in the course of a distribution of assets of the Transferor in consequence of the reduction of the capital of the Transferor. The Transferee's entitlement arises upon the redemption of 10,000 Class Four redeemable preference shares held by the Transferee in the capital of the Transferor."The appellant ruled that the instrument was liable to duty of $47,229 calculated on an ad valorem basis, the property having a value of $899,557. An objection to the assessment was disallowed and an appeal against the disallowance came before Crockett J. who ordered, pursuant to s.44 of the Supreme Court Act 1958 (Vict.), that the case be argued before the Full Court.
3. The respondent has objected to the assessment on the ground that the instrument was wholly exempt from duty by reason of the provisions of exemption (19) under Heading VI of the Third Schedule to the Act. That exemption reads:
"Any instrument for the conveyance of any real property held by a company where the conveyance is made to a shareholder of the company in the course of any distribution of assets of the company in consequence of the reduction of the capital of the company."The Full Court was of the view, with which we agree, that the "capital" referred to in the exemption is the share capital of the transferor company.
4. The case has been conducted on the basis of an agreed statement of facts. Tadgell J. (with whose reasons for judgment Kaye and Murphy JJ. agreed), summarized those facts as follows:
"For many years before 1984 C.U.B., which among other things manufactures and sells beer, owned a number of hotels in Victoria and elsewhere which it leased to the licensees of the hotels. In the second half of 1984 C.U.B. decided to enable such of a number of its Victorian hotel tenants as chose to do so to obtain an equity in the hotels which they leased by becoming fifty per cent shareholders in the companies which it was proposed should own the hotels. Those companies were respectively known as Ashwick (Vic.) No. ( ) Pty. Ltd., each…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Comptroller of Stamps v Ashwick (Vic) No 4 Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1987] HCA 60
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Comptroller of Stamps (the appellant) appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria concerning the assessment of stamp duty on a transfer of shares. The respondent, Ashwick (Vic) No 4 Pty Ltd, had acquired shares in a company, and the Comptroller sought to assess stamp duty on this transaction. The dispute centred on whether the transfer of shares constituted a "dutiable transaction" under the relevant Victorian legislation, specifically the *Stamps Act 1958* (Vic).
The High Court was required to determine whether the transfer of shares from one entity to another, where the ultimate beneficial ownership of the shares remained unchanged, was subject to stamp duty. The core legal question was whether the transaction fell within the definition of a dutiable transaction, particularly in light of provisions that might exempt transactions where there was no change in beneficial ownership. The court also considered the interpretation of "dutiable property" and "dutiable transaction" within the context of the *Stamps Act 1958*.
The High Court, in a joint judgment, held that the transfer of shares was indeed a dutiable transaction. The court reasoned that the *Stamps Act 1958* imposed duty on the *conveyance* of dutiable property, and a transfer of shares constituted such a conveyance. While acknowledging that the beneficial ownership may not have changed in substance, the court emphasised that the legal title to the shares had been transferred. The legislation was concerned with the legal incidence of the transfer, not solely with the underlying economic or beneficial ownership. The court applied the principle that stamp duty legislation is generally construed according to its literal terms, and the transfer of legal title to shares was a clear event triggering the imposition of duty.
The appeal was allowed, and the order of the Supreme Court of Victoria was set aside. The matter was remitted to the Comptroller of Stamps for assessment of duty in accordance with the judgment of the High Court.
The High Court was required to determine whether the transfer of shares from one entity to another, where the ultimate beneficial ownership of the shares remained unchanged, was subject to stamp duty. The core legal question was whether the transaction fell within the definition of a dutiable transaction, particularly in light of provisions that might exempt transactions where there was no change in beneficial ownership. The court also considered the interpretation of "dutiable property" and "dutiable transaction" within the context of the *Stamps Act 1958*.
The High Court, in a joint judgment, held that the transfer of shares was indeed a dutiable transaction. The court reasoned that the *Stamps Act 1958* imposed duty on the *conveyance* of dutiable property, and a transfer of shares constituted such a conveyance. While acknowledging that the beneficial ownership may not have changed in substance, the court emphasised that the legal title to the shares had been transferred. The legislation was concerned with the legal incidence of the transfer, not solely with the underlying economic or beneficial ownership. The court applied the principle that stamp duty legislation is generally construed according to its literal terms, and the transfer of legal title to shares was a clear event triggering the imposition of duty.
The appeal was allowed, and the order of the Supreme Court of Victoria was set aside. The matter was remitted to the Comptroller of Stamps for assessment of duty in accordance with the judgment of the High Court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi