Commonwealth of Australia v Lyon

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commonwealth of Australia v Lyon [2003] FCAFC 284

JURISDICTION – proceeding in Federal Court of Australia - whether jurisdiction under par 39B(1A)(a) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) invoked - application by Commonwealth for a declaration – whether an application made in respect of a ‘matter’ – whether claim gives rise to a justiciable controversy in the Federal Court – whether claim is a criminal matter within the meaning of par 39B(1A)(c).

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 21, 50
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B
Law and Justice Legislation Amendment Act 1999 (Cth) Sch 10
Constitution ss 71, 75, 76, 77

Ainsworthv Criminal JusticeCommission (1992) 175 CLR 564 referred to
Amand v Home Secretary [1943] AC 147 referred to
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Edensor Nominees Pty Limited (2001) 204 CLR 559 referred to
Baxter v Commissioner of Taxation (1907) 4 CLR 1087 cited
Chief Executive Officer of Customs v Jiang (2001)111 FCR 395 referred to
Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police v Poompiriyapinte (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Badgery‑Parker J, 28 August 1990) discussed
Crouch v Commissioner for Railways (Qld) (1985) 159 CLR 22 referred to
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v State Bank of New South Wales (1992) 174 CLR 219 referred to
DPP v Smith (1996) 86 A Crim R 308 discussed
Felton v Mulligan (1971) 124 CLR 367 referred to
Harris v Caladine (1991) 172 CLR 84 referred to
Jacobsen v Rogers (1995) 182 CLR 672 cited
Khatri v Price (1999) 95 FCR 287 referred to
Phong v Attorney‑General of the Commonwealth (2001) 114 FCR 75 referred to
R v Southampton Justices, ex part Green [1975] 2 ALL ER 1073 referred to
Re Macks; Ex parte Saint (2000) 204 CLR 158 cited
R v Stipendiary Magistrateat Lambeth [1983] 1 All ER 321 referred to
Sankey v Whitlam (1978) 142 CLR 1 considered

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA & COMMISSIONER OF THE AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE v PAUL LYON & FRANK PATRICK BARBARO & ARTHUR JOSEPH LOVEDAY & JOSEPH ALEXANDER CASSAR & FRANK VELARDI & PETER PANGALLO & ROBERT IBRAHIM & AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION & SEVEN NETWORK PTY LTD & NINE NETWORK PTY LTD & JOHN FAIRFAX PUBLICATIONS PTY LTD & NEWS LIMITED

N 1706 of 2003

BRANSON, MADGWICK and HELY JJ
SYDNEY
12 DECEMBER 2003


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1706 of 2003

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
FIRST APPELLANT

COMMISSIONER OF THE AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE
SECOND APPELLANT

AND:

PAUL LYON
FIRST RESPONDENT

FRANK PATRICK BARBARO
SECOND RESPONDENT

ARTHUR JOSEPH LOVEDAY
THIRD RESPONDENT

JOSEPH ALEXANDER CASSAR
FOURTH RESPONDENT

FRANK VELARDI
FIFTH RESPONDENT

PETER PANGALLO
SIXTH RESPONDENT

ROBERT IBRAHIM
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

SEVEN NETWORK PTY LTD
NINTH RESPONDENT

NINE NETWORK PTY LTD
TENTH RESPONDENT

JOHN FAIRFAX PUBLICATIONS PTY LTD
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

NEWS LIMITED
TWELFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

BRANSON, MADGWICK and HELY JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

12…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth of Australia v Lyon and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCAFC 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commonwealth of Australia v Lyon involved the Commonwealth challenging the decision of the Federal Court to suppress certain details of a medical certificate that was central to committal proceedings. The respondents were charged with drug offences under New South Wales laws, and the central witness, who was a protected witness, was subject to cross-examination under an agreement with the Director of Public Prosecutions. An issue arose about the central witness's health, which led to a medical certificate being tendered in court. It was later discovered that the doctor who issued the certificate might not have examined the witness and may not have practiced at the address listed on the certificate. The certificate was issued by a doctor who was a member of the Australian Federal Police. This revelation led to controversy, prompting the Commonwealth to seek an order to suppress certain details of the certificate. The Magistrate initially made an interim suppression order, which led to further submissions on whether the contentious details could be published.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Federal Court had jurisdiction to make the suppression order and if the orders made by the primary judge were correct. The court needed to determine if the Federal Court's jurisdiction extended to the matter in question, given that it involved a criminal prosecution. Additionally, the court had to consider the implications of the suppression order on the principles of open justice and whether the orders were appropriate given the circumstances. The court also had to examine the arguments regarding public interest immunity and the Witness Protection Act.

In its decision, the court concluded that the appeal should be allowed, and the orders made by the primary judge should be set aside. The matter was remitted to the primary judge for hearing and determination. The court found that the Law and Justice Legislation Amendment Act 1999 and the Judiciary Act accurately reflected what was enacted by Parliament, and thus did not affect the jurisdiction of the Federal Court. The court did not need to determine whether the words of exclusion at the end of par 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act qualified the conferrals of jurisdiction, as the appeal's outcome rendered this issue unnecessary. The court also noted that it did not accept the respondents' analysis of the effect of those words.

The court's final orders included allowing the appeal, setting aside the orders made by the primary judge, and remitting the matter for hearing and determination. The court stood the proceeding over to a date to be fixed for making an order or orders as to costs. The parties were directed to provide an agreed minute of the order or orders to be made as to costs by a specified date, or if agreement had not been reached, to provide the minutes of order for which they would contend and brief outlines of submissions in support of the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed and orders 1, 2 and 3 made by the primary judge on 22 October 2003 be set aside.

2. Subject to paragraphs 3 and 4 hereof the matter be remitted to the primary judge for hearing and determination.

3. The proceeding be stood over to a date to be fixed for the purpose of making an order or orders as to costs.

4. The parties who appeared at the hearing of this appeal provide to the Associate of Branson J by 19 December 2003 an agreed minute of the order or orders to be made as to costs and if agreement has not then been reached, the minutes of order for which they will respectively contend and brief outlines of submissions in support of the orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons given below, we have concluded that the appeal should be allowed, orders 1, 2 and 3 made by the primary judge on 22 October 2003 set aside and the matter remitted to the primary judge to be heard and determined. The contentious material should be protected from further publication in the meantime.BACKGROUND FACTS The primary judge summarised the history to the proceedings in [4]-[7] of his Honour’s reasons for judgment. Those paragraphs read as follows:‘It is unnecessary to descend into great detail about the events leading to the commencement of these proceedings to deal with jurisdictional issues. However, some of the background should be noted. The following is drawn from both the evidence and statements by counsel in these proceedings, which I apprehend are uncontentious. The second to seventh respondents have been charged with drug offences under New South Wales laws. The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions New South Wales (“the DPP”) has carriage of the committal proceedings for the Crown. One witness whose statement is to be relied on by the DPP in the committal proceedings (“the central witness”), is to be cross-examined by at least counsel for the second respondent and counsel for the fourth respondent. This was as a result of an agreement with the DPP under s 48E of the Justices Act 1902 (NSW). The central witness is a protected witness under the Witness Protection Act.An issue arose in the committal proceedings about whether the central witness was able to undergo cross-examination because of his health. The committal proceedings were scheduled to commence on Monday 15 September 2003. On Friday 12 September 2003 the DPP sought an adjournment of the committal proceedings. In support of this application a medical certificate was furnished concerning the health of the central witness. The certificate contained the name of the doctor who had created the certificate and an address, ostensibly the address of a doctor’s practice, as well as a telephone number. These are the details to which the orders sought (set out at [3] above) relate. The certificate was ultimately tendered in the committal proceedings (on 15 September 2003) by counsel for the fourth respondent.It emerged in the committal proceedings that the doctor may not have examined the central witness and the address may not have been an address at which the doctor practised. It also emerged that the doctor was a member of the Australian Federal Police and that the central witness was a protected witness. That the DPP had sought to rely on a medical certificate of this kind became a controversial issue in the committal proceedings. The proceedings continued on Monday 15 and Wednesday 17 September 2003 in which issues relating to the medical certificate were ventilated. On the evening of Wednesday 17 September 2003 the Magistrate was asked by the Commonwealth interests to make an order suppressing certain details of the certificate. This application was made ex parte.The Magistrate made an interim suppression order and the following day commenced to hear submissions about whether the contentious details on the certificate could be published or should be suppressed. In the context of this debate, the Commonwealth interests sought to read a confidential affidavit (sworn probably on 18 September 2003) from the Acting Deputy Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police in support of a claim for public interest immunity in relation to the medical certificate or at least certain information in it. However, as earlier noted, the Witness Protection Act was also called in aid by the Commonwealth interests. Two other affidavits of the Acting Deputy Commissioner were used in the committal proceedings. One was relied on during the hearing on Wednesday 17 September 2003 and the other was an open affidavit of 18 September 2003 in support of the claim of public interest immunity.’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is thus unnecessary for us to give further consideration to the arguments identified in [45] above. We record, however, that in our view it has not been demonstrated that the Law and Justice Legislation Amendment Act 1999 (Cth), including Schedule 10 thereof which amended the Judiciary Act, and Reprint 6 of the Judiciary Act, in each case as prepared by the Office of Legislative Drafting, Attorney-General’s Department Canberra and published by the Commonwealth, do not accurately reflect what was enacted by Parliament. Whether subsection 39B(1A), in the form which it took after it was amended in 1999, discloses a legislative intention that the closing words of par 39B(1A)(c) qualify the conferrals of jurisdiction affected by pars (a) and (b) is an issue which should await determination in a case which calls for that issue to be determined.CONCLUSION The appeal will be allowed and the proceeding remitted to the primary judge for hearing and determination. The parties indicated during the course of the hearing that it would be appropriate for consideration of the appropriate order as to costs to await the publication of these reasons for judgment. Orders will be made for any dispute as to the appropriate order as to costs to be determined on written submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

His Honour’s above conclusion made it strictly unnecessary for him to determine whether the Court also lacked jurisdiction by reason of the words of exclusion at the end of par 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act. However, his Honour indicated that he did not accept the respondents’ analysis of the effect of those words. By a notice of contention the media interests gave notice that they contend that the decision of the primary judge should be affirmed on the ground that:‘The Federal Court has no jurisdiction under any paragraph of sub‑section 39B(1A) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) in relation to a matter in respect of which a criminal prosecution is instituted or any other criminal matter.’CONSIDERATIONJurisdiction of the Federal Court As this appeal is concerned with the extent of the jurisdiction of the Federal Court, it is appropriate to refer to the nature and source of the jurisdiction of the Court. Section 71 of the Constitution relevantly provides that:‘The judicial power of the Commonwealth shall be vested in a Federal Supreme Court, to be called the High Court of Australia, and in such other federal courts as the Parliament creates, and in such other courts as it invests with federal jurisdiction.’ The Federal Court is one of the ‘other federal courts’ which the Parliament has created. The Parliament created the Court by s 5 of the Federal Court Act as a superior court of record and as a court of law and equity. Section 75 of the Constitution directly vests original jurisdiction in the High Court in five categories of ‘matters’. Section 76 authorises the Parliament to make laws conferring original jurisdiction on the High Court in four additional categories of matters. As federal jurisdiction is ‘the authority to adjudicate derived from the Commonwealth Constitution and laws’ (Baxter v Commissioner of Taxation (1907) 4 CLR 1087 at 1142), the jurisdiction referred to in s 75 and s 76 is federal jurisdiction. The appellate jurisdiction of the High Court and the authority implicit in the characterisation of certain federal courts as superior courts of record (see Re Macks; Ex parte Saint [2000] HCA 62; (2000) 204 CLR 158) aside, s 75 and s 76 set the limits of federal jurisdiction. It is a jurisdiction concerning matters. Section 77 of the Constitution authorises the Parliament, with respect to any of the matters mentioned in s 75 and s 76, to make laws defining the jurisdiction of any federal court other than the High Court. This constitutional provision is reflected in s 19(1) of the Federal Court Act which provides that ‘[t]he Court has such original jurisdiction as is vested in it by laws made by Parliament’. The Parliament has not defined the jurisdiction of the Federal Court in a way which includes everything encompassed by s 75 and s 76 of the Constitution. The jurisdiction of the Federal Court is thus not co‑extensive with federal jurisdiction. However, all jurisdiction exercised by the Federal Court is necessarily federal jurisdiction; it is federal jurisdiction even where the law to be applied is not a law made by the Parliament.