Commonwealth Life Assurance Society Ltd v Smith

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read
59 CLR 527

COMMONWEALTH

ASSURANCE

SOCIETY LIMITED SMITH

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Malicious Prosecution-Essentials of action-Innocence of plaintiff-Evidence-

Admissibility-Damages-Termination of criminal proceedings--Refusal by 1937-1938. Attorney-General to file indictment-Nolle prosequi.

The plaintiff brought an action for malicious prosecution arising out of a charge of conspiracy against him, in respect of which charge the Attorney- Aug. 9. 10, 13, General for New South Wales, after the plaintiff had been committed for trial, had refused to file an indictment.

Held that the guilt or innocence of the plaintiff was not an issue going to his cause of action in malicious prosecution.

Davis v. Gell, (1924) 35 C.L.R. 275, in which the proceedings were deter- mined by the entry of a nolle prosequi, distinguished.

Held, further, that the issue of guilt or innocence had no real relevance to damages.

Decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Full Court) reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

In an action for malicious prosecution brought in September 1933, in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, by Sydney Smith against the Commonwealth Life Assurance Society Ltd., the plaintiff in his

59 CLR 528

declaration alleged that the defendant falsely and maliciously and without reasonable or probable cause prosecuted the plaintiff upon a charge of conspiracy with three other persons to cheat and defraud divers shareholders and policy holders of the Commonwealth Life Assurance (Amalgamated) Association and caused him to be arrested, taken before a magistrate and imprisoned until he obtained bail. The plaintiff further alleged in his declaration that he was committed for trial and thereafter and before any trial the Attorney-General for New South Wales declined to proceed further against the plaintiff in respect of the charge and entered a nolle prosequi in respect thereof whereby the prosecution was determined. The plaintiff claimed as damages the sum of £10,000.

The defendant pleaded (a) that it was not guilty, and (b) that the prosecution was not determined as alleged.

The circumstances out of which the prosecution arose are set forth in the judgments delivered in Commonwealth Life Assurance Society Ltd. v. Brain 1.

On 31st October 1934, after a trial which lasted thirty-one days, the jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff in the sum of £5,000. This verdict was set aside by the Full Court of the Supreme Court and a new trial was ordered.

At the second trial of the action the plaintiff insisted that he was entitled to lead evidence to establish affirmatively that he was innocent of the conspiracy with which he had been charged, and, for that purpose, to prove many matters, such as what he had been informed or believed and what circumstances or alleged circumstances actuated his conduct. The defendant objected and maintained that the question of the actual guilt or innocence of the plaintiff formed no part of the issues before the jury. The trial judge, on the authority of the judgments in Davis v. Gell 2

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Life Assurance Society Ltd v Smith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1938] HCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth Life Assurance Society Ltd. appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had dismissed the Society's motion for a new trial. The underlying dispute concerned an action for malicious prosecution brought by Sydney Smith against the Society. Smith alleged that the Society had falsely and maliciously prosecuted him for conspiracy to defraud shareholders and policyholders, causing his arrest, imprisonment, and committal for trial. The prosecution had ultimately been terminated when the Attorney-General for New South Wales declined to file an indictment, a process distinct from a nolle prosequi.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the actual guilt or innocence of the plaintiff, Sydney Smith, was a matter that needed to be proven by him as an element of his cause of action for malicious prosecution, and whether such guilt or innocence was relevant to the assessment of damages. The defendant Society contended that the plaintiff's innocence was not an issue for the jury and that evidence tendered to prove it was inadmissible. The plaintiff, conversely, argued that his innocence was a necessary component of his claim and also relevant to the quantum of damages.

The High Court, in its joint judgment, held that the guilt or innocence of the plaintiff was not an issue going to the cause of action in a claim for malicious prosecution, distinguishing the present case from *Davis v. Gell* which involved a nolle prosequi. The Court reasoned that the requirement for the criminal proceedings to terminate in favour of the accused was sufficient to establish that the prosecution was unfounded, and that this termination did not necessitate proof of actual innocence. Furthermore, the Court determined that the issue of guilt or innocence had no real relevance to the assessment of damages, as reopening this question in civil proceedings would be contrary to public policy and the principle that the propriety of criminal proceedings should not be canvassed.

Consequently, the High Court reversed the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Court found that the admission of evidence concerning the plaintiff's actual guilt or innocence at the trial was erroneous and, given the nature of the evidence, constituted a substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice, entitling the defendant to a new trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.