Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions v Moodliar

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions v Moodliar [2013] QDC 106

PARTIES:

COMMONWEALTH DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
(Appellant)

and

ALISTAIR CLINTON MOODLIAR
(Respondent)

FILE NO:

D486/12

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against sentence

DELIVERED ON:

10 May 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

29 April 2013

JUDGE:

Judge C F Wall QC

ORDERS:

1.       Appeal allowed.

2.       Sentence below set aside and in lieu thereof the respondent is convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for 4 months but is to be released forthwith upon giving security by recognisance in the sum of $500 conditional that he be of good behaviour for 3 months.

LEGISLATION:

Criminal Code 1995 (Cth), section 135
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), sections 16A, 16F, 17A, 19B

CASES:

R v Price (2008) QCA 30
R v Holdsworth (1993) QCA 242
Ryan v R (2001) 286 CLR 267

Guy v Yek [2010] TASSC 34
R v Tsiaris [1996] VR 398
R v Goodger [2009] QCA 377
R v McGlynn [1981] Qd R 526
R v Dunn [1994] QCA 147
R v Neumann ex-parte A-G (Qld) [2007] 1 Qd R 53

CATCHWORDS:

JUSTICES – appeal by Crown against sentence – pharmacist – obtaining a financial advantage – Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme – whether sentence manifestly inadequate – relevance of general deterrence and psychological factors.

COUNSEL:

Mr M Copley SC for the Appellant

Mr M J Byrne QC for the Respondent

SOLICITORS:

Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions for the Appellant

Potts Lawyers for the Respondent

Introduction

  1. On 20 August 2012 the respondent pleaded guilty in the Southport Magistrates Court to one count of obtaining a financial advantage in contravention of s 135.2 of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth). The respondent was a self-employed pharmacist. The financial advantage he obtained was $7,193.46.

  1. The respondent was, pursuant to s 19B(1)(b)(i) and (c) of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), discharged without conviction upon entering into a recognisance to be of good behaviour for 2 years. He was also ordered to make reparation to the Commonwealth of $7,193.46.

  1. The Commonwealth appeals against the sentence on the ground that it is manifestly inadequate.

  1. Section 135.2(1) of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) is in these terms:

“135.2 Obtaining financial advantage

(1) A person is guilty of an offence if:

(a)     the person engages in conduct; and

(aa)    as a result of that conduct, the person obtains a financial advantage for himself or herself from another person; and

(ab)   the person knows or believes that he or she is not eligible to receive that financial advantage; and

(b)     the other person is a Commonwealth entity.

Penalty: Imprisonment for 12 months.”

  1. Section 135.2(1) is an offence of general application and is not limited to pharmacists.

  1. Section 19B Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), so far as is relevant is in these terms:

“19B Discharge of offenders without proceeding to conviction

(1)Where:

(a)     a person is charged before a court with an offence against the law of the Commonwealth; and

(b)     the court is satisfied, in respect of that charge or more…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions v Moodliar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QDC 106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) brought an appeal against the sentence imposed on Mr. Moodliar, a pharmacist, for obtaining a financial advantage by dishonestly causing the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme to pay out a higher amount than was due. The case was heard in the court of appeal where the DPP argued that the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The appeal centred on the appropriateness of the sentence imposed on Mr. Moodliar, considering the need for general deterrence and the psychological factors relevant to the crime committed. The court was required to determine whether the sentence imposed was manifestly inadequate and, if so, to substitute an appropriate sentence.

The court examined the principles of sentencing, including the need for general deterrence and the psychological factors that might have influenced Mr. Moodliar’s actions. It considered the nature and circumstances of the offence, the degree of moral culpability, and the need to uphold the integrity of the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme. The court also assessed the potential impact of the sentence on Mr. Moodliar's career and reputation, as well as the potential deterrent effect on others in similar circumstances.

The court concluded that the sentence imposed was manifestly inadequate. It found that the original sentence did not sufficiently reflect the seriousness of the offence or serve as an adequate deterrent. The appeal was allowed, and the court set aside the original sentence. In its place, Mr. Moodliar was convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for 4 months, but he was to be released forthwith upon giving security by recognisance in the sum of $500, conditional that he be of good behaviour for 3 months. This decision aimed to balance the need for general deterrence with the specific circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Sentence below set aside and in lieu thereof the respondent is convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for 4 months but is to be released forthwith upon giving security by recognisance in the sum of $500 conditional that he be of good behaviour for 3 months.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established