Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Starrs & Starrs

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA v STARRS & STARRS

[2011] SASC 37

Reasons of Judge Withers a Master of the Supreme Court

22 March 2011

PROCEDURE

Notices to Admit administered by plaintiff - application by plaintiff to strike out responses - form of responses.

Supreme Court Rules 2006 (SA) r 156, referred to.
Rak v Coles Myer Limited (1996) 68 SASR 272; Southern Equities Corporation Ltd (In Liquidation) & Ors v Bond & Ors (No 2) (2000) 34 ACSR 660, applied.
Scott v Williams & Ors & Sims & Ors [2001] SASC 148, considered.

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA v STARRS & STARRS
[2011] SASC 37

  1. JUDGE WITHERS.  This is a claim by the plaintiff against the defendants for money said to be due pursuant to a Deed of Guarantee allegedly executed by the defendants on 27 November 2006.  It is alleged that the defendants guaranteed the obligations of a company to the plaintiff to a maximum of $3.8 million.  While the company names are different it was put in submissions that this action arises out of the failed Truscotts electronics business.

  2. It was pleaded that the company defaulted on its obligations to the plaintiff and as at 18 September 2009 the total amount outstanding by the company to the plaintiff was $3,192,577.57.  The plaintiff pleads that Notices of Demand were given to each defendant dated 18 September 2009 and that at the time of the issue of the proceedings, namely 28 October 2009, the amount outstanding under the guarantee was $3,835,151.12 with interest accruing at the rate of $1,453.21 per day.

  3. By a defence filed on 18 December 2009 – FDN 6 – the defendants jointly pleaded that the debt had been paid in full;  that the guarantee was a joint but not a several obligation;  that the legal process to date had been ineffective;  and that the interest and costs components were not accepted.

  4. An amended defence was filed by the defendants on 13 April 2010 – FDN 8.  In this document the defendants repeated the pleas in the original defence and then added further pleas responding to paragraphs 3, 4, 5 and 6 of the plaintiff’s statement of claim.  In the additional pleas it was asserted that the guarantees provided for a maximum liability of $3 million and not $3.8 million as claimed by the plaintiff.  It was further asserted that the first defendant, Dr C D Starrs had a limited capacity to understand the implications of the guarantee because of poor health;  that he was not independently informed by the Bank of negotiations and amendments to the loan arrangements;  that he was not a director of the borrowing company Starrs & Co Pty Ltd;  and that he signed the guarantee and consent to extension of guarantee under coercion.  It was further pleaded that he received the consent to extension of guarantee via the second defendant, Mrs Starrs and that he signed a mortgage on a house property at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Starrs & Starrs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Starrs & Starrs, the plaintiff sought to enforce a judgment against the defendant. The defendant had issued a Notice to Admit under Rule 156 of the Supreme Court Rules 2006 (SA), requesting the plaintiff to admit specific facts and the admissibility of certain documents. The plaintiff declined to admit the facts or the admissibility of the documents, leading to the plaintiff's application to the court to determine the admissibility of the documents and the facts asserted in the Notice to Admit.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendant's Notice to Admit complied with the requirements of Rule 156 of the Supreme Court Rules 2006 (SA), specifically regarding the assertions of relevance and admissibility of documents. The court had to determine whether the defendant had adequately explained the reasons for the relevance and admissibility of the documents as required by Rule 156(2)(c) and (d). Additionally, the court needed to consider whether the plaintiff's failure to respond to the Notice to Admit resulted in an admission of the facts and the admissibility of the documents.

The court examined the language of Rule 156 and noted that it required an explanation of relevance for assertions regarding the admissibility of documents. The court found that the defendant's Notice to Admit did not provide the necessary reasons for the relevance and admissibility of the documents, thus failing to comply with the rule. As a result, the court determined that the plaintiff's failure to respond did not result in an admission of the facts or the admissibility of the documents. The court ruled that the plaintiff was not required to admit the facts or the admissibility of the documents due to the defendant's non-compliance with Rule 156.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the plaintiff's application to determine the admissibility of the documents and the facts asserted in the Notice to Admit, finding that the defendant's Notice to Admit did not comply with the requirements of Rule 156 of the Supreme Court Rules 2006 (SA). The court ordered that the plaintiff was not required to admit the facts or the admissibility of the documents due to the defendant's failure to provide the necessary reasons for relevance and admissibility as required by the rule.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Rule 156 of the Supreme Court Rules 2006 (SA) deals with Notices to Admit. Relevantly it is in the following terms:[6R 156] Notice to admit facts or documents156 (1) A party may give notice to another party (a notice to admit) asking the other party to admit a particular assertion that the party makes for the purposes of the action.(2) The assertion may be—(a) a statement purporting to be a statement of fact; or(b) an assertion of the authenticity of a particular document; or(c)an assertion that a particular document is, for stated reasons, relevant to the subject matter of the action; or(d)an assertion that a particular document is, for stated reasons, admissible in evidence at the trial of the action.(3) …(4) If a notice to admit asserts the authenticity or relevance of a document, a copy of the document must, unless the Court otherwise directs, be attached to the notice.(5) …(6) A party to whom a notice to admit is addressed (the respondent) must, within 14 days after the notice is given or a longer time agreed by the parties or allowed by the Court, give a notice (a notice of response) responding to each assertion in the notice to admit—(a) by admitting the assertion; or(b) by—(i) denying the assertion and stating the grounds of the denial; or(ii)stating that the respondent is not in a position to admit or deny the assertion and explaining why the respondent is not in a position to do so; or(iii)claiming privilege or some other proper ground for refusing to respond to the assertion.(7) If the respondent fails to respond to an assertion in a notice to admit as required by subrule (6), the respondent is taken to have admitted the assertion.(8) …(9) The Court may, on application made within 21 days after a notice of response is given—(a)order the respondent to give a further and better notice of response within the time allowed by the Court; or(b)if satisfied that the respondent has denied or failed to admit an assertion without adequate reasons for doing so—determine the issue raised by the assertion in advance of the trial.(10) …(11) … Supreme Court Rule 156 replaces 87R 54.01, which provided in subrule (1):54.01 (1) A party may request any other party to admit in writing the truth of any relevant fact or the authenticity or admissibility of any relevant document specified in the notice. It was put in submissions by counsel for the plaintiff that the form of the Notice to Admit had been drafted in response to the language of r 156 which it was suggested had a different consequence from that of 87R 54. What is different is that an explanation of relevance is now required as an integral part of an assertion as to relevance and admissibility. In my view the requirements of 6R 156 in relation to the Notice to Admit can be conveniently split into two sections. The first section is contained within r 156(2)(a) and is an assertion by the applicant of a matter “purporting to be a statement of fact”. The second section is comprised in r 156(2)(b), (c) and (d) and relates to the authenticity, relevance and admissibility of documents for stated reasons. Assertions as to relevance on admissibility of a document must now be accompanied by reasons explaining why the document is relevant and admissible.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established