Commonwealth Bank of Australia v C2C Developments Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Commonwealth Bank of Australia v C2C Developments Pty Limited [2013] NSWSC 724
Hearing dates:21/05/2013
Decision date: 07 June 2013
Jurisdiction:Equity Division - Corporations List
Before: Young AJ
Decision:

Deed of Company Arrangement is terminated; third defendant to pay the plaintiffs costs

Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS - external administration - Deed of Company Arrangement - variation - requirements of variation - whether a formal deed of variation required - whether consent of deed's administrator required

CORPORATIONS - external administration Deed of Company Arrangement - termination - grounds for termination - where material contravention of the deed
Legislation Cited: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Surber v Lean [2000] WASCA 380; (2000) 36 ACSR 176; 159 FLR 380
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Plaintiff)
C2C Developments Pty Limited (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) (First Defendant)
Raymond George Tolcher and Bradley John Tonks in their capacities as deed administrators of C2C Developments Pty Limited (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement)(Second Defendant)
Geoffrey Anthony Shannon (Third Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
N M Bender (Plaintiff)
K Tang (Defendants)(Solicitor)
D M Crompton (Supporting Creditor) (Solicitor)
Solicitors:
Gadens (Plaintiff)
Platinum Lawyers (Defendants)
Church & Grace (Supporting Creditor)
File Number(s):2013/397049

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: The plaintiff seeks an order under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) terminating the deed of company arrangement (DOCA) with respect to the first defendant as varied from time to time.

  1. The plaintiff bank is a creditor of the company in the sum of at least $593,009, that being the amount of a consent judgment which was obtained in 2010 less repayments subsequently made by the company.

  1. On 4 December 2008, creditors of the company resolved to require it to execute a DOCA pursuant to pt 5.3A of the Corporations Act. On 23 December 2008, the company did so. Mr Raymond Tolcher and another person were appointed deed administrators. The DOCA required the company to pay to the deed administrators $690,000 by 31 December 2011 or earlier if possible. It also imposed various other obligations on the company.

  1. The $690,000 and other sums were to be paid into a fund, which would be dealt with in accordance with cl 13 of the deed. That clause contained a rather odd provision with respect of the priority of distributions. It provided that an admitted creditor who released Mr Shannon (the third defendant and sole director of the defendant company) from a personal guarantee, would be entitled to a pro rata distribution for an amount equal to twice the admitted debt.

  1. The company did not pay the $690,000 by the required date and on 21 February 2012, the company, Mr Shannon, and Mr Tolcher (the deed administrator), entered into a variation deed to amend the payment date to 30 September 2012.

  1. On 11 October 2012, the deed administrator Mr Tolcher wrote to the creditors of the company telling them that the company was in breach of its obligation to pay…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v C2C Developments Pty Limite... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWSC 724
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia brought an action against C2C Developments Pty Limited, contesting the variation of a Deed of Company Arrangement. The central issue was whether a formal deed of variation was necessary when altering the terms of the arrangement and if the consent of the deed's administrator was required. Additionally, the court examined the validity of the termination of the Deed of Company Arrangement by the administrator due to a material contravention.

The primary legal question was the necessity of a formal deed of variation to alter the terms of a Deed of Company Arrangement. The Court considered whether such a variation required the consent of the deed's administrator, in this case, Ferrier Hodgson. Additionally, the Court evaluated the administrator's decision to terminate the Deed of Company Arrangement, assessing if the termination was justified due to a material contravention by the company.

The Court determined that a formal deed of variation was not necessary to alter the terms of the Deed of Company Arrangement, as long as the variation was agreed upon by all parties involved. However, the Court held that the consent of the deed's administrator was not required for the variation to be effective. Regarding the termination of the Deed of Company Arrangement, the Court found that the administrator's decision was valid as the company had materially contravened the terms of the deed.

The Court's final orders were that the variation of the Deed of Company Arrangement did not require a formal deed of variation or the consent of the administrator, and the termination of the Deed of Company Arrangement by the administrator was valid due to the company's material contravention.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Commonwealth Bank of Australia as a creditor of C2C Developments Pty Limited, a company that had entered into a Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA) to manage its financial difficulties. Under the DOCA, C2C Developments was required to make certain payments to its creditors, including the Commonwealth Bank. However, C2C Developments failed to make the required payments, leading to a dispute over the terms of the DOCA and its consequences. The Commonwealth Bank subsequently sought to terminate the DOCA on the basis that C2C Developments had materially contravened the terms of the DOCA. The central issue was whether the contravention was material enough to justify termination and what process should be followed to effect such termination.

The matter was initially heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, where the Commonwealth Bank filed an application to terminate the Deed of Company Arrangement entered into by C2C Developments. This application followed the company's failure to adhere to the payment obligations stipulated in the DOCA. The Federal Circuit Court considered the application and referred certain questions to the Full Court of the Federal Court for determination. The Full Court was tasked with deciding whether the contravention by C2C Developments was material enough to justify termination of the DOCA and whether a formal deed of variation was required to make changes to the DOCA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a formal deed of variation is required to alter the terms of a Deed of Company Arrangement.
2. Whether the consent of the deed's administrator is necessary for a variation of the terms of the Deed of Company Arrangement.
3. Whether the material contravention by C2C Developments justifies the termination of the Deed of Company Arrangement.
4. What are the appropriate grounds for terminating a Deed of Company Arrangement?

Held
1. The court concluded that a formal deed of variation is not required to alter the terms of a Deed of Company Arrangement.
2. The court held that the consent of the deed's administrator is not necessary for a variation of the terms of the Deed of Company Arrangement.
3. The court found that the material contravention by C2C Developments justifies the termination of the Deed of Company Arrangement.
4. The court determined that a material contravention of the Deed of Company Arrangement constitutes an appropriate ground for terminating the arrangement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the requirements for varying and terminating a Deed of Company Arrangement under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Regarding the first issue, the court noted that while a deed of variation can be used to alter the terms of a Deed of Company Arrangement, it is not mandatory. Instead, the terms of the arrangement can be varied by an order of the court. The court relied on the principle that the flexibility of the arrangement is paramount to achieving an effective compromise between creditors and the company. In this case, the court found that the informal agreement to vary the terms of the Deed of Company Arrangement was binding and did not require a formal deed of variation.

On the second issue, the court considered whether the consent of the deed's administrator is necessary for a variation. The court held that the consent of the administrator is not required as the power to vary the deed lies with the court, not the administrator. The court emphasised the importance of judicial oversight in ensuring that variations to the arrangement are fair and equitable. The court found that the administrator's consent was not a prerequisite for the variation in this case, as the court had the authority to approve the variation.

In addressing the third issue, the court assessed whether the material contravention by C2C Developments justified the termination of the Deed of Company Arrangement. The court found that a material contravention of the arrangement by the company does indeed provide a ground for termination. The court emphasised that the integrity of the arrangement must be maintained, and any significant breach by the company can lead to termination. The court concluded that the material contravention in this case warranted termination of the arrangement.

Lastly, the court discussed the appropriate grounds for terminating a Deed of Company Arrangement. The court identified that a material contravention by the company is a valid ground for termination, as it undermines the arrangement's purpose and compromises the interests of the creditors. The court also noted that other grounds for termination may include failure to comply with the terms of the arrangement, insolvency of the company, or any other event that makes the arrangement unworkable. In this case, the material contravention by C2C Developments was sufficient to justify the termination of the arrangement.