Commissioner of Taxation v Macoun

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of Taxation v Macoun [2014] FCAFC 162

Citation: Commissioner of Taxation v Macoun [2014] FCAFC 162
Appeal from: Macoun v Commissioner of Taxation [2014] AATA 155
Parties: COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION v ANDREW JOHN MACOUN
File number: NSD 401 of 2014
Judges: EDMONDS, PERRAM AND NICHOLAS JJ
Date of judgment: 4 December 2014
Catchwords: INCOME TAX – appeal from Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether appeal competent – whether pension from foreign retirement plan received in years of income when pensioner no longer employed by Specialised Agency exempt from income tax under cl 8 of the Specialised Agencies (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 1986 (Cth); Part 1 of Fourth Schedule to International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963 (Cth); and s 6-20(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth)
Legislation: Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44(1)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 23(x), 23(y), 27H
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 6-5,6-10, 6-20
International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963 (Cth) s 6
Specialized Agencies (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 1986 (Cth) cl 8
Taxation Laws Amendment Act (No 2) 1988 (Cth)
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties
Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of Specialized Agencies
Income Tax Regulations 1936 (Cth) cl 4AB
Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 33.12, 33.30
Cases cited: AAT Case 10,901 (1996) 32 ATR 1279 cited
Australian Gas Light Company v Valuer-General (1940) 40 SR (NSW) 126 applied
Birdseye v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2003) 38 AAR 55 cited
Brumby v Milner [1976] 1 WLR 1096 cited
Brutus v Cozens [1973] AC 854 cited
Case M90 (1980) 80 ATC 648 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Broken Hill South Ltd (1941) 65 CLR 150 cited
Hope v Bathurst City Council (1980) 144 CLR 1 cited
Lombardo v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 28 ALR 574 cited
Master Education Services Pty Limited v Ketchell (2008) 236 CLR 101 cited
Nette v Howarth (1935) 53 CLR 55 cited
Plaintiff M47/2012 v Director-General of Security (2012) 86 ALJR 1372 considered
TNT Skypak International (Aust) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 82 ALR 175 cited
Date of hearing: 5 November 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 60
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr JO Hmelnitsky SC with Ms TL Phillips
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Taxation Office Dispute Resolution
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr RJ Ellicott QC with Ms MJ Hirschhorn and Mr B Symons
Solicitor for the Respondent: Hazan Hollander

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 401 of 2014

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Applicant

AND:

ANDREW JOHN MACOUN
Respondent

JUDGES:

EDMONDS, PERRAM AND NICHOLAS JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

4 DECEMBER 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal given on 20 March 2014 be set aside and the decision under review be affirmed.

3.The applicant pay the respondent’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Macoun and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCAFC 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the respondent, a former officer of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, appeals against the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that pension payments received from the World Bank's Staff Retirement Plan (SRP) were exempt from income tax. The Commissioner of Taxation contends that the pension payments were assessable income and should be taxed. The primary issue before the court was whether the pension payments received by the respondent after his retirement were exempt from income tax under the provisions of the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963 (Cth) and the Specialised Agencies (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 1986 (Cth). The court had to determine whether these provisions confer a taxation exemption in respect of pension plan payments received by the respondent, a former officer of the IBRD, at a time when he did not hold office in that organisation.

The court held that the pension payments were not exempt from income tax under the relevant provisions of the IOPI Act and the Regulations. The court found that the AAT's reasoning was flawed in two main respects. First, the AAT adopted a "bottom up" approach to the construction of the IOPI Act by reference to the terms of the Regulations, rather than a "top down" approach. Second, the AAT's consideration of "entitlement" arising during the course of employment was irrelevant. The court emphasised that the relevant consideration was "receipt" during the course of employment. The court concluded that the clear language of s 6(1)(d) of the IOPI Act provided a more secure basis from which to infer the relevant legislative purpose.

The court allowed the appeal, set aside the decision of the AAT, and affirmed the decision under review. The applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs, as agreed or taxed. This decision clarifies the scope of the tax exemption provisions for former officers of international organisations and ensures that the correct approach is taken in construing the relevant statutes and regulations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal given on 20 March 2014 be set aside and the decision under review be affirmed.

3. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Subsection 6(1)(d)(i) of the IOPI Act and cl 8(1) of the Regulations confer upon a person who holds an office in an international organisation to which the IOPI Act applies an exemption from taxation on salaries and emoluments received from the organisation. The question that arises in the present case is whether these provisions confer a taxation exemption in respect of pension plan payments received by the respondent, a former officer of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (“IBRD”), one of the organisations comprising the World Bank, at a time when he did not hold office in that organisation. The Commissioner contends that that question should be answered in the negative.THE FACTS The primary facts, as found by the Tribunal, are not in dispute and are summarised below. Between 1992 and 2007, the respondent worked overseas as a sanitary engineer for the IBRD. During the respondent’s period of service with the IBRD he participated in the World Bank’s Staff Retirement Plan (“SRP”). The SRP was a contributory defined benefit plan under which participants were required to make regular contributions equivalent to 7% of their pensionable gross salary. During his employment with the IBRD, the respondent contributed a total of US$200,842 to the SRP. The SRP required the IBRD to make contributions to fund the liabilities of the plan that were not funded by the participants’ contributions and to hold the assets of the SRP as a retirement fund. Participation in the SRP was optional for employees under the age of 62 on fixed term appointments and mandatory for employees who had regular appointment status prior to attaining the age of 62, as did the respondent from September 1993 onwards. The respondent retired from the IBRD in 2007, aged 60. Participants in the SRP who retired between the ages of 55 and 62 could elect, as the respondent did, to receive monthly pension payments from the date of their retirement, calculated in accordance with formulae in the SRP. During the years of income the respondent received pension payments under the SRP in the order of AUD$130,000 per annum. The respondent originally lodged returns for the years of income that included as assessable income the amount of the pension payments received in each of those years. He subsequently amended those returns to exclude the pension payments as assessable income, which led to the issue of the amended assessments referred to in [1] and [2] above.STATUTORY FRAMEWORK Pension payments from a foreign pension fund would ordinarily fall to be taxed in accordance with s 27H of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (“1936 Act”) as assessable income, unless a relevant exemption applies: see s 27H(1)(a); and the definition of “annuity” in s 27H(4). See also ss 6-5, 6-10 and 6-20 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (“1997 Act”). In particular, s 6-20(1) of the 1997 Act provides:An amount of *ordinary income or *statutory income is exempt income if it is made exempt from income tax by a provision of this Act or another *Commonwealth law.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Although the Fourth Schedule is included as part of the IOPI Act, it is only given operative effect by force of the Regulations and is to be construed accordingly. THE TRIBUNAL DECISION The Tribunal concluded at [59] of its Reasons (“R”) that the pension payments paid to the respondent in the years of income were exempt from tax on the basis that they were “emoluments” within the meaning of the Fourth Schedule to the IOPI Act. The Tribunal considered that “the immunity in respect of ‘emoluments’ in Pt I of that Schedule continued in force and effect after the termination of the respondent’s employment and after performance of the services in respect of which the pension entitlement was granted during the period of his service or office”. The process of reasoning by which the Tribunal got to this conclusion is, with great respect, somewhat difficult to follow. As a preliminary observation, exemption from taxation is not strictly an immunity like immunity from suit as conferred by item 1 of Parts I and II of the Fourth Schedule. Indeed, the heading to Part II of the Fourth Schedule omits the word privilege by contrast to Part I of that Schedule. At R [21]–[31] the Tribunal considered the respective submissions of the respondent and the Commissioner on the issue as to whether the pension payments were “emoluments”. The Tribunal analysed various authorities to which it was referred, finding that one was not “on point” (Case M90 (1980) 80 ATC 648 at [15]–[18]) (R [24]); the reasoning in another was not “directly on point” (Nette v Howarth (1935) 53 CLR 55) (R [26]); referring to a decision of the House of Lords as authority for the proposition that if the payment “arose” from the employment or office it fell within the description of an “emolument” (Brumby v Milner [1976] 1 WLR 1096) (R [29]); dismissing a decision of the Tribunal, contrary to the conclusion of the Tribunal in the present case, on the basis that it “rests on an assertion without reasoning” and was not of any “assistance in resolving the question before me” (AAT case 10,901 (1996) 32 ATR 1279) (R [30], [31]). At R [32] the Tribunal concluded that the pension payments were “in the nature of an ‘emolument’ because they can be described as a profit or gain arising from an office or employment or as ‘compensation for services’ by way of remuneration”. At R [34]–[37] the Tribunal reasoned that the pension entitlement arose as “part of the [respondent’s] remuneration entitlement and crystallised during the course of the [respondent’s] employment” and “did not cease on termination of his employment” (R [34]). At R [38] it concluded:In my view the characterisation of the payments does not alter simply because the payments are made after the rendering of the services. As noted earlier, if “salary” to which an employee became entitled prior to termination of employment is paid after employment ceased, it would nevertheless continue to be impressed with its character as “salary”. The circumstance in which payment is actually made or received after the officer has ceased holding office is in my view immaterial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Question 2 is also a question of law as it only requires one to engage in a process of construction of Pt I of the Fourth Schedule to the IOPI Act and cl 8(1) of the Regulations: see Hope at 8 per Mason J.CONSIDERATION AND ANALYSIS The focus of the Tribunal’s process of reasoning was directed at the issue of whether the pension payments received by the respondent in the years of income were “emoluments” as that word is used in item 2 of Pt I of the Fourth Schedule to the IOPI Act and, having come to the conclusion that they were, focused on the issue as to whether they ceased to have that character by reason of the termination of the respondent’s employment. The Tribunal concluded that the termination of the respondent’s employment did not alter the character of the pension payments as “emoluments” and that therefore they were exempt from income tax. In coming to this conclusion, the Tribunal was heavily influenced by the consideration that “entitlement” to the pension arose during the respondent’s term of employment: R [33]; [36] [45] and that this entitlement did not cease on termination of his employment: R [34]; [38]; [59]. With great respect, this process of reasoning is flawed in two main respects. First, it adopts a “bottom up” approach to the construction of a statute (the IOPI Act) by reference to the terms of relevant delegated regulation (the Regulations), rather than a “top down” approach. As French CJ said in Plaintiff M47/2012 v Director-General of Security (2012) 86 ALJR 1372 at [56]:Generally speaking an Act, which does not provide for its own modification by operation of regulations made under it, is not to be construed by reference to those regulations: Hunter Resources Ltd v Melville (1988) 164 CLR 234 at 244 per Mason CJ and Gaudron J. That would be a case of the tail wagging the dog.See too Master Education Services Pty Limited v Ketchell (2008) 236 CLR 101 at [19]. Second, the consideration of “entitlement” arising during the course of employment is totally irrelevant. The only relevant consideration is “receipt” during the course of employment: see item 2 of Pt I of the Fourth Schedule to the IOPI Act. In his defence of the Tribunal’s reasoning, Senior Counsel for the respondent relied upon the Second Reading Speech in the House of Representatives (8 May 1963) in relation to the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Bill 1963 in which Sir Garfield Barwick referred to the reasons for according privileges and immunities to international organisations and persons connected with such organisations. Relevantly, Sir Garfield said (at p 2):… certain exemptions from the fiscal laws of member states are justified on the ground that no one state should obtain financial advantages by imposing charges on assets contributed by the states which are members of an international organisation. The reference to “certain exemptions” suggests that the privileges may not have been intended to provide the breadth of protection from the fiscal laws of member states implied by the respondent’s submissions. In any case, there is a clear dichotomy established by s 6(1)(d) of the IOPI Act between the privileges and immunities which apply to a person who holds office, and the immunities which apply to a person who has ceased to hold office. We think the clear language of s 6(1)(d) provides a more secure basis from which to infer the relevant legislative purpose.