Commissioner of Railways (WA) v Stewart

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read
56 CLR 520

COMMISSIONER

RAILWAYS (WESTERN AUSTRALIA)

STEWART AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS. PLAINTIFFS, Negligence-Water-Statutory authority-Embankment-Flooding.

In 1885 a railway embankment was constructed across a depression through PERTH,

which there ran one or more natural channels or streams carrying off surface Sept. 16, 17,

water from a catchment on the higher side of a railway. The railway was 18, 21, 22.

then vested in the Crown and managed by a commissioner who was an unincor- porated agency of the Crown. By the Crown Suits Act 1898 (W.A.) the Crown MELBOURNE,

was made liable for tort, and by the Government Railways Act 1904 (W.A.) the railways were vested in the minister on behalf of the Crown, the commis- sioner was made a body corporate, and all actions against the Crown relating to railways or arising out of their management, maintenance and control were directed to be brought against him. In 1934 the embankment proved the cause of damage during a heavy downpour of rain. It obstructed the flow water which was banked back on to private property on the upper side of the railway, and subsequently escaped through a breach in the embankment and flooded property on the other side. The culverts originally provided were insufficient to carry off an exceptional fall of water, and, although they had afterwards been increased, their capacity was not great enough. The fall in question was greater than had ever previously been experienced, but on the facts it was found to be not SO great that no reasonably prudent engineer would provide against it.

56 CLR 521

Held, in an action against the Commissioner of Railways :- (1) That he was liable for the consequences of negligent construction because the cause of action was not complete until the damage in 1933 and the statute of 1904 meant that he was the person properly to be sued in respect of any wrongs done in connection with the railways after the statute.

(2) That the construction of the railway was negligent, and the statutory authority to construct and maintain it afforded no answer to the action.

(3) That the downpour did not amount to an "act of God " " and was not of such magnitude and intensity that no reasonably prudent person would antici- pate and guard against it.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia (Dwyer J.) affirmed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Percy Andrew Victor Stewart and others brought an action in the Supreme Court of Western Australia against the Commissioner of Railways of that State whereby they claimed damages for the negli- gence of the defendant as a result of which the property of the plaintiffs suffered damage by flooding.

The statement of claim was substantially as follows :- 1. The defendant is the Commissioner of Railways appointed under the Government Railways Act 1904 (W.A.).

2. The defendant at some time or times prior to March 1934 artificially constructed as part of a railway an embankment from Macartney Street to South…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Railways (WA) v Stewart and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1936] HCA 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Commissioner of Railways (WA) v Stewart* involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The respondents, Percy Andrew Victor Stewart and others, had sued the Commissioner of Railways for damages caused by flooding in 1934, alleging negligence in the construction and maintenance of a railway embankment. The embankment, constructed in 1885, had obstructed the natural flow of surface water, leading to flooding on both sides of the railway during a heavy rainfall event.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the Commissioner of Railways was liable for damage caused by the negligent construction of the railway, which predated his statutory corporate existence and the Crown's liability in tort. The court also had to determine if the construction of the railway embankment constituted negligence, and if the statutory authority to build and maintain the railway provided a defence. Furthermore, the court considered whether the exceptionally heavy rainfall constituted an "act of God" that would absolve the Commissioner of liability, and whether the evidence supported the finding of negligence and the extent of the damage caused by the embankment.

The High Court, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court, held that the Commissioner of Railways was liable. The court reasoned that the cause of action was complete in 1934 when the damage occurred, and the relevant legislation, particularly the Crown Suits Act 1898 and the Government Railways Act 1904, made the Commissioner the proper party to sue for wrongs related to the railways. The court found that the construction of the embankment was negligent, as it failed to make adequate provision for the flow of water, and the statutory authority to construct the railway did not excuse this negligence. The rainfall, while exceptionally heavy, was not considered an "act of God" as it was not of such magnitude that no reasonably prudent engineer could have anticipated or guarded against it.

The appeal was dismissed, and the judgment of the Supreme Court of Western Australia in favour of the plaintiffs was affirmed. The Commissioner of Railways was ordered to pay damages to the plaintiffs for the losses they suffered due to the flooding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established