Commissioner of Police v MC

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

CITATION:Commissioner of Police v MC (2019) NTLC 022

PARTIES:COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

v

MC

TITLE OF COURT:  Local Court

JURISDICTION:  Criminal

FILE NO(s):21834506

DELIVERED ON:  12 JULY 2019

DELIVERED AT:  Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):  2 May 2019

JUDGMENT OF:  Chief Judge Lowndes

CATCHWORDS:

CHILD PROTECTION PROHIBITION ORDER – NATURE OF A CHILD

PROTECTION PROHIBITION ORDER – FACTORS TO BE TAKEN INTO

ACCOUNT WHEN DETERMINING WHETHER TO MAKE AN ORDER – THE

APPLICANT’S BURDEN OF PROOF – LEVEL OF RISK AND AMBIT OF THE

ORDER

Child Protection (Offender Reporting and Registration) Act ss 71, 72(1), 72(2),

73 and 74

Commissioner of Police v Tak (No2) [2011] WADC 219 applied

Commissioner of Police v ABC [2010] WADC 161 applied

Commissioner of Police v ND (unreported decision of the Youth Justice Court

delivered on 17 Apr 2015) followed

R v Mulholland (1991) 1 NTLR 1 applied

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Applicant:Mr. T Dunham

Respondent:  Mr. J Razi

Solicitors:

Applicant:Solicitor for the Norther Territory

Respondent:  NAAJA

Judgment category classification:       B

Judgment ID number:[2019] NTLC 022     

Number of paragraphs:   63        

IN THE LOCAL COURT OF
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21834506

BETWEEN:

Commissioner of Police

Applicant

AND:

MC

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 12 July 2019)

CHIEF JUDGE LOWNDES

THE NATURE OF THE PROCEEDINGS

  1. The Commissioner of Police (the applicant) has made an application to the Local Court (Criminal Division) seeking a child protection prohibition order against MC (the respondent), being a reportable offender, in the following terms:

    For a period of five (5) years:

    1.   Prohibited from approaching, contacting or remaining in the company of any female child under the age of 16 years (contact includes by mail, phone, text messages, facsimile or other forms of communication) except in the presence of a responsible adult who is aware of the respondent’s sexual criminal history.

    2.   Prohibited from residing at any residence occupied by a child under the age of 16 years unless with the consent of that child’s adult parent, or adult guardian who is aware of the respondent’s sexual offending.

    3.   Prohibited from purchasing, possessing or consuming any alcohol and must submit to breath test and/or breath analysis when requested by a police in relation to this order, including accompanying police to an appropriate location for such testing.

    4.   Prohibited from purchasing, possessing or consuming any drugs and/or volatile substances that have not been prescribed by a medical practitioner and must submit to saliva, urinalysis, buccal swab and /or blood test when requested by a police officer in relation to this order, including accompanying police to an appropriate location for such testing.

  2. Although the respondent does not object to the making of a child protection prohibition order the respondent opposes the orders in the terms sought by the applicant on the grounds that those orders are unnecessarily restrictive, and not required to meet the risk that the respondent poses to the sexual safety of one or more children or children generally, and proposes that the following less restrictive orders would be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v MC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NTLC 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commissioner of Police v MC involved an application for a child protection prohibition order. The applicant argued that the respondent, who had previously committed two offences of having sexual intercourse with a child under the age of 16, posed a risk to children and required the imposition of such an order to protect them. The matter was heard and determined in the relevant Australian court.

The legal issues before the court included the assessment of the level of risk posed by the respondent to children, the factors to be considered in determining whether to make a child protection prohibition order, and the burden of proof required by the applicant. The court had to consider the nature and pattern of the respondent’s conduct, as well as other relevant considerations mentioned in the applicable legislation.

In reaching its decision, the court highlighted the need for an evidence-based assessment of the level of risk, taking into account the nature and pattern of the respondent’s conduct. The court also noted that the specific terms of any child protection prohibition order should be no more than necessary to reduce the relevant risk, given the potential of such an order to curtail personal liberty. The court found that the applicant had not met the required burden of proof to establish that a child protection prohibition order was necessary.

The court did not grant the application for a child protection prohibition order. The specific terms of the order, if any, were not addressed as the court found the application unsuccessful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As pointed out by Ms Fong Lim SM in Commissioner of Police v ND “the assessment of the level of risk” must be evidence- based having regard to the “nature and pattern of the conduct” of the reportable offender. I would add that the level of risk is also be assessed by reference to the other considerations mentioned in s 72(1) of the Act. Those considerations are also relevant to the nature and extent of any child protection prohibition order that the court considers is necessary to address the identified risk. The specific terms of an order should be no more than are necessary to reduce the relevant risk, given the potential of a child protection prohibition order to curtail one’s personal liberty.[3]CONSIDERATION OF THE LEVEL OF RISK AND THE AMBIT OF THE CHILD PROHIBITION ORDER The evidence relied upon by the applicant is to be found in the affidavit of Kate Alison MacMichael declared 7 August 2018 and her further affidavit declared 26 April 2019. In support of the application for a child protection prohibition order the applicant relies upon the seriousness of the respondent’s reportable offences. On 17 November 2010 the respondent committed the offence of having sexual intercourse with a child under the age of 16 years , namely 13 years of age, contrary to s 127(1)(a) of the Criminal Code ( the first reportable offence). The respondent was convicted of that offence on 24 July 2012 and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 58 days which was backdated to 28 May 21012 Between 1 July and 13 July 2013 the respondent committed a further offence contrary to s 127 (1) (a) of the Code – namely having sexual intercourse with a child under the age of 16 years, namely 13 years of age , contrary to s 127(1)(a) of the Criminal Code ( the second reportable offence). The respondent was convicted of that offence on 22 September 2016 and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 2 and a half years backdated to 5 March 2016, with a non- parole period of 21 months, backdated to commence on 5 March 2016. It in relation to these two reportable offences the respondent received a total sentence of 2 years 2 months, having been released from prison on 4 September 2018. An assessment of the seriousness of the respondent’s reportable offences must begin with the facts and circumstances of the offences and reasons for sentence of the sentencing judge. Justice Barr was the sentencing judge in relation to the first reportable offence. In his sentencing remarks His Honour referred to the facts relating to the offending as set out in Exhibit P1. It is agreed between the parties that facts contained in Exhibit P1 are along the lines of the precis annexed to the affidavit of Kate McMichael declared on 7 August 2018. Although His Honour remarked that there was a need to protect young persons from entering into sexual relations before they are mature enough to do so and to have weighed up the possible consequences, this was not a case of “older male predatory conduct”. Moreover, the offending was consensual.