DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Commissioner of Police v James [2013] QDC 54
PARTIES:
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(appellant)
And
ANTHONY WILLLIAM JAMES
(respondent)
FILE NO/S:
3095/12
DIVISION:
Appellate
PROCEEDING:
Section 222 Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Magistrates Court of Beenleigh
DELIVERED ON:
22 March 2013
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
11 March 2013
JUDGE:
Reid DCJ
ORDER:
Appeal allowed.
Plea of guilty set aside and the appellant discharged for all 15 offences of forgery under s 488(1)(a) of the Code and 15 offences of uttering registration documents under s 488(1)(b) of the Code.
Sentence varied to term of two years imprisonment, to be wholly suspended with an operational period of three years for each of 59 charges of making a false statement under s 50 of the Criminal Code.CATCHWORDS:
Forgery and uttering; s 488(1) – intent to defraud – no evidence of deception – setting aside guilty plea – false statement; s 501 – relevance of financial gain – inadequacy of sentence – relevance of past sentencing factors
CASES REFERRED TO
Peters v The Queen [1998] 192 CLR 493
Meissner v R [1995] 184 CLR 132
R v Law; Ex Parte Attorney General (1996) 2 Qd R 63
R v Ehrmann [2001] QCA 50
R v Black and Sutton [2004] QCA 369COUNSEL:
S Bain for the appellant
J McNab for the respondent
SOLICITORS:
Office of Director of Public Prosecutions for the appellant
Cobb Law Pty Ltd for the respondent
Introduction
This is an appeal by the Commissioner of Police from a sentence of one year, wholly suspended, with an operational period of two years imposed by the Magistrates Court, Beenleigh on 9 July 2012. The respondent, who was the director of a funeral home business in southern Brisbane suburbs had pleaded guilty to 59 charges of making a false statement concerning a register of births deaths or marriages under s 501 of the Criminal Code, which carry a maximum sentence of three years imprisonment and, to 15 offences of forgery under s 488(1)(a) of the Code and 15 of uttering registration documents under s 488(1)(b) of the Code. The maximum penalties under these latter two sections were 3 years and 14 years imprisonment respectively. It is not apparent why the circumstances of aggravation, namely the fact that the uttering was of “registration documents”, did not apply also to the forgery.
It is also unclear from the sentence, but appears to be accepted, that the sentence imposed was in respect of each of the 89 offences, and that all sentences were to be served concurrently.
S. 488(1) offences
During the hearing there was significant discussion about the fact that the maximum penalty was 14 years imprisonment for 15 of the offences. The police prosecution submitted that this indicated the attitude of parliament to the seriousness of offences involving falsification of public records. Whilst the significant maximum sentence is of some relevance, I have difficulty with the notion that such considerations were of critical importance in the sentence, because it seems…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v James and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] QDC 54
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues addressed by the court involved the adequacy of the evidence supporting the appellant's convictions and the appropriateness of the sentence. The appeal centred on whether there was sufficient evidence to prove intent to defraud under section 488(1) of the Criminal Code, and whether the sentence was adequate given the appellant's background and the nature of the offences. Furthermore, the court considered the relevance of financial gain and past sentencing factors in determining the sentence.
The court found that there was insufficient evidence of deception necessary to prove intent to defraud under section 488(1). Consequently, the court set aside the guilty pleas for the forgery and uttering offences. The court also found the original sentence to be inadequate, particularly in light of the appellant's clean criminal record and the non-financial nature of the offences. The court varied the sentence to a term of two years imprisonment, to be wholly suspended with an operational period of three years for each of the 29 false statement charges.
The court's final orders were to allow the appeal, set aside the guilty pleas for the forgery and uttering offences, and discharge the appellant in relation to those charges. The sentence for the false statement charges was varied to a wholly suspended term of two years imprisonment, with an operational period of three years.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal allowed.
Plea of guilty set aside and the appellant discharged for all 15 offences of forgery under s 488(1)(a) of the Code and 15 offences of uttering registration documents under s 488(1)(b) of the Code.
Sentence varied to term of two years imprisonment, to be wholly suspended with an operational period of three years for each of 59 charges of making a false statement under s 50 of the Criminal Code.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi