Commissioner of Police v David Taylor (a pseudonym)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

MAGISTRATES  COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:Commissioner of Police v David Taylor (a pseudonym) [2023] QChCM 2

PARTIES:  COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

v

DAVID TAYLOR (a pseudonym)

FILE NO:Mount Isa CCM 669/22

PROCEEDING:                  Sentence

COURT:  Children’s Court, Mount Isa

DELIVERED ON:               24 January 2023

HEARING DATE:              10 January 2023

MAGISTRATE:                  E. Mac Giolla Ri 

APPEARANCES:               Mr B Fotheringham, Prosecution
  Mr N Honnef, ATSILS for Mr Taylor
  Mr C Lewis, Youth Justice

  1. On 10 January 2023 I sentenced David Taylor, a 17-year-old aboriginal boy, to 51 days in detention and ordered that he serve 70% or 36 days. That order saw David released on the day of his sentence. David had served the 36 days either in the Mount Isa watchhouse or confined in his cell for 21+ hours per day at Cleveland Youth Detention Centre in Townsville (‘CYDC’).

  2. At the time of sentence, I explained the order to David but reserved my reasons. I publish my reasons now.

  3. On 6 December 2022 David had pleaded guilty to the following offences, all of which occurred on 4 & 5 December 2022:

Offence Facts
Enter premises David and his co-accused entered a business premises in his regional/remote home-town and stole sets of car keys.
Unlawful use of a car (x 4) David and his co-accused used those of those sets of keys to drive away in two cars belonging to the business. They drove the cars to Mount Isa. The balance of the offending took place at Mount Isa or on route to Mount Isa.[1]
Stealing David and his co-accused stole petrol for one of the stolen cars from a service station in a town on route to Mount Isa
Enter Premises David and his co-accused broke into a shop in the same town.
Enter Premises In the same town, David and his co-accused broke into a second shop and stole cash and hardware items.
Attempted Enter Premises In the same town, the offenders damaged glass trying to enter a business premises but they did not get in.
Enter Premises In the same town, the offenders entered a supermarket and stole groceries and cigarettes
Stealing On arrival in Mount Isa one of the stolen cars was involved in a further fuel theft at a service station.

[1] The four UUMV charges are based on the use of the same two cars in two discrete time periods.

  1. David was picked up by police for this offending on 5 December 2022 and was remanded in custody when he appeared before me on 6 December 2022.

  2. A presentence report (‘PSR’) was ordered and the sentence was heard on 10 January 2023. David appeared at the sentence hearing by video link from CYDC. At that time, David had spent 36 nights in custody: 10 days in the watchhouse at Mount Isa and 26 days in Cleveland Youth Detention Centre (‘CYDC’).

David’s background

  1. At the time of sentence David was 17 years old.  I was assisted by a pre-sentence report, which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v David Taylor (a pseudonym) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QChCM 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Magistrates Court of Queensland, the Commissioner of Police brought charges against David Taylor, a pseudonym used for a 17-year-old Aboriginal boy, who was sentenced for multiple offences committed over two days. The legal issues the court had to decide included the appropriate sentence for the crimes committed, taking into account David's disadvantaged background, and the impact of the conditions of his detention on the sentencing decision. The court found that David's imprisonment was substantially more onerous than what would be considered normal, and that his time in detention already served met the requirements of punishment, deterrence, denunciation, and the protection of the community.

The reasoning behind the court's decision was that the Youth Justice principles supported David's release, as his continued detention under the present circumstances would be contrary to treating him with dignity and respect. Additionally, David appeared to be maturing out of offending, and his rehabilitation would be facilitated more easily in the community. The court also took into account the extremely onerous circumstances of David's detention, which were well beyond how a child should ordinarily be expected to serve detention. As a result, the court sentenced David to 51 days in detention, with release at 36 days (70%), which more than adequately met the requirements of punishment, deterrence, denunciation, and the protection of the community, and was consistent with the Youth Justice Principles.

The final orders of the court were that David Taylor was to serve 51 days in detention, with release at 36 days (70%), and that he was to be released on the day of his sentence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established