Commissioner of Highways v Dorchester Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS v DORCHESTER PTY LTD & OTHERS

[2021] SASC 137

Judgment of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court  

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION

REAL PROPERTY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - EJECTMENT

Land acquired by the applicant - third interested party tenant pursuant to an unregistered lease - acquisition has the effect of extinguishing the lease - notice of possession given - 6 September 2021 nominated as the date for possession - third interested party has not vacated the premises - applicant seeks order of ejectment - third interested party says applicant not presently entitled to an order for ejectment.

Held:

1. The applicant has leave, to the extent necessary, nunc pro tunc, to file an interlocutory application in these proceedings seeking an order for ejectment.

2. The third interested party is to provide vacant possession of the land comprised and described in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 6255 Folio 948 to the Commissioner on or before 4.00pm on 13 December 2021.

3. The Commissioner is to forthwith pay the sum of $40,000 into the Court’s Suitors Fund to the credit of this action as part-payment of compensation due to the third interested party.

4. Costs of application reserved for further consideration.

Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) s 10, s 16, s 23A, s 24, s 24A; Land and Valuation Division Rules 2014 r 4(2)(e), r 5, r 12(4); Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 10, r 12; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 27, referred to.
Hall v Nominal Defendant (1966) 117 CLR 423; Licul v Corney (1994) 180 CLR 213, considered.

COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS v DORCHESTER PTY LTD & OTHERS
[2021] SASC 137

Civil

  1. This is an application by the Commissioner of Highways (“Commissioner”) by which he seeks an order evicting the third interested party from land on Glen Osmond Road.  The Commissioner is entitled to the order sought.

    Background

  2. The Commissioner has commenced works to widen and generally upgrade the intersection of Glen Osmond and Fullarton Roads.  As part of that project the Commissioner has acquired various parcels of land.  Relevant for this matter is the land comprised and described in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5443 Folio 399, being the land at 179 Glen Osmond Road Frewville. 

  3. The first interested party, Dorchester Pty Ltd, was the registered proprietor of the land.  The second interested party, Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd held a mortgage on the land.  This application deals with the third interested party, Nordburger Pty Ltd (“Nordburger”), a tenant of the first interested party, pursuant to an unregistered written lease.  It conducts a fast-food outlet on the site. 

    Structure of the Land Acquisition Act 1969

  4. The Land Acquisition Act 1969 (“the Act”) contains a structured approach for the acquisition of land and the payment of compensation when land is acquired by a relevant government authority.  If the amount of compensation is not able to be agreed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Highways v Dorchester Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commissioner of Highways v Dorchester Pty Ltd concerns the compulsory acquisition of land for the purpose of widening and upgrading the intersection of Glen Osmond and Fullarton Roads. The Commissioner of Highways, the applicant, seeks an order evicting Nordburger Pty Ltd, the tenant of Dorchester Pty Ltd, the registered proprietor of the land. The Court finds that the Commissioner is entitled to the order sought. The primary issue before the Court was whether the Commissioner was entitled to an order for ejectment of Nordburger from the acquired land, given Nordburger's refusal to vacate the premises. Nordburger argued that the land had not been properly acquired under the Land Acquisition Act 1969 and, therefore, the Commissioner did not have the right to exercise any rights over the acquired land.

The Court found that Nordburger's argument was inconsistent with the provisions of the Act. While the obligation to make an offer of compensation is mandatory, it is not a prerequisite for exercising rights over acquired land. Section 23A(1a) of the Act absolves the Commissioner from the obligation to make an offer of compensation in circumstances where that compensation is not able to be determined. Furthermore, the Court found that there was a valid acquisition between the Commissioner and Dorchester, as evidenced by the payment of monies into the Suitors Fund at the time of acquisition. Consequently, Nordburger's entitlements were extinguished. The Court granted the Commissioner leave to file an interlocutory application seeking an order for ejectment and ordered Nordburger to provide vacant possession of the land to the Commissioner by 4:00 pm on 13 December 2021. The Court also ordered the Commissioner to pay $40,000 into the Court's Suitors Fund as part-payment of compensation due to Nordburger. Costs of the application were reserved for further consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held:

1. The applicant has leave, to the extent necessary, nunc pro tunc, to file an interlocutory application in these proceedings seeking an order for ejectment.

2. The third interested party is to provide vacant possession of the land comprised and described in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 6255 Folio 948 to the Commissioner on or before 4.00pm on 13 December 2021.

3. The Commissioner is to forthwith pay the sum of $40,000 into the Court’s Suitors Fund to the credit of this action as part-payment of compensation due to the third interested party.

4. Costs of application reserved for further consideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by the Commissioner of Highways (“Commissioner”) by which he seeks an order evicting the third interested party from land on Glen Osmond Road. The Commissioner is entitled to the order sought. Background The Commissioner has commenced works to widen and generally upgrade the intersection of Glen Osmond and Fullarton Roads. As part of that project the Commissioner has acquired various parcels of land. Relevant for this matter is the land comprised and described in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5443 Folio 399, being the land at 179 Glen Osmond Road Frewville. The first interested party, Dorchester Pty Ltd, was the registered proprietor of the land. The second interested party, Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd held a mortgage on the land. This application deals with the third interested party, Nordburger Pty Ltd (“Nordburger”), a tenant of the first interested party, pursuant to an unregistered written lease. It conducts a fast-food outlet on the site. Structure of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 The Land Acquisition Act 1969 (“the Act”) contains a structured approach for the acquisition of land and the payment of compensation when land is acquired by a relevant government authority. If the amount of compensation is not able to be agreed between parties, jurisdiction is vested in this Court to determine the appropriate compensation. There are a number of sections of the Act which are relevant to the dispute in this matter. The first is s 10, which provides:10—Notice of intention to acquire land(1)Subject to this Act, if the Authority proposes to acquire land (other than native title), the Authority must give a notice of intention to acquire the land to each person whose interest in the land is subject to acquisition, or such of those persons as, after diligent inquiry, become known to the Authority. The Commissioner complied with the obligation in s 10(1) by serving notices of intention to acquire land on Dorchester and Nordburger on or about 19 August 2020. There is no dispute about the service of those notices and no issue arises in respect of s 10. The next relevant section is s 16:16—Notice of acquisition(1)Subject to this Act,[1] the Authority may, at least three months after the first occasion on which any notice of intention to acquire was given but before the period for acquisition of the land comes to an end,[2] publish a notice of acquisition in the Gazette.(2)On publication of the notice of acquisition—(a)the land vests in the Authority to the extent of the interest specified in the notice; and(b)a mortgage, charge, encumbrance, trust or other interest affecting the land (except native title) is, to the extent it affects the land subject to the acquisition, discharged; and(c)if a residual interest remains after the acquisition, the interest is modified to the extent required by the acquisition.[3][1] See in particular Division 1 of Part 4 which imposes limitations on the acquisition of native title in land in certain circumstances.[2] The period for acquisition of the land is the period of 18 months after the notice of intention to acquire was given (see section 15(4)) or a longer period fixed under section 15(4a).[3] The acquisition of land under this section extinguishes native title to the extent permitted by the Native Title Act 1993(Cwth) (see sections 24MD(2), (2A) and (3)).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On this application, the Court is not being asked to determine who has the better right to possession. Nordburger has no such right. It is simply obliging Nordburger to vacate a property which it has no right to remain in possession of. The contest between the parties that does exist, and which would be final, is the question of compensation. That is a matter for another day and will be litigated in due course. That is the matter that will need to be dealt with by a Justice rather than a Master. The present application is interlocutory.Consideration The sole question is whether the Commissioner is entitled to an order for ejectment in circumstances where Nordburger is not willing to vacate the property. It is clear that the store is profitable and Nordburger wishes to continue trading at the location for as long as it can. The evidence before the Court from the Commissioner is to the effect that further delay in obtaining possession of the property may cause a delay to the overall project. It is the intention of the Commissioner to demolish the improvements on the land before Christmas. Whether that is still practical is unclear. Nordburger has filed no affidavits. The Court has no evidence of the consequences to it of an ejectment, other than it will cease trading. The scheme of the Act as set out above is clear. The Commissioner is now the registered proprietor of the land and a new Title has issued.[9] Nordburger’s lease was extinguished. The Act gives a grace period of 90 days for a person with interest in acquired land to vacate the premises, but once that date has expired, the occupant is a trespasser.[9] Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 6255 Folio 948. Nordburger’s principal argument is that the land has not been properly acquired under the Act. The argument is that an offer of compensation is a prerequisite for exercising rights over acquired land. It is submitted that the Commissioner did not comply with the statutory obligation to make an offer of compensation and the subject land should not be treated as having been “acquired under” the Act. The argument is not consistent with the provisions of the Act. The obligation to make an offer of compensation contained in s 23A is mandatory, but s 23A(1a) absolves the Commissioner from the obligation to make an offer of compensation in circumstances where that compensation is not able to be determined. That is the situation here. It is only in the last week or two that Nordburger has advised the Commissioner that it will not seek to relocate the store. The Commissioner will now proceed to make an offer of compensation and pay the money into the suitors Fund. The other problem with the argument is, as between the Commissioner and the registered proprietor, Dorchester, there can be no doubt that there was a valid acquisition. Monies were paid into the Suitors Fund at the time of acquisition. The Commissioner properly became the registered proprietor of the land and Nordburger’s entitlements at that time were extinguished.