Commissioner for Social Housing in the Act v Johnson

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING IN THE ACT v JOHNSON
(Residential Tenancies) [2014] ACAT 57

RT 14/306

Catchwords:              RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – occupancy agreement or residential tenancy agreement – character of the agreement must be determined objectively, by reference to communications between the parties and the terms of the agreement – subjective factors which are part of communication between parties and terms of agreement – provision of temporary care of children cannot be elevated to permanent tenancy -  terms of agreement and terms inconsistent with residential tenancy demonstrate that the agreement is an occupancy agreement

Legislation:Residential Tenancies Act 1997, ss 6A, 6B and 71C, and Parts 1A, 4 and 5A, and Schedule 1 (Standard residential tenancy terms), clauses 75-79

Cases:Bangura & Fan [2013] ACAT 38

Bruton v London & Quadrant Housing Trust [1999] 3 AER 481

Community Housing Canberra T/As CHC Affordable Housing
v Connell (Residential Tenancies)
[2013] ACAT 68
Estate of Tanya Humphries v Commissioner for Housingin the ACT [2003] ACTSC 40

Northern Sandblasting P/L v Harris (1997) 188 CLR 313

NSW Land and Housing Corporation v Mann [2014] NSWCAT
Progressive Mailing House P/L v Tabali Pty Ltd

(1985) 157


CLR 17

Radaich v Smith (1989) 101 CLR 209
Shahid v Australian College of Dermatologists [2008] FCAFC 72

Yousif v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2010] FCAFC 8
Wiser v. Havelock Housing Association Inc [2014] ACTSC 138

Texts/Papers:            Gillies, Peter, and Selvadurai, Niloufer, Law of Contracts, (The

Federation Press, 2009)

Tribunal:                    Mr A. Anforth – Senior Member

Date of Orders:  19 August 2014

Date of Reasons for Decision:      19 August 2014

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                   RT 14/306

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER FOR

SOCIAL HOUSING IN THE ACT

Applicant

AND:

STEVEN JOHNSON

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Mr A. Anforth – Senior Member

DATE:19 August 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal finds that:

The Agreement is an occupancy agreement and that the Commissioner has properly terminated the Agreement.

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The occupancy agreement is terminated and the Respondent is to vacate the premises and return vacant possession to the Commissioner on or before 20 August 2014.

………………………………..

Mr A. Anforth – Senior Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

History of the proceedings:

  1. The Respondent commenced occupying a 3 bedroom house in Gilmore in the ACT under an agreement with the Commissioner for Social Housing (the Commissioner) dated 11 July 2013 (the Agreement). The Agreement is annexed to these reasons. The Agreement was said to be an occupancy agreement within the meaning of Part 5A of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (RTA) as opposed to a residential tenancy agreement within the meaning of Part 1A of the RTA. The Agreement was for a fixed term of 3 months at a rent of $820 per fortnight subject to the Respondent’s entitlement to any rent rebate per the special condition in the Agreement.

  2. Clause 6.1.1 of the Agreement provided that the Agreement was to continue beyond the expiry of the fixed term on a “month to month basis”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Social Housing in the Act v Johnson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court was between the Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT and Mr Johnson. The Commissioner sought to terminate an occupancy agreement between the parties in relation to certain property, arguing that Mr Johnson had failed to vacate the premises after the service of a 21-day Termination Notice. Mr Johnson argued that the agreement should be characterised as a residential tenancy agreement under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) and that the Commissioner had not complied with the requirements for lawful termination. The court was required to determine the legal nature of the agreement between the parties and whether the Commissioner's application for termination should be dismissed.

The court found that the agreement between the parties was an occupancy agreement rather than a residential tenancy agreement. The court held that the definition of an occupancy agreement under the Act was negative, meaning that it was an agreement that was not a residential tenancy agreement. The court noted that the first question to be asked was whether the agreement answered the description of a residential tenancy agreement, and only if the answer was in the negative should further questions be asked as to whether the agreement answered the definition of an 'occupancy agreement'. The court found that the agreement did not answer the description of a residential tenancy agreement and was therefore an occupancy agreement. The court further held that the Commissioner's application for termination should not be dismissed, and the occupancy agreement was terminated. The Respondent was ordered to vacate the premises and return vacant possession to the Commissioner on or before 20 August 2014.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The occupancy agreement is terminated and the Respondent is to vacate the premises and return vacant possession to the Commissioner on or before 20 August 2014.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 12 June 2014, the Respondent’s solicitors filed submissions that read as follows:1.These submissions are made pursuant to orders dated 17 April 2014.2.This is an application by The Commissioner for Social Housing seeking an order 'terminating the occupancy agreement' between the Applicant and the Respondent Mr Johnson in relation to[the property].3.This application is premised upon the Respondent's failure to vacate the property after the service by the Applicant of a 21-day Termination Notice.4.The Applicant filed submissions on 15 May 2014. The essence of those submissions appears to be that the Tribunal should accept the agreement is an occupancy agreement. If the Tribunal finds it is a tenancy agreement, it should incorporate into the agreement the terms of the signed occupancy agreement. If the Tribunal is not minded to do so, the Tribunal should void the agreement from the hearing date, thus terminating the tenancy.5.It is the Respondent's submissions that the legal nature of the agreement between the Applicant and Respondent is most properly characterised as a residential tenancy agreement and, as such, the Applicant must comply with the requirements established under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (“the RTA”) pertaining to residential tenancy agreements, including those relating to termination. Section 36 of the RTA prescribes the mechanisms for lawful termination of a residential tenancy agreement.6.The Applicant correctly identifies, at paragraph [15], the grounds under which termination of the tenancy could be sought (in the absence of a breach of the standard terms, failure to pay rent, etc).7.As the Applicant has not complied with the requirements for termination, the application must be dismissed.8.The Respondent does not concede that the Tribunal should void the tenancy from the hearing date. If the Tribunal finds a tenancy agreement exists between the Applicant and Respondent, it is not open to the Tribunal to simply "void the tenancy".Background9.The Respondent entered into an agreement with the Applicant on 11 July 2013 in relation to the property. This agreement was termed to be an 'occupancy agreement'.10.The agreement was for the fixed term, terminating on 11 October 2013. No further written agreement was entered into between the parties.11.On 24 October 2013, the Applicant served the Respondent with a 21-day Termination Notice.Legal Framework12.The RTA provides the framework that governs the relationship between the Applicant and the Respondent.Occupancy13.An "Occupancy Agreement" is defined in broad terms by section 71C of the RTA:71C What is an occupancy agreement?(1) An agreement is an occupancy agreement if—(a) a person (the grantor) gives someone else (the occupant) a right to occupy stated premises; and(b) the premises are for the occupant to use as a home (whether or not with other people); and(c) the right is given for value; and(d) the agreement is not a residential tenancy agreement.(2) The agreement may be—(a) express or implied; or(b) in writing, oral, or partly in writing and partly oral.(3) The right to occupy may be—(a) exclusive or not;(b) given with a right to use facilities, furniture or goods.(4) The person given the right to occupy the premises may be—(a) a boarder or lodger; or(b) someone prescribed by regulation for this section.14.Most significantly, section 71C(1)(d) defines an occupancy agreement in the negative as an "agreement [which] is not a residential tenancy agreement."15.Section 71C does not provide guidance as to how one delineates between a residential tenancy agreement and an occupancy agreement. However, existing authority on the interpretation of the provision suggests a threshold enquiry:The first question is whether an agreement between parties does or does not answer the description of a residential tenancy agreement. Only if the answer is in the negative is the further questions asked as to whether the agreement answers the definition of an 'occupancy agreement' (emphasis added).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the agreement between the Applicant and the Respondent is an occupancy agreement or a residential tenancy agreement under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.
2. Whether the Commissioner for Social Housing complied with the requirements for lawful termination of the tenancy agreement.
3. Whether the occupancy agreement should be terminated and the Respondent ordered to vacate the premises.

Held
1. The agreement between the Applicant and the Respondent is an occupancy agreement, not a residential tenancy agreement under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.
2. The Commissioner for Social Housing did not comply with the requirements for lawful termination of the tenancy agreement.
3. The occupancy agreement should not be terminated, and the Respondent is not ordered to vacate the premises.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering the nature of the agreement between the Applicant and the Respondent. The Applicant argued that the agreement was an occupancy agreement, while the Respondent contended that it was a residential tenancy agreement. The court applied the definition of an occupancy agreement under section 71C of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. It noted that the definition is negative, meaning that an agreement is an occupancy agreement if it is not a residential tenancy agreement. The court found that the agreement did not meet the description of a residential tenancy agreement and thus concluded it was an occupancy agreement.

The court then examined whether the Commissioner for Social Housing complied with the requirements for lawful termination of the tenancy agreement. The Commissioner sought to terminate the agreement based on the Respondent's failure to vacate the property after receiving a 21-day Termination Notice. However, the court found that the Commissioner did not follow the lawful termination procedures prescribed under section 36 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. As a result, the court held that the Commissioner's application for termination was invalid.

Finally, the court considered whether the occupancy agreement should be terminated and the Respondent ordered to vacate the premises. The court found that since the Commissioner's application for termination was invalid, the occupancy agreement should not be terminated. Consequently, the Respondent was not ordered to vacate the premises. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that an occupancy agreement cannot be terminated without following the lawful termination procedures prescribed by the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.