Commissioner for Housing for the ACT -v- Eastman

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Commissioner for Housing for the ACT -v- Eastman   ACTRTT14  [2007]

CATCHWORDS
Termination of tenancy; no breach of standard terms

ISSUES
Discretion of Tribunal

LEGISLATION
Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)
 Section 47; Clause 94

CASES CITED

Eastman v Commissioner for Housing in the Australian Capital Territory  [2006] ACTSC 52
Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd. v. Maher [1988] HCA 7

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:  RT 1518 of 2001

RE: Premises at 20C Jerilderie Court REID ACT 2601

DECISION

ORDERS

1)   That the residential tenancy agreement relating to the tenant’s occupancy of premises at 20C Jerilderie court, REID in the Australian Capital Territory be terminated at 10 am on 21 May 2007.

2)   That the Applicants be granted vacant possession of the premises from the 21st day of May 2007.

3)   That the tenant and any other person claiming a right of possession through the tenant’s tenancy is to vacate the premises in accordance with this Order.

Member:         Jann Lennard

Date:               18 May 2007

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

The tenancy

  1. Premises: 20 C Jerilderie Court REID ACT
  2. Lessor: Commissioner for Housing for the ACT
  3. Tenant: David Harold Eastman
  4. Periodic tenancy commenced 24 December 1981.

The application to Residential Tenancies Tribunal

1) On 1 May 2001 the Applicant lessor served Mr Eastman with a Notice to Vacate pursuant to clause 94 of the Standard Residential Tenancy Terms contained in Schedule 1 to the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.

2)   Clause 94 provides:

The lessor may serve a notice to vacate during the term of a tenancy requiring the tenant to vacate at the end of the notice provided that –

(a)    the notice is for 26 weeks; and

(b)   the notice does not require the tenant to vacate the premises during a fixed term.

3)   Mr Eastman was also sent a letter setting out his right to ask for a review of the Applicant’s decision to terminate the tenancy.

4)   On 8 May 2001, Mr Eastman through his solicitor, Bernard Collaery, sought such a review on the following grounds:

a)Estoppel by virtue of an undertaking given on behalf of the ACT government by Ms Bernadette Maher.

b)The decision is oppressive.

c)The decision is unreasonable given the circumstances.

d)There has been no breach of the prescribed terms or of the covenants express or implied.

5)   On 1 June 2001 Mr Bob Hutchinson, Executive Director, ACT Housing wrote to Mr Collaery and stated “ I have reviewed Mr Eastman’s file and have considered the contents of your letter of 8 May 2001 and have determined that the decision to terminate Mr Eastman’s tenancy should stand.

6)   Mr Eastman did not vacate or surrender possession of the premises in accordance with the Notice to Vacate and the lessor made an application to the Residential Tenancies Tribunal for a termination and possession order to have effect as a warrant of eviction.

7)   The matter came before the Residential Tenancies Tribunal in 2006 as a consequence of the decision of Ryan J in Eastman v Commissioner for Housing in the Australian…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Housing for the ACT -v- Eastman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ACTRTT 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner for Housing for the ACT brought an application to the Residential Tenancies Tribunal against David Harold Eastman for the termination of a periodic tenancy agreement for premises at 20C Jerilderie Court, Reid, ACT. The Commissioner sought a termination and possession order based on clause 94 of the Standard Residential Tenancy Terms, which allows for a notice to vacate without cause, provided it is for 26 weeks and does not fall within a fixed term. The dispute arose when Mr. Eastman did not vacate the premises after receiving the notice to vacate on 1 May 2001, leading the Commissioner to apply to the Tribunal for a termination and possession order.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Commissioner had complied with the statutory requirements for terminating the tenancy and whether the Tribunal had discretion to refuse making a termination and possession order under section 47 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. The Tribunal needed to determine if the Commissioner had a valid ground for termination, served a proper notice, and whether Mr. Eastman had failed to vacate. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider if it should exercise its discretion to refuse the order despite meeting the statutory criteria.

The Tribunal found that the Commissioner had complied with the statutory requirements, establishing grounds for termination, serving a proper notice, and Mr. Eastman not vacating. Regarding the discretion under section 47, the Tribunal acknowledged the discretion to refuse an order but noted it was not unfettered. The Tribunal considered factors such as the balance of interests between lessors and tenants and the contractual basis of the agreement. Mr. Eastman argued for an estoppel based on a letter from Ms. Bernadette Maher, suggesting his tenancy would continue until the completion of a judicial review. However, the Tribunal found that Mr. Eastman could not establish estoppel, as he failed to show detrimental reliance on the assumed state of affairs. The Tribunal also considered the Commissioner's actions in good faith and the significant demand for public housing. Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the Commissioner's actions were not unconscionable, and the termination and possession order should be granted.

The Tribunal ordered the termination of the residential tenancy agreement at 10 am on 21 May 2007, granting the Commissioner vacant possession from 21 May 2007, and requiring Mr. Eastman and any other claimants to vacate the premises in accordance with the order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.