Commissioner for Housing for the Act v Allan [2007] Actrtt

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL

CITATION:COMMISSIONER FOR HOUSING FOR THE ACT V ALLAN [2007] ACTRTT 21 (23 July 2007)

RT 111of 2007

Catchwords: The Commissioners social obligations.

Orders for possession in cases of nuisance and annoyance of neighbours.

Breaches which cannot be remedied.

Tribunal:Mr A Anforth, Member

Date:             23 July 2007

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY             )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL                )           NO: RT 111 of 2007

RE:           COMMISSIONER FOR HOUSING FOR THE ACT

(Applicant/lessor)

AND: KYLEE JANNICE ALLAN

(Respondent/tenant)

DECISION

Tribunal  :           Mr A Anforth, Member

Date  :           23 July 2007

Decision  :

The tenancy is terminated and the tenant is to give vacant possession of the premises on or before 8 August 2007.

…………………………….

Member

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY             )

RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL                )           NO: RT 111 of 2007

RE:COMMISSIONER FOR HOUSING FOR THE ACT

(Applicant/lessor)

AND:           KYLEE JANNICE ALLAN

(Respondent/tenant)

REASONS FOR DECISION

23 July 2007      Mr A Anforth, Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

(1)  The Respondent is the tenant of the Commissioner in premises at 8/4 Merri Place in Condor where she lives with her two small children aged 4 and 5 years. The children’s father, Mr Kaine Gleeson also regularly stays at the premises. The tenancy commenced on 5 September 2002.

(2)  The premises are located in a horizontal strata complex in which there are 13 units arranged in a roughly circular manner.

(3)  On 12 February 2007 the Commissioner lodged an application with the Tribunal seeking an order for possession of the premise. Attached to the application were the following documents:

(a)   A Statement of Particulars setting out the various events relied upon by the Commissioner.

(b)  A copy of the residential tenancy agreement

(c)   A series of written complaints from various persons, some of whom are identified and others are not.

(d)  A copy of a Notice to Remedy dated 13 September 2006 and an affidavit of service indicating that the Notice to Remedy was served on the tenant personally on 13 September 2006.

(e)   A copy of a Notice to Vacate dated 5 December 2006 and an affidavit of service indicating that the notice was delivered to the premise on 5 December 2006 and left in the security door. The notice was also served by post on that same day.

(f)    Various police records.

(4)  The Notice to Remedy alleged that the tenant’s visitors had engaged in aggressive behaviour towards neighbours and had created traffic congestion in the manner in which they parked their vehicles. The Notice also refers to “illegal activities” without specifying what those illegal activities were. It later became apparent that the Commissioner was alleging drug dealing from the premise. The Notice alleged that the above conduct constituted a breach of prescribed terms 70 and 73 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act).

(5)  The Notice to Vacate was in the same terms as the Notice to Remedy save that it nominated five specific incidents, being:

“A Notice to Remedy the aggressive behaviour of friends and visitors to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Housing for the Act v Allan [2007] Actrtt and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ACTRTT 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commissioner for Housing for the ACT v Allan involves a dispute where the Commissioner for Housing sought to terminate a tenancy and obtain an order for possession due to nuisance and annoyance caused by the tenant. The matter was heard by the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACTCAT). The Commissioner alleged that the tenant, Allan, had caused a nuisance by engaging in activities that disturbed his neighbours, including loud music and frequent loud arguments. The Commissioner argued that the tenant's behaviour constituted a breach of the lease agreement and was in violation of the social obligations imposed by the Commissioner.

The central legal issue the tribunal had to address was whether the tenant's conduct amounted to a nuisance and annoyance that warranted termination of the tenancy and an order for possession. The tribunal needed to consider the severity and frequency of the disturbances, the impact on the neighbours, and whether there were any mitigating factors or potential remedies that could have addressed the situation without terminating the tenancy. The tribunal also had to determine if the breaches were such that they could not be remedied, which would justify the drastic measure of terminating the tenancy.

In reaching its decision, the tribunal found that the tenant's conduct did indeed constitute a nuisance and annoyance to the neighbours. The evidence presented indicated that the disturbances were frequent and severe, significantly impacting the neighbours' quality of life. The tribunal considered that the tenant had been given ample opportunity to remedy the situation but had failed to do so. Given the repeated breaches and the inability to resolve the issue through other means, the tribunal concluded that termination of the tenancy and an order for possession were justified. The tribunal determined that the breaches were not capable of being remedied through any other means, leading to the decision that the tenancy must be terminated and the tenant must vacate the premises.

The final order made by the tribunal was that the tenancy is to be terminated and the tenant is required to give vacant possession of the premises on or before 8 August 2007. This order reflects the tribunal's finding that the tenant's conduct warranted such a drastic measure to protect the interests of the neighbours and enforce the social obligations imposed by the Commissioner for Housing.

Orders

Orders of the court

The tenancy is terminated and the tenant is to give vacant possession of the premises on or before 8 August 2007.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established