Commissioner for Fair Trading v Blinksell

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



COMMISSIONER FOR FAIR TRADING v BLINKSELL
(Occupational Discipline) [2014] ACAT 11

Case Number            OR 13/37

Catchwords:             OCCUPATIONAL DISCIPLINE – REAL ESTATE AGENT cancellation of real estate agent’s licence and business agent’s licence – disqualification from applying for licence or salesperson’s registration – misapplication of trust monies – whether there is a ground for occupational discipline – respondent’s failure to give evidence: Jones v Dunkel inference – considerations in relation to imposing penalty for breach of occupational discipline – not taking reasonable steps to avoid contravention – no previous contravention –  belated mitigation of the effect of contravention –  impact on real estate industry –  likelihood of repeat behaviour – specific penalty applied for.

Legislation:ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, ss. 63, 65 & 66

Agents Act 2003, ss. 42, 107, 173

Subordinate

Legislation:Agents Regulation 2003, Schedule 8

Cases:Council of the Law Society of the Australian Capital Territory v The Legal Practitioner (Occupational Discipline) [2010] ACAT 2

Council of the Law Society of the ACT v Legal Practitioner E (Occupational Discipline) [2013] ACAT 7
Davidson v Commissioner for Fair Trading
[2008] NSWADT 269
Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria v Marshall (Review and Regulation) [2013] VCAT 1316

Foong v Director General Department of Finance and Services

[2012] NSWADT 261


Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298
Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee and Trowell
[2009] WASAT 42
Tassios v Commissioner for Fair Trading  

[2005] NSWADT 179


The Chief Executive , DTFTWID v Cornwell, J

[2005] QCCTPAMD 49


 The Chief Executive, Department of Employment, Economic Development and Innovation v Welburn

[2010] QCAT 202


Legal Practitioner v Council of the Law Society of the Australian Capital Territory [2014] ACTSC 9

Watson v Director General Department of Finance and Services [

2012] NSWADT 64



Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member

Date of Orders:  3 February 2014

Date of Reasons for Decision:         25 February 2014

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                   OR 13/37

COMMISSIONER FOR FAIR TRADING

Applicant

AND:  MARK BLINKSELL

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member

DATE:3 February 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. Pursuant to section 66(2)(e), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal
    Act 2008
    the respondent’s real estate agent licence is cancelled.

  2. Pursuant to section 66(2)(f), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal
    Act 2008
    the respondent is disqualified from applying for a real estate agent’s licence for a period of five years from 15 November 2013.

  1. Pursuant to section 66(2)(f), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal
    Act 2008
    the respondent is disqualified from applying for real estate or business salesperson’s registration for a period of three years from 15 November 2013.

  1. Pursuant to section 66(2)(e), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal
    Act 2008
    the respondent’s business agent licence is cancelled.

  1. Pursuant to section 66(2)(f), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal
    Act 2008
    the respondent is disqualified from applying for a business agent licence for a period of five years from 15…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Fair Trading v Blinksell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Commissioner for Fair Trading v Blinksell, the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) dealt with allegations of non-compliance with statutory obligations concerning trust account management and record-keeping. The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the respondent, Mr Blinksell, had contravened the requirements set forth in the Real Estate Agents Act 2003 and the Real Estate Agents Regulations 2003. The Tribunal found that Mr Blinksell had failed to maintain proper accounting records, respond to inquiries, and lodge audit reports, leading to significant breaches of trust account management protocols. These failures were compounded by Mr Blinksell's lack of a satisfactory explanation and his refusal to engage in compliance assistance over an extended period.

The Tribunal's reasoning was rooted in the importance of strict compliance with statutory obligations, especially concerning the handling of trust monies. The Tribunal emphasised the necessity for real estate agents to uphold community expectations of honesty and integrity. Given Mr Blinksell's repeated failures and the absence of any mitigating actions, the Tribunal concluded that significant disciplinary action was warranted. Consequently, the Tribunal cancelled Mr Blinksell's real estate agent licence and disqualified him from applying for any real estate or business salesperson's registration for five years. Additionally, his business agent licence was also cancelled, and he was similarly disqualified from applying for a business agent licence for five years. The Tribunal further required Mr Blinksell to undertake specific trust account training if he were to apply for any future licences or registrations.

In summary, the Tribunal's decision underscores the critical nature of compliance with statutory obligations in the real estate industry, particularly regarding trust account management. The penalties imposed reflect the Tribunal's commitment to protecting the community's interests and maintaining the integrity of the industry.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.

Pursuant to section 66(2)(e), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Act 2008 the respondent’s real estate agent licence is cancelled.

2.

Pursuant to section 66(2)(f), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Act 2008 the respondent is disqualified from applying for a real estate agent’s licence for a period of five years from 15 November 2013.

3.

Pursuant to section 66(2)(f), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Act 2008 the respondent is disqualified from applying for real estate or business salesperson’s registration for a period of three years from 15 November 2013.

4.

Pursuant to section 66(2)(e), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Act 2008 the respondent’s business agent licence is cancelled.

5.

Pursuant to section 66(2)(f), of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Act 2008 the respondent is disqualified from applying for a business agent licence for a period of five years from 15 November 2013.

The tribunal notes:

(a) that should the respondent become eligible for and apply for any licence or registration under the Agents Act 2003, the respondent will be required to undertake training to the satisfaction of the applicant in relation to Trust Accounts, including CPPDSM40064 – Establish and Manage Agency Trust Accounts - pursuant to 66 (2)(c) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008.

(b) The respondent through his solicitor, undertook to de-registrar Grapevine Real Estate Pty Ltd on completion of all proceedings

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Marshall, where the Tribunal was dealing with failure to comply with reporting and record keeping requirements, the tribunal’s findings and conclusion were-46.The Tribunal finds that the Respondent-a. failed or refused to respond to enquiries, requests and directions made on behalf of the Applicant for approximately 3 years;b. failed to retain financial records as required;c. failed to provide any satisfactory explanation as to why he failed to maintain proper accounting records or obtain and file audit reports;d. failed to engage or seek assistance in complying with his statutory obligations; ande. as at the date of the inquiry, has continued to fail to lodge any audit reports or accounting records or otherwise respond to any enquiries made by the Applicant in relation to the relevant accounting periods47.The Tribunal is otherwise satisfied that the Respondent has accepted full responsibility for his conduct.48. The Tribunal takes into account that the Respondent comes before the Tribunal with prior good character and there have been no prior adverse findings in relation to the Respondent, brought to the attention of the Tribunal.CONCLUSION49. This Tribunal has consistently reinforced the fundamental importance of strict compliance with the Act and Regulations, particularly where a licence authorises the receipt of trust monies. Breaches of a kind committed in this area, as acknowledged by the Respondent, prevent a proper monitoring of statutory compliance and identification of possible trust account deficiencies or defalcations. The tribunal ordered that Mr Marshall’s real estate licence be suspended for 12 months and thereafter be subject to a permanent condition that he not be entitled to deal with trust monies. In Davidson, the principals of a company whose employee had stolen a large amount of trust money (almost $440,000) were disqualified for 18 months for failing to properly supervise that employee in the performance of trust account duties. In Watson, a real estate agent involved in running a larger company was disqualified at first instance for a period of 8 years in circumstances where, amongst other issues, trust monies had been misappropriated. Notwithstanding that the tribunal found that the agent had been manipulated by another person in acting as she did, the tribunal affirmed the decision and put the matters of principle this way:This behaviour is particularly apparent concerning the evident misappropriation and misuse of trust account funds in respect of strata plan 5565 and the other matters referred to in this Schedule.The licence issued to the Corporation was issued for the purpose of conducting business in the real estate industry. It is a fundamental concern of the legislation to ensure that those who work in the industry do so honestly, competently and fairly. Members of the community are entitled to expect that licensees and certificate holders will not mislead them and will not mishandle money that is entrust to the licensees and certificate holders.In my opinion, the conduct of the Corporation's business fell well short of community expectations and represents a fundamental failure to properly carry out the functions of a licence holder. I am reasonably satisfied that the conduct of the Corporation's business, through its directors, officers, employees and licensees in charge, was also improper and there are numerous examples of where there has been a blatant disregard for the legal requirements when dealing with trust funds.The community entrusts real estate agents with substantial sums of money when making one of the most expensive and significant decisions of their life. It is imperative that real estate agents can be trusted to protect the interests of the community. It is incumbent of each agent to uphold the standard expected of them and not to bring the industry into disrepute.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 65 and section 66 of the ACAT Act state:65Considerations before making orders on application for occupational discipline(1)This section applies if the tribunal is considering an application for occupational discipline against a person (the subject person).(2)The tribunal may make an order for occupational discipline in relation to the subject person if satisfied that a ground for occupational discipline exists against the person.(3)In considering what occupational discipline to use against the subject person, the tribunal must consider the following:(a)whether the person took reasonable steps to avoid the action (the contravention) that is the ground for occupational discipline;(b)whether occupational discipline has previously been used against the person for a similar act;(c)whether the person has taken steps to mitigate the effect of the contravention;(d)the impact of the contravention on any other person;(e)the likelihood that the person will act in a way that is a ground for occupational discipline in the future;(f)whether the entity bringing the application has applied for particular occupational discipline to be used and, if so, the kind of occupational discipline applied for.Example—par (c)the person has changed a method of work or given a direction to staff to prevent further contraventions(4)The tribunal may consider any other relevant matter.66Orders for occupational discipline(1)This section applies if the tribunal may make an order for occupational discipline in relation to the subject person.(2)The tribunal may make 1 or more of the following orders for occupational discipline in relation to the subject person:(a)reprimand the person;(b)require the person to give a written undertaking;(c)require the person to complete a stated course of training to the satisfaction of the regulatory body or another stated person;(d)give the person a direction;(e)cancel or suspend the person’s licence or registration; (f)disqualify the person from applying for a licence, or registration, of a stated kind for a stated period or until a stated thing happens;(g)if a regulatory body may put conditions on the person’s licence or registration under an authorising law—direct the regulatory body to—(i)put a condition on the person’s licence or registration; or(ii)remove or amend a condition put on the person’s licence or registration;(h)require the person to pay to the Territory or someone else a stated amount (not more than any amount prescribed by regulation);(i)if the person gained financial advantage from the action that is the ground for occupational discipline—require the person to pay to the Territory an amount assessed as the amount of financial advantage gained by the person.(3)If the ACAT cancels a person’s licence or registration, the ACAT may disqualify the person from applying for a licence or registration for a stated period or indefinitely.(4)This section does not limit the orders the tribunal may make.(5)In this section:regulatory body means the entity responsible for issuing licences of the kind held by the subject person or for registering people in the occupation or profession in which the subject person is registered.