JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: COMMERCIAL & CIVIL
ACT: CONSUMER CREDIT (WESTERN AUSTRALIA) ACT 1996 (WA)
CITATION: COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION and CHEQUECASH PTY LTD [2009] WASAT 244
MEMBER: MR T CAREY (MEMBER)
HEARD: 2 OCTOBER 2009
DELIVERED : 11 DECEMBER 2009
FILE NO/S: CC 1726 of 2007
BETWEEN: COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION
Applicant
AND
CHEQUECASH PTY LTD
Respondent
Catchwords:
Consumer credit - Misstatements of total interest charges payable - Civil penalty - Factors prescribed by s 102(4) of Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Code - Costs
Legislation:
Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Act 1996, s 7(1)
Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Code, s 15, s 15(E), s 15(G), s 100(1), s 102, Sch 1 s 1(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 3
Result:
Contraventions of Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Code found
Civil penalty of $10,000 imposed
Costs awarded to applicant
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant: Ms L Black
Respondent: Self-represented
Solicitors:
Applicant: Department of Commerce
Respondent: Self-represented
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Associated Premium Funding Pty Ltd v Director Consumer Affairs Victoria [2003] VCAT 1492
Avco Financial Services Ltd v Various Debtors & DirectorGeneral, Office of Fair Trading (Commercial) [2003] NSWCTTT 776
Commissioner for Consumer Protection and Hawaii Pty Ltd [2008] WASAT 22 (S)
Department for Consumer and Employment Protection and Chequecash Pty Ltd [2008] WASAT 168
Department for Consumer and Employment Protection and Chequecash Pty Ltd [2009] WASAT 168(S)
Department of Consumer and Employment Protection and Chequecash Pty Ltd [2009] WASC 18
Qantas Staff Credit Union Limited v Director-General, Department of Fair Trading (as it then was) (Commercial) [2003] NSWCTTT 823
Qantas Staff Credit Union Ltd and Various Debtors [2007] WASAT 162
Qantas Staff Credit Union v Various Debtors (Commercial) [2006] NSWCTTT 578
Westpac Banking Corporation Ltd v Various Respondents (No 4) (1992) ASC 56187
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
The applicant sought a civil penalty against the respondent in relation to admitted contraventions of a 'key requirement' of the consumer credit legislation that credit contracts specify the total amount of interest charges payable under them. Its principal complaint was that the respondent had in its credit contracts specified an inflated amount for the interest charges payable, which was explained by a failure of the respondent's computer program to recognise reductions in interest in cases where repayments were to be made over the life of the loan. Some 989 cases of overcharging were identified.
The parties were in disagreement as to the appropriate amount of the penalty. The applicant relied upon the respondent's systemic failures which allowed the contraventions to occur and continue without detection for some seven years, the losses which were incurred in the first instance which, although not great in absolute terms, were of significance to the borrowers concerned, and the need for deterrence for both the respondent and other credit providers. The respondent pointed to the swift action taken upon being notified of the contraventions to reimburse the borrowers and rectify its computer system to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION and CHEQUECASH PTY LTD and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASAT 244
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered various factors prescribed by section 102(4) of the Code when determining the appropriate civil penalty. These factors included the conduct of the credit provider and debtor, whether the contravention was deliberate, the loss or detriment to the debtor, and the systems or procedures in place to prevent or identify contraventions. The applicant highlighted that the contraventions went unnoticed for approximately five years and that while ChequeCash had taken steps to remedy the situation, it was the applicant's application that brought the issue to light. The court also noted that the applicant filed its application on 30 October 2007, and that the applicant argued that a lesser penalty should be imposed if the credit provider self-identifies its breaches.
The tribunal found that ChequeCash Pty Ltd had indeed contravened the Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Code by misstating the total interest charges payable. Despite the absence of deliberate intent, the court deemed the systemic failures and the prolonged duration of the contraventions as serious breaches. Considering the prescribed factors, the tribunal imposed a civil penalty of $10,000 on ChequeCash Pty Ltd. Additionally, the tribunal awarded costs to the applicant, the Commissioner for Consumer Protection.
The final orders included a declaration that ChequeCash Pty Ltd had contravened the Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Code, a civil penalty of $10,000 imposed on the company, and an award of costs to the Commissioner for Consumer Protection. These orders reflect the tribunal's consideration of the severity of the breaches and the need to uphold the integrity of consumer credit laws.
Orders
Orders of the court
Contraventions of Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Code found Civil penalty of $10,000 imposed Costs awarded to applicant
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 102 of the Code provides relevantly:(1)Declaration as to key requirement. The Court must, on an application being made, by order declare whether or not the credit provider has contravened a key requirement in connection with the credit contract or contracts concerned. (2)Penalty orders. The Court may make an order, in accordance with this Division, requiring the credit provider to pay an amount as a civil penalty, if it is of the opinion that the credit provider has contravened a key requirement. …(4)Other matters to be considered. The Court, in considering the imposition of a civil penalty, must have regard to the following (a)the conduct of the credit provider and debtor before and after the credit contract was entered into; (b)whether the contravention was deliberate or otherwise; (c)the loss or other detriment (if any) suffered by the debtor as a result of the contravention; (d)when the credit provider first became aware, or ought reasonably to have become aware, of the contravention; (e)any systems or procedures of the credit provider to prevent or identify contraventions; (f)whether the contravention could have been prevented by the credit provider; (g)any action taken by the credit provider to remedy the contravention or compensate the debtor or to prevent further contraventions; (h)the time taken to make the application and the nature of the application; [and](i)any other matter the Court considers relevant. The admitted contraventions, which are the subject of the application, were breaches of s 15(E) of the Code, which provides:15.Matters that must be in contract documentThe contract document must contain the following matters …(E)Total amount of interest charges payable.The total amount of interest charges payable under the contract, if ascertainable (but only if the contract would, on the assumptions under sections 158 and 160, be paid out within 7 years of the date on which credit is first provided under the contract). The references to 'The Court' in s 102 of the Code are to be interpreted in accordance with the following definition of 'Court' which appears in s 1(1) of Sch 1 to the Code:Court, in relation to a provision of this Code, means the court or tribunal which has by law jurisdiction under that provision. Jurisdiction under s 102 of the Code is conferred on the Tribunal by reason of s 7(1) of the Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Act 1996 (CC Act). I will structure my findings in accordance with the factors prescribed by s 102(4) of the Code as those to which the Tribunal must have regard in considering the penalty to be imposed. The applicant accepts that the respondent did not deliberately overcharge its clients, but is highly critical of its failure to have in place a system which would have prevented the contraventions in the first place, and systems to continually monitor compliance with the key requirements, relevant to this matter, relating to interest charges. The systemic failure persisted for a period of approximately five years, until the applicant brought it to the respondent's attention. Further, although it was open to the respondent to bring an application under s 102 of the Code, on 30 October 2007 the applicant filed this application. The applicant submitted that the decided cases were consistently in favour of a lesser penalty being imposed where the credit provider uncovers its own breaches.