Commissioner for Consumer Affairs v Schmidt
[2004] SADC 23Judge Lee and Assessors Griguol and Hutchinson
Civil - Administrative and Disciplinary Division
This is a complaint by the Commissioner for Consumer Affairs of unlawful conduct by the defendant as a second-hand motor vehicle dealer.
At all relevant times, the defendant was the director and employee of Smitsu Pty Ltd, trading as Grantley Schmidt & Associates, and both the defendant and his company were licensed dealers under the Second-hand Vehicle Dealers Act 1995.
The complaint alleges five occasions of unlawful conduct against the defendant between July 2000 and January 2001. The defendant admits the allegations, which means that our only function is to determine what disciplinary action should be taken under the Act.
The unlawful conduct as particularised in the complaint can be summarised as follows.
On four occasions, the defendant sold second-hand vehicles to customers, but failed to remit to Transport SA monies received from those customers for stamp duty and transfer fees. The total amount involved was $5,184.
On two of those occasions, the defendant failed to remit to warranty providers monies received from customers for the purchase of warranties. The total amount involved was $1,099.
On a fifth occasion, the defendant sold a second-hand vehicle, which he had been holding for the vendor on consignment, to a third party, but failed to account to the vendor for the proceeds. The amount involved was $5,000.
The parties are in agreement that the defendant’s unlawful conduct occurred against the background of similar conduct on seven other occasions between about March 1999 and about February 2001, and on an eighth occasion when the defendant failed to honour statutory warranty obligations with respect to repair work carried out on a car purchased from Smitsu Pty Ltd.
Other facts are also common ground between the parties, namely
1.In July 1991, the defendant was a director of Fifth Harpoon Pty Ltd trading as Southern Nissan. The company was licensed as a dealer under the Act and went into liquidation. The company surrendered its licence on 28 February 1991. So, by virtue of s.9(1)(e) of the Act, the defendant was not eligible to be licensed as a dealer under the Act for a period of five years.
2.On 27 February 2002, the defendant and Smitsu Pty Ltd surrendered their licences.
3.On 18 June 2002, Smitsu Pty Ltd was wound up for the benefit of creditors.
4.Claims against the Second-hand Vehicles Compensation Fund by all 13 customers led to orders against the Fund in the total sum of $101,337.28.
To the extent that is relevant to these proceedings, the Second-hand Vehicle Dealers Act provides:
“27. (1) There is proper cause for disciplinary action against a dealer if–
….
(d)in the case of a dealer who has been employed or engaged to manage and supervise an incorporated dealer’s business–the dealer or another person has acted unlawfully, improperly, negligently or unfairly in the course of managing or supervising, or being employed or otherwise engaged in, that business;…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Consumer Affairs v Schmidt No. Dcadd-03-136 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] SADC 23
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to decide the appropriate disciplinary action for Schmidt's admitted unlawful conduct. The Commissioner argued for permanent disqualification and prohibition, while Schmidt's counsel suggested a suspension for a finite period. The court considered the nature and extent of Schmidt's conduct, which occurred against a background of similar conduct on other occasions, as well as the significant loss caused to the public and the drain on the Second-hand Vehicles Compensation Fund. The court concluded that Schmidt's conduct made him an unsuitable person to hold a licence in the future, and that a lesser penalty would not sufficiently deter others in the industry or maintain public confidence in the industry's integrity.
The court found that the nature and extent of Schmidt's conduct made him unsuitable to hold a licence in the future. Given the significant loss caused to the public and the drain on the Second-hand Vehicles Compensation Fund, the court determined that permanent disqualification and prohibition were necessary to protect the public and maintain public confidence in the industry. The court ordered that Schmidt be permanently disqualified from being licensed under the Act, permanently prohibited from being employed or otherwise engaged in the business of a dealer, and permanently prohibited from being a director or having an interest in a body corporate that is a dealer.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.