Comgroup Supplies Pty Ltd v Products for Industry Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Comgroup Supplies Pty Ltd v Products for Industry Pty Ltd & Anor [2016] QCA 88

PARTIES:

COMGROUP SUPPLIES PTY LIMITED
ACN 008 732 465

(applicant)v
PRODUCTS FOR INDUSTRY PTY LTD
ACN 111 733 576

(first respondent)GAVIN DUNWOODIE
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 1983 of 2015
DC No 3538 of 2012

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave s 118 DCA (Civil)
Application for Extension of Time s 118 DCA (Civil)

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2014] QDC 293

DELIVERED ON:

8 April 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24 August 2015

JUDGES:

Margaret McMurdo P and Atkinson and Mullins JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1.   Application for leave to appeal the decision made by the District Court on 19 December 2014 refused.

2.   Application for an extension of time to appeal refused.

3.   Application for leave to amend the application for leave to appeal refused.

4.   Unless the applicant files submissions on costs in accordance with paragraph 52(4) of Practice Direction 3 of 2013 within 14 days, with any response by the respondents with seven days of receipt of those submissions, the applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs of the applications.

CATCHWORDS:

EQUITY – TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – IMPLIED TRUSTS – CONSTRUCTIVE TRUSTS – KNOWING RECEIPT – where an employee of the applicant induced the first respondent, through its managing director, the second respondent, to invoice the applicant for work done by a company owned and controlled by the employee – where in fact no such work had been performed by the employee’s company and the invoices were a fabrication – where the applicant submitted that the issue of the fictitious invoices by the respondents constituted knowing assistance of the employee – where the applicant submitted that the respondents knowingly received the proceeds of payment of the invoices – whether the respondents’ held the kind of knowledge necessary to be found accessorily liable for the employee’s breach of fiduciary duty

EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – MISTAKE RECOVERY OF MONEY PAID OR EXPENDED – MONEY PAID BY MISTAKE – MISTAKE OF FACT – where the applicant paid money to the first respondent under an operative mistake of fact – where the respondents entered into the arrangement with the applicant’s employee in good faith – where the respondents would be placed in a worse position if ordered to make restitution of payments that it had passed on to the employee’s company than if it had not received payments from the applicant at all – whether the respondents could rely on a change of position defence to a claim by the applicant for restitution

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – WHEN APPEAL LIES – FROM DISTRICT COURT – BY LEAVE OF COURT – where the proposed appeal does not raise any significant questions of law but rather the application of well-established principles of law…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Comgroup Supplies Pty Ltd v Products for Industry Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCA 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Comgroup Supplies Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of Consolidated Foods Australia Limited, sought to recover a loss of $277,484 from Products for Industry Pty Ltd and its managing director, Gavin Dunwoodie, in the District Court. Comgroup alleged that Products for Industry and Mr Dunwoodie were involved in a fraudulent scheme orchestrated by Comgroup's former engineering manager, Gabriel Soldini. Soldini had induced Products for Industry to invoice Comgroup for work that was never performed by his own company, which was owned and controlled by him. The District Court dismissed Comgroup's claims for damages, deceit, knowing assistance/knowing receipt, breach of contract, restitution, and constructive trust, among others. The court found that Products for Industry and Mr Dunwoodie were not knowingly involved in Soldini's fraud and dismissed the claims against them. Comgroup appealed the decision to the Queensland Court of Appeal.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether Products for Industry and Mr Dunwoodie were liable for knowing receipt, whether they could rely on a change of position defence to a claim for restitution, and whether leave to appeal should be granted. The Court of Appeal found that Products for Industry and Mr Dunwoodie were not liable for knowing receipt as there was no evidence that they had the requisite knowledge to be found accessorily liable for Soldini's breach of fiduciary duty. The court also held that Products for Industry and Mr Dunwoodie could rely on a change of position defence to a claim for restitution as they had entered into the arrangement with Soldini in good faith and would be placed in a worse position if ordered to make restitution of payments that they had passed on to Soldini's company than if they had not received payments from Comgroup at all. The Court of Appeal held that leave to appeal should not be granted as the proposed appeal did not raise any significant questions of law but rather the application of well-established principles of law to the facts.

The Court of Appeal refused Comgroup's application for leave to appeal the decision made by the District Court on 19 December 2014, as well as its application for an extension of time to appeal and its application for leave to amend the application for leave to appeal. The Court of Appeal ordered that unless Comgroup filed submissions on costs in accordance with Practice Direction 3 of 2013 within 14 days, it was to pay the respondents' costs of the applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application for leave to appeal the decision made by the District Court on 19 December 2014 refused.

2. Application for an extension of time to appeal refused.

3. Application for leave to amend the application for leave to appeal refused.

4. Unless the applicant files submissions on costs in accordance with paragraph 52(4) of Practice Direction 3 of 2013 within 14 days, with any response by the respondents with seven days of receipt of those submissions, the applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs of the applications.

Background

Background to the litigation

As far as the application to appeal the costs order is concerned, if leave to appeal the substantive decision is granted, it would be convenient to deal with the costs order as well. If leave to appeal is not granted, then the applicant conceded that there would be no power in this court to grant leave independently on the application to appeal the costs order.[5] If leave to appeal were to be granted, then the respondents’ proposed cross-appeal should also be considered.[5]State of Queensland v Munro [2014] QCA 231 at [52] (Muir JA), [57]–[61] (Peter Lyons J).The background facts The applicant, Comgroup, is a subsidiary of Consolidated Foods Australia Limited. It produces and processes snap-frozen raw and cooked food products and sells them to fast food chains in Australia and also exports its products to the Middle East and Asia. Its turnover is about $100 million a year. It employs between 140 and 160 people in its production plant. On 22 February 2010, Comgroup, after a rigorous recruitment process, appointed Gabriel Soldini as its engineering manager. Unbeknown to Comgroup, Mr Soldini had been dismissed by a previous employer for serious misconduct in May 2009. That misconduct was similar to the dishonesty referred to in this case. He worked for Comgroup until he was made redundant in July 2012. The learned trial judge found that Mr Soldini was employed in that role from June 2009, but that is not supported by the documentation relied upon at trial. It does not appear to have had any impact on the judgment so is not a matter of any importance. One of the conditions of Mr Soldini’s employment was that he not have any direct or indirect pecuniary interests that would in any way compromise the performance of his duties and, in particular, that he not hold any position for monetary or other reward which could conflict with his responsibilities to Comgroup. As engineering manager, Mr Soldini had an operating budget of over $2 million and was responsible for 14 employees and for the repair and maintenance of the production plant. He had the authority to order goods and services to a certain financial limit. The procedure was that he would raise a purchase order for those goods and services; the purchase order would be sent to the supplier of the goods or services; the goods or services would be supplied; the supplier would send an invoice to Comgroup; Mr Soldini would initial and date the invoice to show the work had been done or the goods supplied; the signed invoice would be passed on to Comgroup’s accounts department for payment; the invoice would then be checked against the purchase order and authorised for payment. Payment would not be made without an invoice signed by Mr Soldini showing that the work had been done. Products for Industry carried on the business of designing and supplying machine safety systems, machine automation systems and engineered mechanical systems. Gavin Dunwoodie is the managing director of Products for Industry. Mr Dunwoodie knew Mr Soldini from a previous work association in Victoria in about 2003 or 2004. Mr Dunwoodie made contact with Mr Soldini in mid to late 2010 and, on behalf of Comgroup, Mr Soldini offered work to Products for Industry. In accordance with the usual practice, Mr Dunwoodie dealt with the engineering manager for Comgroup in arranging work and payment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Comgroup took proceedings in the District Court against Products for Industry and Mr Dunwoodie to recover its loss of $277,484. The relief and causes of action pleaded in the alternative were for damages and/or compensation for misleading and deceptive conduct pursuant to s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“TPA”) and/or s 236 of Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (“CCA”); damages and exemplary damages for deceit; money had and received by the defendants for the use of the plaintiff (as a result of knowing assistance or knowing receipt); damages for breach of contract or for consideration that had totally failed; restitution of money paid by Comgroup to Products for Industry under a mistake of fact; a declaration that the defendants held the sum paid to the Products for Industry on constructive trust for Comgroup and an order that they account to it for that sum; and equitable damages. In each case, apart from exemplary damages, the amount claimed was $277,484. Comgroup also claimed interest on that sum and costs.The judgment at first instance The learned trial judge characterised these proceedings as a dispute as to which of two innocent parties is to suffer for the fraud of a third. The trial judge did not find any want of reasonable care by Comgroup in employing Mr Soldini as its engineering manager. The trial judge accepted that the arrangement made by Mr Soldini with Mr Dunwoodie was a normal transaction in business. Evidence was given on behalf of Comgroup that they had never entered into an arrangement of the type whereby an approved supplier would invoice for work done by an unapproved supplier. The judge recorded the scepticism of the plaintiff about the arrangement and also his own initial scepticism. He referred to the fact that as well as Mr Dunwoodie’s evidence, the defendants called three apparently independent witnesses involved in the engineering contracting business who testified to the fact that they had been involved in or knew of similar arrangements and that such arrangements were common place because of the practice of large companies having only a limited number of authorised vendors. The learned trial judge said that he saw no good reason to reject this evidence. The learned trial judge then made relevant findings of fact as to the details of the transactions that occurred. He accepted that the defendant in general, and Mr Dunwoodie in particular, were not knowingly involved in Mr Soldini’s fraud. Because of that finding he dismissed the claim in deceit. So far as the knowing assistance/knowing receipt claim was concerned, the claim was dismissed because after going through all of the factors which, on Comgroup’s submission, would or should have led Mr Dunwoodie to suspect that Mr Soldini was acting in breach of his fiduciary duty to his employer, the judge concluded that he was not persuaded on the evidence that Mr Dunwoodie ought to have known that Mr Soldini’s conduct was in breach of his fiduciary duty to Comgroup or that a reasonable person would conclude that there was impropriety in Mr Soldini’s conduct. The judge found there was no breach of contract between the plaintiff and defendant nor any total failure of consideration. The trial judge dismissed the claim for misleading and deceptive conduct. He held that if, contrary to that finding, the defendants were liable for misleading and deceptive conduct, he would apportion the liability under s 87CD of the Australian Consumer Law (“ACL”), 5 per cent to the defendants and 95 per cent to Mr Soldini.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether the respondents knowingly received the proceeds of payment of the invoices and held the kind of knowledge necessary to be found accessorily liable for the employee’s breach of fiduciary duty. The court found that the trial judge was not persuaded on the evidence that Mr Dunwoodie ought to have known that Mr Soldini’s conduct was in breach of his fiduciary duty to Comgroup or that a reasonable person would conclude that there was impropriety in Mr Soldini’s conduct. The court considered the evidence and the trial judge’s findings of fact and concluded that the respondents were not knowingly involved in Mr Soldini’s fraud. Therefore, the court dismissed the claim for knowing assistance/knowing receipt.

The court then addressed the issue of whether the respondents could rely on a change of position defence to a claim by the applicant for restitution. The court found that the respondents would be placed in a worse position if ordered to make restitution of payments that it had passed on to the employee’s company than if it had not received payments from the applicant at all. The court held that the respondents could not rely on a change of position defence and dismissed the claim for restitution.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether leave to appeal should be granted from the District Court by leave of court. The court considered the nature of the appeal and the application of well-established principles of law to the facts. The court concluded that the proposed appeal did not raise any significant questions of law and that leave to appeal should not be granted. The court referred to prior authority and distinguished the case from other decisions where leave to appeal had been granted.

In summary, the court applied the legal principles of knowing receipt and change of position defence to the facts of the case and concluded that the respondents were not accessorily liable for the employee’s breach of fiduciary duty and could not rely on a change of position defence. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that a party cannot be found accessorily liable for the breach of fiduciary duty of another party if they did not have the necessary knowledge of the breach and cannot rely on a change of position defence if they would be placed in a worse position if ordered to make restitution.