JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: COMBES & ANOR and CITY OF NEDLANDS [2014] WASAT 65
MEMBER: MR P DE VILLIERS (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)
HEARD: 13 AND 16 MAY 2014
DELIVERED : 4 JUNE 2014
FILE NO/S: DR 30 of 2014
BETWEEN: OLINKA COMBES
CLAYTON KENDALL
ApplicantsAND
CITY OF NEDLANDS
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning Development application Scheme provisions for garage walls on side boundaries Whether provisions of Residential Design Codes of Western Australia 2013 apply Definition of 'garage' House of 'substantial construction' Whether 'substantial construction' should be adjacent to proposed garage Evident purpose of clause Whether light and ventilation to rooms adversely affected Condition of planning approval Notification of condition on title Whether notification is reasonable and appropriate
Legislation:
City of Nedlands Town Planning Scheme No 2, cl 1.3, cl 5.2.3, cl 5.6.3, cl 6.4.2, Pt 5
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
Residential Design Codes of Western Australia 2013, cl 5.1.2, cl 5.1.3, cl 5.2.1, cl 5.4.2
Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), s 70A
Result:
Application for review allowed for both proposed garage and pergola subject to conditions
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
Following the approval of a proposed residence at No 10 (Lot 246) Carrington Street, Nedlands in October 2013 the applicants sought approval for the inclusion of a pergola structure on the southern side of the residence and a reduction in the setback to the double garage adjacent to the western boundary.
The two substantive matters for the Tribunal were whether the pergola should be approved and, if so, what conditions should be attached to any such approval, and whether the proposed double garage should be set back 1 metre from the western boundary, as previously approved by the respondent or, 20 millimetres as proposed by the applicants.
In regard to the pergola, the question in dispute between the parties was whether an approval should include a section 70A notification (under the Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA)) on the title to inform any future landowner that the pergola could be used for parking vehicles. On this issue, the Tribunal concluded that the circumstances of the current review could not in any substantive sense be distinguished from relevant previous decisions of the Tribunal, and it would not be appropriate to attach this condition. It should however be noted that the applicants undertook to construct permanent planter boxes restricting vehicle access to the pergola.
In regard to the boundary wall, given the explicit provisions of the City of Nedlands Town Planning Scheme No 2, the Tribunal rejected the respondent's argument that, should the Tribunal find that the proposed boundary wall met the tests established by the City of Nedlands Town Planning Scheme No 2, it would in addition be necessary to assess the wall against the design principles of the Residential Design Codes 2013.
Furthermore, the Tribunal found that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Combes & Anor and City Of Nedlands and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] WASAT 65
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the provisions of the Residential Design Codes applied to the proposed garage and pergola, particularly concerning the definition of 'garage', the requirement for a house of 'substantial construction' to be adjacent to the proposed garage, and the evident purpose of the clause in question. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the proposed development would adversely affect light and ventilation to the adjoining properties and whether the conditions of planning approval, including the notification of these conditions on the title, were reasonable and appropriate.
The court found that the provisions of the Residential Design Codes applied to the proposed garage and pergola. It held that the evident purpose of the clause was to restrict the height of garage walls on side boundaries to ensure adequate light and ventilation to adjoining properties. The court concluded that the proposed garage and pergola complied with the scheme provisions and did not adversely affect the light and ventilation to the adjoining properties. Furthermore, the court determined that the conditions of planning approval, including the notification of these conditions on the title, were reasonable and appropriate.
Accordingly, the court granted approval for the pergola and garage as indicated on the plans, subject to specific conditions to ensure compliance with the approved plans and to maintain the integrity of the adjoining properties. These conditions included restrictions on the use of the pergola for parking, requirements for the pergola to remain an unenclosed open-framed structure, and specifications for the construction and finishing of the garage boundary wall.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. In accordance with the provisions of the City of Nedlands Town Planning Scheme No 2 and the authority delegated to the Council (or the Tribunal in its place) under the provisions of the Metropolitan Region Scheme, approval to commence development is granted for the pergola and garage as indicated on the plans on Sheets 1 and 2 by Ritter Building Design dated 14 November 2013 and the revised Elevations on the plans dated 13 May 2014 (Sheet 3 of 3) subject to the following conditions:
(a) The development shall at all times comply with the approved plans and these conditions of approval.
(b) This approval only applies to the garage and the pergola shown on the approved plans.
(c) The pergola (as marked in red on the plans) is not to be used for parking.
(d) In order to ensure that the pergola is not used for car parking, the planter boxes shown in Elevation 2 on the approved plans dated 13 May 2014 (Sheet 3 of 3) must be put in place before the dwelling is first occupied, and must thereafter remain in place unless their removal or modification is subsequently approved by the City of Nedlands.
(e) The pergola (as marked in red on the plans) must remain an unenclosed open-framed structure covered in a water permeable material or unroofed.
(f) All footings and structures of the garage boundary wall shall be constructed wholly inside the site boundaries.
(g) The garage boundary wall shall be finished to a professional standard, to the satisfaction of the City of Nedlands provided access is granted by the adjoining lot owner to finish the wall.
(h) All stormwater from the development, which includes permeable and non-permeable areas, shall be contained onsite by draining to soakwells of adequate capacity to contain run-off from a 20 year recurrent storm event. Soakwells shall be a minimum capacity of 1.0 m³ for every 80 m² of calculated surface area of the development.
(i) Any additional development or varied development which is not in accordance with the approved plans or these conditions of approval will require further approval by Council.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi