Colton v Dhelkaya Health

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Colton v Dhelkaya Health [2025] FCA 942

Appeal from:

Mayne v Dhelkaya Health [2024] FedCFamC2G 938

Colton v Dhelkaya Health [2024] FedCFamC2G 939

File number(s): VID 1116 of 2024
VID 1117 of 2024
Judgment of: ANDERSON J
Date of judgment: 13 August 2025
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – appeals from decisions of Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) – where appellants alleged contraventions of general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in relation to respondent’s introduction of mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy – where FCFCOA found that appellants were dismissed by reason of inability to perform inherent requirements of their role on capacity grounds – various grounds of appeal – where appellants contend primary judge erred in making certain procedural orders which prevented the appellants from properly bringing their whole case – where appellants contend primary judge wrongfully excluded evidence regarding the (un)safety, (in)efficacy and (in)effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines – where appellants contend the primary judge failed to determine certain conduct amounted to adverse action – where appellants contend primary judge erred in determining that the operative reason for taking any adverse action was to give effect to the operative public health directions – where appellants sought to challenge certain factual findings of the primary judge – no error disclosed in the reasons of the primary judge – appeals dismissed.
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic)

Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic)

COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (Specified Facilities) Order 2022 (No. 6) (Vic)

Cases cited: Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 331 ALR 550; [2016] HCA 22
Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 53
Date of hearing: 15 July 2025
Solicitor for the Appellant: Mr G Ryan
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M Minucci
Solicitor for the Respondent: MinterEllison

ORDERS

VID 1116 of 2024
BETWEEN:

LEONARD BERNARD COLTON

Appellant

AND:

DHELKAYA HEALTH

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ANDERSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 AUGUST 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.By 4pm on 25 August 2025, the Respondent file any affidavit material and any written submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) on the question of costs.

3.By 4pm on 3 September 2025, the Appellant file any affidavit material and any written submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) on the question of costs.

4.By 4pm on 8 September 2025, the parties are to contact the Associate to Justice Anderson to confirm if either party wishes to be heard orally on the question of costs, failing which costs will be determined on the papers.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ORDERS

VID 1117 of 2024
BETWEEN:

BERNADETTE THERESE MAYNE

Appellant

AND:

DHELKAYA HEALTH

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ANDERSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 AUGUST 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.By 4pm on 25 August 2025, the Respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colton v Dhelkaya Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 942
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Colton v Dhelkaya Health, the appellants, employees of Dhelkaya Health, appealed against the decisions of the primary judge who found that they were dismissed due to their inability to perform the inherent requirements of their roles due to capacity grounds, specifically their inability to comply with the employer's mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy. The appellants argued that the primary judge made certain procedural orders that prevented them from properly presenting their case, wrongfully excluded evidence regarding the safety, efficacy, and effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines, and failed to determine that certain conduct by the employer amounted to adverse action. They also contended that the primary judge erred in determining that the reason for taking adverse action was to comply with public health directives.

The legal issues before the court were whether the primary judge made any procedural errors in excluding evidence or limiting the scope of the appellants' case, whether the primary judge correctly excluded evidence about the safety and efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines, and whether the primary judge properly applied the relevant sections of the Fair Work Act 2009. The court found that the primary judge had correctly applied the law and made no procedural errors that would warrant an appeal. The primary judge had rightly excluded evidence about the safety and efficacy of the vaccines as it was not relevant to the reason for the appellants' dismissal, which was their failure to comply with the employer's vaccination policy. The court also found that the primary judge correctly determined that the reason for the adverse action was to comply with public health directives.

The reasoning of the court was that the primary judge had correctly applied the law and made no procedural errors that would warrant an appeal. The court found that the primary judge had rightly excluded evidence about the safety and efficacy of the vaccines as it was not relevant to the reason for the appellants' dismissal, which was their failure to comply with the employer's vaccination policy. The court also found that the primary judge correctly determined that the reason for the adverse action was to comply with public health directives. The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the parties file written submissions on costs by specified dates, with an option for an oral hearing if requested by either party.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. By 4pm on 25 August 2025, the Respondent file any affidavit material and any written submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) on the question of costs.

3. By 4pm on 3 September 2025, the Appellant file any affidavit material and any written submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) on the question of costs.

4. By 4pm on 8 September 2025, the parties are to contact the Associate to Justice Anderson to confirm if either party wishes to be heard orally on the question of costs, failing which costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The path of reasoning disclosed in the PJs make it clear that the primary judge considered ss 360 and 361 of the FW Act. Grounds 7 and 8 of the Colton Appeal, and Grounds 9 and 10 of the Mayne Appeal fail to identify any appellable error in the Primary Judgments. It follows that these Grounds must be dismissed. 3.5 Ground 10 (Colton Appeal) and Grounds 7 and 12 (Mayne Appeal): Failure to consider and determine facts in the Appellants’ favour Ground 10 of the Colton Appeal and Grounds 7 and 12 of the Mayne Appeal do not provide any legal basis upon which it could be said the matters identified amount to an error of fact or of law that would give rise to an appellable error. The primary judge’s conclusions as to consultation were open to her on the evidence. This Court, on appeal, will not interfere with the primary judge’s findings of fact unless they are demonstrated to be wrong by “incontrovertible facts or uncontested testimony”, or they are “glaringly improbable” or “contrary to compelling inferences”: Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 331 ALR 550; [2016] HCA 22 at [43] (French CJ, Bell, Keane, Nettle and Gordon JJ). The Appellants on this appeal have not demonstrated error by the primary judge in the findings that her Honour made in relation to the evidence. For these reasons, Ground 10 of the Colton Appeal and Grounds 7 and 12 of the Mayne Appeal must be dismissed. 3.6 Ground 11 (Colton Appeal) and Ground 13 (Mayne Appeal) – Wrong assumption of strict liability Ground 11 of the Colton Appeal and Ground 13 of the Mayne Appeal are misconceived. At no stage of the proceedings was the legal effect or validity of the specified facilities order or the workplace order an issue for determination in the proceedings. The relevant fact, as found by the primary judge, is that the Respondent took the view that the mandatory vaccination directions which commenced on 7 September 2021 applied to all its employees, since the Respondent was predominantly an aged care facility and employees were required to work across all areas of the hospital: Mayne PJ, [65]. The primary judge was entitled to make the finding that she did at paragraphs [59]-[66] of the Colton PJ, and [57]-[65] of the Mayne PJ. For the reasons given, Ground 11 of the Colton Appeal and Ground 13 of the Mayne Appeal must be dismissed. 4. DISPOSITION The Appeals will be dismissed. In the event that the Appeals were dismissed, the Respondent asked to be heard on the question of costs. The Respondent shall, by 25 August 2025, file any affidavit material and written submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) as to costs. The Appellants shall, by 3 September 2025, file any affidavit material and written submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) as to costs. Subject to the parties indicating that they wish to be heard orally on the question of costs, I intend to determine the question of costs on the papers.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As the primary judge observed in the PJs, the “critical issue in the present case turns on the Respondent’s reason(s) for the action it took (or inaction, as the case may be)”. The primary judge concluded that the substantive and operative reasons for the Appellants’ dismissals were separate and distinct from the exercise or proposed exercise of a workplace right. The primary judge found that the Appellants were dismissed because of their failure to provide the requested proof of vaccination against COVID-19 or an applicable exemption in accordance with the then operative public health orders: Colton PJ at [125]; Mayne PJ at [142].Exclusion of evidence as to the Vaccine Issue was appropriate At the hearing before the primary judge, and in light of the concession made, the Respondent objected to any and all evidence that went to establishing the Vaccine Issue. That is, the Respondent contended that the evidence was irrelevant and therefore inadmissible by reason of s 56(2) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The Appellants were on notice of this from at least the 5 February 2024 case management hearing. The primary judge observed on that occasion:I can indicate to you Mr Ryan, that it would seem based on the concession that has been made by the respondent that there is no need for expert evidence to prove the safety of the COVID vaccine or otherwise, because they accept your clients held a view about that. And so that ought to confine the evidence … so you can take on notice, that concession, for what it is. It is not correct to submit, as the Appellants seek to do, that there was a lack of notice or proper opportunity to respond. The Appellants were squarely on notice, through the explicit comments made by the primary judge, that there would be issues as to the relevance of such evidence in light of the concession made by the Respondents. Additionally, while the Appellants’ now seek to submit that, by excluding the evidence regarding the Vaccine Issue, they were deprived of the opportunity to prove their case, they have not substantively engaged with the correctness of the primary judge’s approach. The primary judge was plainly correct to state that, in light of the concession made by the Respondent, the truth of the (un)safety, (in)efficacy and (in)effectiveness of the COVID-19 vaccines did not need to be established as an issue in the Proceedings. It follows that without establishing an error in the primary judge’s approach to this issue, it cannot logically follow that the Appellants were somehow deprived of the opportunity to prove their case when the evidence that was excluded was not in respect of a live issue in the Proceedings. The Respondent’s objection was appropriately taken in accordance with the 5 February Orders. The Appellants were on notice, well in advance of the hearing, of the nature of the objections. It was reasonable and open to the primary judge to determine the objections and refuse to admit that evidence. The Appellants have failed to establish any appellable error in the primary judge’s decision to exclude the evidence. The Appellants’ submissions, that the Court was wrong to assume any evidence that touched on the safety and effectiveness of the COVID-19 vaccines was irrelevant, fails to understand the operative question in the Proceedings, being, as identified by the primary judge, the Respondent’s reason(s) for the action it took.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 23 September 2024, after a hearing on 2 and 3 May 2024, the primary judge dismissed the Proceedings and ordered costs be reserved. The primary judge published separate reasons in respect of each of the Proceedings (referred to collectively in these reasons as the Primary Judgments or PJs, and separately as the Colton PJ and Mayne PJ respectively). The primary judge noted that as the cases were factually distinct, the reasons in each stood alone, but bore similarities to the extent of common issues of law and procedure. By way of Notices of Appeal and Supplementary Notices of Appeal, the Appellants appeal the Primary Judgments. While separate appeals have been filed in relation to each of the Primary Judgments (to which I will refer to as the Colton Appeal and Mayne Appeal respectively, and collectively, as the Appeals), the grounds of appeal filed in each are broadly similar in effect and are addressed together in these reasons. The supplementary notices of appeal contain many generalised allegations of error with little attempt to identify the legal basis for the grounds of appeal relied upon. Notwithstanding, taking the appeals at their highest, the appeals allege that the primary judge erred in the following respects:(a)wrongfully making the interlocutory orders dated 5 February 2024 and limiting the Appellants’ cases to each of the Form F2s filed in each of the Proceedings with certain amendments (5 February Orders): Grounds 1-3 of the Appeals; (b)wrongfully determining that, in circumstances where the Respondent accepted the Appellants’ beliefs about the (un)safety, (in)efficacy and (in)effectiveness of the COVID-19 vaccines (the Vaccine Issue), the truth of that belief did not need to be proved for the Appellants to be successful in their cases. In light of that finding, ruling that evidence that went to the Vaccine Issue was not relevant or admissible: Grounds 4-5 of the Appeals; Ground 5A of the Colton Appeal; Ground 6 of the Mayne Appeal; (c)failing to determine that certain actions amounted to adverse action by the Respondent: Grounds 6 and 9 of the Colton Appeal; Grounds 8 and 11 of the Mayne Appeal; (d)failing to apply ss 360 and 361 of the FW Act, including by failing to find that the Respondent’s reasons for taking adverse action included the proscribed reason, being that the appellants had not become vaccinated: Grounds 7 and 8 of the Colton Appeal; Grounds 9 and 10 of the Mayne Appeal; (e)failing to consider and determine a number of factual matters in the Appellants' favour: Ground 10 of the Colton Appeal; Grounds 7 and 12 of the Mayne Appeal; and (f)wrongly assuming the Respondent’s liability to prevent unvaccinated employees from attending its facilities was a strict liability and failing to consider s 203(2) of the Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic): Ground 11 of the Colton Appeal; Ground 13 of the Mayne Appeal. 2. BACKGROUND I do not intend to traverse, in these reasons, the factual matrix leading to the Respondent’s decision to terminate the employment of the Appellants. This has been covered in detail within the reasons of the primary decision and is largely unchallenged on appeal. However, given the grounds of appeal, it is relevant to outline the procedural background in some detail.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.