Colmenares v Neilson (Civil Dispute)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

COLMENARES v NEILSON (Civil Dispute) [2022] ACAT 51

XD 419/2021

Catchwords:               CIVIL DISPUTE – cost of hire of replacement vehicle – delay in carrying out the repairs – whether vehicle hired was unduly expensive

Cases cited:Arsalan v Rixon [2021] HCA 40

Rixon v Arsalan [2019] NSWSC 1136

Tribunal:Senior Member A Anforth

Date of Orders:  15 June 2022

Date of Reasons for Decision:      15 June 2022

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          XD 419/2021

BETWEEN:

PABLO COLMENARES

Applicant

AND:

EMILY NEILSON

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member A Anforth

DATE:15 June 2022

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The respondent to pay the applicant the sum of $10,773.40 within 28 days of this order.

………………………………..
Senior Member A Anforth AM

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. In July 2020 the respondent ‘rear ended’ the applicant’s vehicle causing damage. The damage to the applicant’s car was repaired under insurance. The applicant’s vehicle was a Toyota MR2 which is apparently an up-market prestige vehicle.

  2. The applicant claimed from the respondent the cost of hiring a replacement vehicle from 6 October 2020 to 23 February 2021 at a cost of $10,701.90 plus the tribunal lodgement fee of $71.50. The replacement vehicle was a Kia Rio S which apparently is also an up-market prestige vehicle similar to the damaged vehicle.

  3. The respondent denied the claim on the basis that:

    (a)the hire car was unnecessarily expensive;

    (b)the hire car was hired for an excessive period of time; and

    (c)the applicant had another vehicle open to him during the period of the hire.

  4. The chronology of events is a as follows:

    29 Jul 20The accident

    6 Oct 20The applicant took his damaged vehicle to Hume Bodyworks and hired the replacement vehicle;

    19 Oct 20The repairer ordered the necessary body parts;

    22 Oct 20The parts wholesaler (Janrule Parts) dispatched two of the ordered parts to the repair and notified that the other two items would have to be ordered from Japan which would take eight weeks.

  5. On 28 April 2021, the applicant filed his application in the tribunal. On 26 May 2021 the respondent filed her response denying the claim.

  6. The matter was listed for conference on 25 June 2021 and was adjourned to permit further negotiations. The matter failed to settle at the resumed conference on 19 July 2021 and was listed for hearing on 1 October 2021. Orders were made for filing of evidence, submissions and the issue of subpoenas.

  7. On 27 September 2021 the applicant filed:

    (a)A timeline of events.

    (b)An invoice from Compass Corp Pty Ltd for the cost of the hire of the car for 141 days at $69 per day, delivery of $65 and GST coming to a total of $10,773.40.

    (c)An invoice from Janrule Parts dated 22 October 2020.

    (d)An undated invoice from Hume Bodyworks for the sum of $5,202.66. The invoice itemised the parts at $1,936.09 plus GST and labour of 34.92 hours at $80 per hour.

    (e)Photographs of the damage to the rear of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colmenares v Neilson (Civil Dispute) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACAT 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Colmenares v Neilson was a case before the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) in which the applicant sought to recover the cost of hiring a replacement vehicle following an accident. The dispute centred around the fairness of the amount charged for the hire car and the delay in repairing the applicant's vehicle. The respondent argued that the cost of the hire car was excessive and that the delay was unreasonable.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the hire car was unduly expensive and whether the delay in repairing the original vehicle was unreasonable. The Tribunal examined the evidence regarding the cost of the hire car and the reasons for the delay in repairing the vehicle. The applicant provided evidence of the cost of the hire car, while the respondent argued that the hire car was more expensive than necessary.

The Tribunal found that the cost of the hire car was reasonable and that the delay in repairing the vehicle was not unreasonable. The Tribunal considered the evidence of the cost of the hire car and found that it was reasonable in the circumstances. The Tribunal also found that the delay in repairing the vehicle was not unreasonable, given the complexity of the repairs and the availability of parts. The Tribunal therefore ordered the respondent to pay the applicant the sum of $10,773.40 within 28 days of the order.

In summary, the Tribunal found in favour of the applicant and ordered the respondent to pay the cost of the hire car. The Tribunal rejected the respondent's argument that the cost of the hire car was excessive and found that the delay in repairing the vehicle was not unreasonable. The Tribunal's decision provides guidance on the factors to consider when determining the reasonableness of the cost of a hire car and the reasonableness of a delay in repairing a vehicle.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The respondent to pay the applicant the sum of $10,773.40 within 28 days of this order.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.