Collins v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Collins v State of Queensland [2021] QCA 36

PARTIES:

KENNETH CHARLES COLLINS
(appellant)
v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 7047 of 2020
SC No 8473 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court of Queensland – [2020] QSC 154 (Holmes CJ)

DELIVERED ON:

5 March 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

9 February 2021

JUDGES:

Sofronoff P and Mullins JA and Boddice J

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to adduce further evidence be refused.

2.   The appeal be dismissed with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE’S FINDINGS OF FACT – PROOF AND EVIDENCE – OTHER MATTERS – where the primary Judge dismissed the appellant’s application to set aside a Deed of Settlement, signed by him on 9 September 2019, following a mediation of a claim the appellant had brought against the respondent, seeking damages for the destruction of a ship in 2016 – where the appellant appeals that decision on numerous grounds, said to constitute errors of fact or law – where the primary judge found that, whilst the notice of discontinuance had been signed and filed by the respondent prior to payment of the settlement sum, in breach of the terms of the Deed, it was not conclusive that that term was an essential term – whether the primary judge erred in both fact and law in the interpretation of the terms of the Deed of Settlement – whether the primary Judge failed to give adequate reasons – whether the primary Judge erred in rejecting the appellant’s contentions that the mediation had been conducted in breach of the rules of mediation

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES – ADMISSION OF FURTHER EVIDENCE – where the appellant accepted in argument that the various documents sought to be led by way of additional evidence constituted an elaboration of material relied upon by him at the hearing below, or constituted material reasonably available to him at the time of that hearing

COUNSEL:

The appellant appeared on his own behalf
M H Hindman QC for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The appellant appeared on his own behalf
Crown Law for the respondent

  1. SOFRONOFF P:  I agree with the reasons of Boddice J and with the orders proposed.

  2. MULLINS JA:  I agree with Boddice J.

  3. BODDICE J:  On 5 June 2020, the primary Judge dismissed the appellant’s application to set aside a Deed of Settlement, signed by him on 9 September 2019, following a mediation of a claim the appellant had brought against the respondent, seeking damages for the destruction of a ship in 2016.

  4. The appellant appeals that decision on numerous grounds, said to constitute errors of fact or law.  The appellant also seeks leave to adduce additional evidence.

    Background

  5. On 4 December 2016, a ship owned and operated by the appellant ran aground on Flat Rock, near South Stradbroke Island.  The ship was lost, despite a distress call by the appellant.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collins v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCA 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Collins v State of Queensland concerns the enforceability of a Deed of Settlement signed by the appellant, Collins, on 9 September 2019. Collins had commenced proceedings against the State of Queensland, alleging negligence and seeking damages for the destruction of his ship in 2016. After mediation, the parties executed a Deed of Settlement, which stipulated that Collins should execute a notice of discontinuance immediately, to be signed and filed by Queensland's solicitors after payment of the settlement sum. However, Queensland signed and filed the notice prior to payment, leading Collins to seek to set aside the Deed. The primary judge dismissed Collins' application, leading to this appeal.

The key legal issues in this case revolve around whether the primary judge erred in finding that the breach of the Deed's terms regarding the notice of discontinuance was not an essential term, whether the primary judge gave adequate reasons for his findings, and whether the mediation process was conducted in breach of mediation rules. Collins also contends that the primary judge erred in his interpretation of the Deed's terms.

The court found that Collins had not established any error of fact or law in the primary judge's decision. The court upheld the primary judge's findings that Collins entered into the Deed freely, despite his reluctance, and that there was no undue influence, duress, or unconscionability on the part of Queensland or the mediator. The court noted that mediations, while governed by certain rules, do not have the same structures as court hearings, and the primary judge correctly assessed that the mediator's conduct was within acceptable bounds. The court also rejected Collins' argument that the primary judge failed to give adequate reasons, finding the reasons provided to be clear and concise.

The court further ruled that Collins' request for leave to adduce additional evidence should be refused, as the material sought was either an elaboration of existing evidence or reasonably available at the time of the hearing below. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed, and the Deed of Settlement was upheld as enforceable. The primary judge's findings and reasons were supported, and no new evidence was admissible. Collins' dissatisfaction with the mediation process and the primary judge's decision did not establish any legal or factual errors warranting a reversal of the primary judge's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to adduce further evidence be refused.

2. The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals that decision on numerous grounds, said to constitute errors of fact or law. The appellant also seeks leave to adduce additional evidence.Background On 4 December 2016, a ship owned and operated by the appellant ran aground on Flat Rock, near South Stradbroke Island. The ship was lost, despite a distress call by the appellant. In 2018, the appellant commenced proceedings against the respondent, claiming damages for negligence. In essence, the appellant alleged he had suffered the loss of the ship and consequential loss due to the respondent’s failure to light the relevant hazard and to respond to his distress call. The respondent defended the proceeding, denying both liability and the quantum of the appellant’s claimed damages. In 2019, when the appellant was suffering significant health concerns, the appellant made applications for orders that his proceeding be determined at mediation. Ultimately, a mediation took place on 9 September 2019. At the time of the mediation, there was in existence, a mediation agreement and a mediator’s brief. The brief included the relevant pleadings, a response to the appellant’s notice to admit facts, outline of submissions and numerous other documents. The mediation was conducted before an experienced mediator on 9 September 2019. Both the appellant and the respondent were legally represented at the mediation. At the conclusion, the parties executed a Deed of Settlement. Relevantly, that Deed provided for the appellant to immediately execute a notice of discontinuance, which was to be signed and filed by the respondent’s solicitors after payment of a sum described as the settlement sum. Contrary to the terms of the Deed, the Notice of Discontinuance was signed by the respondent and filed by the respondent prior to payment of the settlement sum.Proceedings below On the day following execution of the Deed of Settlement and the Notice of Discontinuance, the appellant wrote to the mediator complaining of a denial of justice. Some days later the appellant’s solicitors sent a letter to the respondent’s solicitors alleging breach of the terms of the Deed. The appellant contended the notice of discontinuance was not to be signed and filed until payment had been made, but in breach of that term, the Notice had been filed prior to payment. The solicitors also asserted that the Deed had been signed in circumstances constituting undue influence and duress. Subsequently, the appellant filed an application to set aside the Deed of Settlement on the grounds that essential terms had been breached by the signing and filing of the notice of discontinuance prior to payment of the settlement sum. The appellant also contended the terms of the Deed were ambiguous and that, accordingly, it was unenforceable and void.Primary Judge’s findings The primary Judge found that, although the appellant was dismayed and overwhelmed by the process of the mediation, and accepting that the mediator had put aggressively to the appellant that he had caused the loss by mis-navigation, there was no basis to conclude that the appellant was subject to any special disadvantage, or that there was any demonstrated conflict of interest on the part of the mediator, or that the respondent had acted in bad faith in participating in the mediation, or that there was improper conduct by the appellant’s legal representatives.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the primary Judge properly found that there was no basis upon which the appellant could terminate that Deed of Settlement. The reasons for doing so were clearly and concisely set out in the judgment. There is no basis to find there was a failure to give adequate reasons.Conclusions The appellant has not established any error of fact or law in the primary Judge’s decision. The application below was properly dismissed.Orders I would order:1. Leave to adduce further evidence be refused.2. The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent further submits that the additional evidence sought to be adduced on appeal is not admissible. It is, at best, an elaboration of material relied upon by the appellant at mediation or was evidence which was reasonably available to the appellant at that time.ConsiderationLeave to adduce further evidence The appellant accepted in argument that the various documents sought to be led by way of additional evidence constituted an elaboration of material relied upon by him at the hearing below, or constituted material reasonably available to him at the time of that hearing. A consideration of the material sought to be led by way of additional evidence supports the accuracy of that concession. Having regard to that concession, there is no basis upon which the additional material ought to be received on the hearing of the appeal. None of it constitutes fresh or new evidence. Accordingly, I would refuse leave to adduce additional evidence.The Appeal Although the appellant sought to characterise the appeal as involving a consideration of the proper processes and the rules surrounding mediation, the appellant’s grounds of appeal and submissions must be viewed in the context of the relief sought by him in the hearing below. That relief related to the enforceability of the Deed of Settlement. A consideration of the appellant’s submissions supports a conclusion that his complaints about the mediation process are framed by what were his expectations of that process. Those expectations failed to have regard for the fact that a mediation is a process which, whilst conducted within certain rules, does not have the structures of a Court hearing. The fact that the mediation, as conducted by the mediator, failed to meet the appellant’s expectations is no basis for a conclusion that the mediation involved undue influence, duress or unconscionable conduct. As the primary Judge properly found, there is nothing impermissible in both a mediator and a party’s legal representatives referring to obvious difficulties that party may have in succeeding at trial, and the significant financial consequences in the event of an adverse costs order. A consideration of the record also amply supports the primary Judge’s findings that there is no basis to conclude that the appellant entered into the Deed of Settlement as a consequence of duress, undue influence or unconscionability on the part of the mediator or his legal representatives and, more importantly, no basis to conclude that the behaviour of the mediator and his legal representatives occurred with the knowledge of the respondent or at the respondent’s behest. The appellant entered into the Deed of Settlement freely, albeit reluctantly, with full knowledge of its consequences. His obvious disappointment thereafter forms no basis for findings to the contrary. A consideration of the record also amply supports a conclusion that the primary Judge correctly found no basis for the appellant’s contentions that the respondent’s conduct at mediation was in breach of the respondent’s obligation on mediation, or that the respondent did not fully and effectively participate or cooperate in the mediation in breach of the rules of a mediation.