Collins v Paget

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

COLLINS v PAGET & ORS

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle

23 July 2004

CRIMINAL LAW - ADMINISTRATION OF PRISONS - CIVIL LIABILITY

CRIMINAL LAW - ADMINISTRATION OF PRISONS - MISCELLANEOUS MATTERS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Plaintiff serving a sentence of imprisonment - search conducted of plaintiff's cell - order made directing that plaintiff be kept separate and apart from other prisoners - plaintiff transferred from F division to G division - whether search authorised by s 37(1) of the Correctional Services Act - whether order made to keep plaintiff separate and apart from other prisoners authorised by s 36 - whether duration of separation unreasonable - whether procedural requirements of s 36 satisfied - decision allowing plaintiff to have computer in cell revoked - whether revocation authorised under the Correctional Services Act - whether decision unreasonable - stamps removed from plaintiff's mail by prison management - whether removal of stamps from plaintiff's mail authorised by s 33 - whether plaintiff had right to have stamps placed in property - plaintiff authorised to subscribe to journal - journals and other mail items returned to the sender by prison management - whether return of journals amounted to conversion.

Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) s 23, s 23(3)(b), s 24, s 24(2)(b), s 30, s 32, s 33, s 33(4), s 33 (12), s 33A, ; Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) s 33A(4), s 33A(5), s 36, s 36(1), s 36(2)(a), s 36(2)(d), s 37(1), s 37(1)(b); Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) s 36(3); Correctional Services Act Regulations 1985 reg 6, reg  40(1); International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights article 2(3), article 3, article 5(1), article 10(3); Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 6(1), referred to.
Minogue v Williams (2000) 60 ALD 366; Collins v The State of South Australia (1999) 74 SASR 200, considered.

COLLINS v PAGET & ORS
[2004] SASC 206

  1. DOYLE CJ           Mr Collins has brought proceedings against the State.  He challenges the legality of certain aspects of his treatment while imprisoned.  He claims damages.

    Facts

  2. In April 1994 Mr Collins began to serve a sentence of imprisonment for 9 years 3 months for offences of fraudulent conversion and false pretences.  Mr Collins was released in March 2003 to serve the balance of his sentence on home detention.

  3. During his imprisonment Mr Collins was subject to the regime of control provided for by the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (“the CSA”): see in particular s 24 of the CSA (set out below). He spent periods of time in various correctional institutions, including Yatala Labour Prison, Cadell Training Centre, Mobilong Prison and the Adelaide Pre-Release Centre.

  4. In 1994 Mr Collins was given approval to purchase a computer and keep it in his cell, and in 1997 to commence certain education programs at his own expense.  He was allowed to upgrade his computer and purchase various software packages from time to time.  In 1997 Mr Collins began studies…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collins v Paget and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 206
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Collins v Paget involved a plaintiff who was serving a sentence of imprisonment. The plaintiff alleged that he had been subjected to various unauthorised actions by the prison authorities, including a search of his cell, an order to keep him separate from other prisoners, the removal of a computer from his cell, and the removal of stamps from his mail. The plaintiff further alleged that his journals and other mail items were returned to the sender by prison management, amounting to conversion. The plaintiff sought damages for these alleged breaches of his rights.

The legal issues before the court included whether the search of the plaintiff's cell and the order to keep him separate from other prisoners were authorised by the Correctional Services Act (CSA). The court also had to consider whether the duration of the separation was unreasonable and whether the procedural requirements of the Act were satisfied. Another issue was whether the revocation of the plaintiff's right to have a computer in his cell was authorised under the CSA and whether it was unreasonable. The court also had to determine whether the removal of stamps from the plaintiff's mail and the return of his journals to the sender by prison management were authorised by the CSA and whether they amounted to conversion.

The court found that the plaintiff did not establish any loss flowing from his removal to another division for 27 days. Even if the removal was not authorised, the plaintiff's imprisonment remained lawful. The court held that the CEO of the prison had the power to regulate or control the things that prisoners had and kept in their cells, and that any decision about participation in courses of education and training would be subject to decisions about what property a prisoner could have access to or keep in their cell. The court held that the provisions of the CSA gave the CEO and the manager of the correctional institution the power to make rules relating to the management of the institution. The court concluded that the plaintiff's claims were not established.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's claims and ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ
Mr Collins did not establish any loss flowing from his removal to G division for 27 days. Even if the removal was not authorised, his imprisonment remained lawful. In the circumstances it is not necessary to explore the issue of whether his claim, if made out, would entitle him to damages.The decision to remove the personal computer Mr Collins argues that the decision to refuse to permit him to keep his personal computer in his cell did not comply with sections 23, 30 and 32 of the CSA. Section 23 requires the CEO to have prisoners assessed. Section 23 (3) (b) requires the assessment of prisoners to have regards to education needs. Section 30 requires the CEO to arrange for such courses of instruction or training as the CEO thinks fit to be made available to prisoners. Section 32 provides for the purchase of items of personal use by prisoners. Mr Collins argues that he purchased the computer and software to advance his education and training, and that the CEO was obliged to allow him to keep them and use them for that purpose. The CEO or his delegates may have made decisions pursuant to these sections, allowing Mr Collins to purchase and have access to his computer in his cell for educational purposes and undertake a course of training. The decisions made in this respect were not proved. It does not follow that the CEO, having made a decision in respect of education and training, and more specifically to allow access to a personal computer, cannot revoke it. Pursuant to s 30 the CEO must arrange for such courses of instruction or training as he thinks fit. This does not mean that having allowed a prisoner to embark on a course of instruction or training the CEO cannot vary or revoke the decision. Section 24 (2) (b) of the CSA provides: “24 (2) Subject to this Act, the Chief Executive Officer has an absolute discretion- …(b)to establish with respect of any particular prisoner, or prisoner of a particular class, or in respect of prisoners placed in any particular part of the correctional institution, such a regime for work, recreation, contact with other prisoners or any other aspect of the day-to-day life of prisoners,as from time to time seems expedient to the Chief Executive Officer.” Under s 83 the manager of a correctional institution has the power to make rules relating to the management of the institution. I am satisfied that these provisions give the CEO and the manager of the correctional institution in question power to regulate or control the things that prisoners have and keep in their cells. The power is not limited to creating a regime of prohibited items the presence of which will attract sanctions. It is inherent in the concept of imprisonment, and implicit in the provisions of the CSA, that the CEO has control over the possessions of prisoners. Any decision by the CEO about participation by a prisoner in courses of education and training would properly be subject to and affected by decisions about what property a prisoner could have access to or keep in his cell.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ