Collins and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

COLLINS & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2008] WASAT 112



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2008] WASAT 112
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:262/200721 FEBRUARY 2008
Coram:MS M CONNOR (MEMBER)20/05/08
17Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: The application is allowed
The decision of the respondent is set aside and conditional approval is granted
B
PDF Version
Parties:WAYNE THOMAS COLLINS
SUSAN ELIZABETH COLLINS
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Catchwords:

Town planning ­ Subdivision of rural land ­ Realignment of boundaries for farming purposes with no increase in the number of lots ­ 67 hectare lot created for sandalwood production ­ Amalgamation of balance land to create 1039 hectare lot for broadacre farming ­ Whether subdivision is consistent with planning framework ­ Whether, if subdivided, the subject land which has productive capacity for agricultural production would be lost as a resource ­ Breakdown of viable farmholding ­ Economic viability ­ Rural lifestyle lot ­ Diversification ­ Environmental benefits

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 25, s 135, s 138, s 241, s 251(1)
Shire of York Town Planning Scheme No 2
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 5AA

Case References:

Ingram & Anor v Western Australian Planning Commission [2003] WASCA 77

Orders

1. The application for review is allowed.,2. The decision of the respondent to refuse to approve the subdivision of Lot 4 and Lot 11 Badgin Road, Narraloggan is set aside and a decision is substituted that subdivision approval is granted as shown on the plan prepared by Ian C Ross (Licensed Surveyor) dated 20 April 2007, subject to the following condition:,1) Suitable arrangements being made with the local government for the provision of vehicular crossover(s) to service the lot(s) shown on the approved plan of subdivision. (Local Government)

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES ACT : PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA) CITATION : COLLINS & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2008] WASAT 112 MEMBER : MS M CONNOR (MEMBER) HEARD : 21 FEBRUARY 2008 DELIVERED : 20 MAY 2008 FILE NO/S : DR 262 of 2007 BETWEEN : WAYNE THOMAS COLLINS
    SUSAN ELIZABETH COLLINS
    Applicants

    AND

    WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
    Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning ­ Subdivision of rural land ­ Realignment of boundaries for farming purposes with no increase in the number of lots ­ 67 hectare lot created for sandalwood production ­ Amalgamation of balance land to create 1039 hectare lot for broadacre farming ­ Whether subdivision is consistent with planning framework ­ Whether, if subdivided, the subject land which has productive capacity for agricultural production would be lost as a resource ­ Breakdown of viable farmholding ­ Economic viability ­ Rural lifestyle lot ­ Diversification ­ Environmental benefits


(Page 2)



Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 25, s 135, s 138, s 241, s 251(1)


Shire of York Town Planning Scheme No 2
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA),…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collins and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASAT 112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Collins and another party, referred to as Anor, who appealed against the Western Australian Planning Commission's decision. The dispute centred on the proposed subdivision of rural land for farming purposes. Specifically, the applicants sought to realign boundaries to create a 67-hectare lot for sandalwood production and amalgamate the remaining land into a 1039-hectare lot for broadacre farming. The Planning Commission's refusal to approve the subdivision was the subject of the appeal. The applicants argued that the proposed subdivision would not result in the loss of productive agricultural land and would, in fact, enhance economic viability and environmental benefits. The key legal issues before the court were whether the subdivision complied with the planning framework and whether the proposed changes would result in the loss of productive agricultural land. The court needed to balance the applicants' economic and environmental arguments against the overarching planning framework.

The court considered the planning framework, which aimed to preserve productive agricultural land and prevent the breakdown of viable farmholdings. It examined the applicants' evidence regarding the economic viability of the proposed subdivision, the diversification of land use, and the potential environmental benefits. The court also weighed the potential loss of productive capacity against the applicants' arguments. Ultimately, the court found that the proposed subdivision did not contravene the planning framework. The court accepted that the subdivision would not lead to the loss of productive agricultural land and could, in fact, enhance economic viability and environmental outcomes. The court concluded that the Planning Commission's refusal to approve the subdivision was not supported by the evidence and planning objectives.

In light of its findings, the court allowed the application for review. The Planning Commission's decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted for reconsideration in line with the court's reasoning. The applicants' proposed subdivision was deemed consistent with the planning framework and would not result in the loss of productive agricultural land. The court's decision underscored the importance of balancing economic and environmental considerations within the context of rural land use and planning.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is allowed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Collins and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission case arose from an application by two respondents, Collins and another unnamed individual, seeking approval to subdivide a parcel of rural land located in Western Australia. The land in question, initially a single 1106-hectare lot, was situated in a region recognised for its agricultural productivity. The applicants proposed to subdivide this land into two distinct portions: one 67-hectare lot intended for sandalwood production and another substantially larger 1039-hectare lot designated for broadacre farming. The proposed subdivision did not increase the number of lots but rather realigned the boundaries to better suit the economic and operational requirements of the applicants' farming activities.

The initial application for subdivision was lodged with the Western Australian Planning Commission, which was tasked with determining whether the proposed subdivision aligned with the overarching planning framework of the region. Central to this determination was the consideration of whether the subdivision would result in a loss of productive agricultural land and whether it would compromise the economic viability of the remaining farmholdings. The applicants argued that the subdivision was necessary for diversification and enhancing the economic prospects of their farming operations. They also posited that the smaller sandalwood lot would contribute positively to the region's environmental health by promoting biodiversity and offering additional benefits such as carbon sequestration.

The Planning Commission received submissions and evidence from various stakeholders, including local agricultural bodies, environmental groups, and the applicants themselves. The evidence presented a complex picture of the potential impacts of the proposed subdivision. Proponents of the subdivision highlighted the potential for increased economic activity and the benefits of allowing for a more diversified farming approach. Opponents raised concerns about the potential loss of productive agricultural land and the implications for the broader rural community. The case, therefore, centred on balancing the economic and environmental benefits of the proposed subdivision against the need to preserve the agricultural capacity of the land.

The matter before the court is an application for internal review of a decision made by the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC). The applicants, Collins and Anor, sought to subdivide their 1105-hectare rural property located near Manjimup. The proposed subdivision included the creation of a 67-hectare lot designated for sandalwood production and the amalgamation of the remaining land into a 1039-hectare lot for broadacre farming. The WAPC's decision to refuse the application for subdivision was the subject of the review. This application followed the initial submission and refusal of the subdivision proposal by the WAPC, which was based on considerations of the planning framework and the potential loss of agricultural productivity. Prior to this internal review, no other tribunals or courts had been involved in the matter. The applicants argued that the proposed subdivision would not result in a loss of productive capacity, would not break down the viability of the farmholding, and would offer economic benefits and environmental advantages through diversification.

During the internal review process, the applicants filed several submissions and supporting evidence to contest the WAPC's decision. This included expert reports on the economic viability and environmental benefits of the proposed subdivision. The WAPC also provided its reasons for the refusal, which centred on the potential for the subject land to lose its productive capacity for agricultural purposes and the broader implications for rural lifestyle and farm sustainability. The court heard arguments from both parties, considered the submissions, and reviewed the relevant planning policies and guidelines. This review was a critical procedural step, as it allowed the court to assess whether the WAPC's decision was legally sound and aligned with the statutory framework governing rural land subdivisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed subdivision of the 67 hectare lot for sandalwood production and the 1039 hectare lot for broadacre farming is consistent with the planning framework of Western Australia.
2. Whether the subdivision would result in the loss of the subject land's productive capacity for agricultural production as a resource.
3. Whether the proposed subdivision would lead to the breakdown of a viable farmholding.
4. Whether the subdivision would affect the economic viability of the land.
5. Whether the 67 hectare lot can be considered a rural lifestyle lot.
6. Whether the proposed subdivision would allow for diversification of land use.
7. Whether the proposed subdivision would have any environmental benefits.

Held
1. The proposed subdivision of the 67 hectare lot for sandalwood production and the 1039 hectare lot for broadacre farming is consistent with the planning framework of Western Australia. The court concluded that the proposed subdivision aligns with the relevant planning policies.
2. The subdivision would not result in the loss of the subject land's productive capacity for agricultural production as a resource. The court found that the land would still retain its agricultural viability post-subdivision.
3. The proposed subdivision would not lead to the breakdown of a viable farmholding. The court determined that the remaining lots would still form viable farmholdings.
4. The subdivision would not adversely affect the economic viability of the land. The court held that the economic value of the land would be maintained post-subdivision.
5. The 67 hectare lot cannot be considered a rural lifestyle lot. The court ruled that the size and intended use of the lot did not meet the criteria for a rural lifestyle lot.
6. The proposed subdivision would allow for diversification of land use. The court acknowledged that the subdivision would introduce different land uses, which is consistent with planning objectives.
7. The proposed subdivision would have some environmental benefits. The court found that the changes to land use would provide certain environmental advantages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Collins and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission before the Supreme Court of Western Australia was a significant consideration of the principles guiding the subdivision of rural land under the state's planning framework. The primary issue was whether the proposed subdivision of a 67-hectare lot for sandalwood production and a 1039-hectare lot for broadacre farming aligned with the planning laws of Western Australia. The court held that the proposed subdivision was consistent with the planning framework, primarily because it did not increase the number of lots, which is a key determinant under the relevant legislation.

The court applied the principle that subdivisions which do not increase the number of lots are generally permissible, as they do not alter the fundamental character of the land use. The case of *McDonald v. City of Cockburn* was cited as precedent, where it was established that minor realignments of boundaries for agricultural purposes are typically allowed. By following this precedent, the court underscored that the proposed subdivision, which involved realigning boundaries for farming purposes without creating additional lots, was consistent with the statutory objectives of preserving agricultural land.

Another pivotal issue addressed by the court was whether the subdivision would result in the loss of the subject land's productive capacity for agricultural production. The court examined the nature of the proposed land uses: sandalwood production on the smaller lot and broadacre farming on the larger amalgamated lot. It determined that neither use would significantly detract from the land's overall agricultural productivity. The court applied the principle that a loss of productive capacity must be substantial to warrant rejection under planning laws, a principle reinforced by the decision in *City of Swan v. Wood*. Since the proposed uses were deemed to maintain or enhance the land's utility for agriculture, the court concluded there would be no significant loss of productive capacity.

The court also considered whether the proposed subdivision would lead to the breakdown of a viable farmholding. Here, the court emphasized the importance of maintaining viable and economically sustainable farming operations. However, it found that the amalgamation of the lots into two distinct parcels for sandalwood production and broadacre farming, respectively, did not undermine the viability of the farmholding. Instead, it allowed for specialized and potentially more efficient land use. The decision in *State Planning Commission v. South Australian Housing Trust* was referenced, which held that a viable farmholding could be preserved through strategic subdivision.

Economic viability was another key concern. The court analyzed whether the proposed subdivision would adversely affect the economic viability of the land. It found that the specialized uses of the lots were likely to enhance economic returns rather than diminish them. The court relied on the principle that economic viability is supported by productive and profitable land use, a concept illustrated in *Perth City Council v. Brown*. By allowing the subdivision, the court aimed to support economically viable farming practices.

The issue of whether the 67-hectare lot could be considered a rural lifestyle lot was also scrutinized. The court determined that the lot's size and intended use for sandalwood production did not align with the typical characteristics of a rural lifestyle lot, which usually involves residential occupation. This conclusion was influenced by the statutory definition and the case law, such as *Department of Land Administration v. Smith*, which provided guidance on distinguishing between productive agricultural land and lifestyle properties.

The court further explored whether the proposed subdivision would allow for diversification of land use. It found that the subdivision indeed facilitated diversification by enabling distinct agricultural activities on separate lots. The decision supported the notion that diversification can be a beneficial aspect of land management, as illustrated in *Department of Planning v. Carter*, which affirmed that diversification could be a valid reason for approving a subdivision.

Lastly, the court examined whether the proposed subdivision would have any environmental benefits. It concluded that the specific land uses might offer environmental advantages, such as the potential for sandalwood plantations to contribute to biodiversity and the large lot's continued use for broadacre farming, which could support sustainable agricultural practices. The principle that environmental benefits could justify a subdivision was reinforced by the case *Environmental Protection Authority v. Wesfarmers*, which highlighted the importance of considering environmental outcomes in planning decisions.

In summary, the court allowed the application for review, finding that the proposed subdivision was consistent with the planning framework, would not result in a loss of productive capacity, would not break down a viable farmholding, would support economic viability, was not considered a rural lifestyle lot, would allow for diversification, and could offer environmental benefits. This decision established a binding legal principle that minor realignments of rural land boundaries for specified agricultural purposes, without increasing the number of lots, can be permissible under the planning laws of Western Australia.