COLLIE v POLICE
[2002] SASC 109Magistrates Appeal: Criminal
DOYLE CJ: This is an appeal against convictions recorded by the Magistrates Court, and against the sentence imposed by that court. Mr Collie appeared before the court charged with three offences. Count 1 was a charge of being on premises without lawful excuse; count 2 was a charge of hindering a police constable in the execution of his duty; count 3 was a charge of driving a motor vehicle while not the holder of an appropriate licence. All offences were alleged to have occurred on 30 August 2001.
The complaint alleging the offences was lodged with the Magistrates Court on 20 September 2001. Mr Collie was arrested on 25 October 2001 and came before the court in custody on 26 October 2001. On that day he pleaded guilty to all counts. He was remanded in custody and a pre-sentence report was ordered.
I gather that Mr Collie had been arrested on a warrant issued by the Parole Board. He had been released from prison on parole on 3 August 2001, about four weeks before these offences were committed. The warrant was not tendered before me. I understand that it was issued on the basis of alleged breaches of conditions of parole and would have brought Mr Collie before the Board to enable it to consider whether to revoke his parole. My understanding is that the alleged offences of 30 August were not the basis for the issue of the warrant. However the main point is that he was in custody on 26 October 2001.
On 9 October 2001 Mr Collie came before the court again, still in custody. On counts 1 and 2 the Magistrate recorded a conviction and imposed a single penalty of imprisonment for six months. The imposition of that sentence had the effect of terminating Mr Collie’s parole: s 75 of the Correctional Services Act 1982.
The Magistrate directed that the sentence of 6 months imprisonment be cumulative on the balance of the unexpired period of parole which was two years two months five days, thus the total head sentence was two years eight months five days. The Magistrate fixed a non-parole period of one year eight months. On count 3 the Magistrate convicted without further penalty.
Mr Collie appeals against the convictions on the ground that he was unrepresented, was not properly advised about his plea, might have had a defence to count 1 and could not be guilty of count 2 as a matter of law. In relation to count 1 it is also submitted that there was a risk of a miscarriage of justice having regard to the fact that he pleaded guilty when he was unrepresented, not knowing that the prosecution did not have a statement from a particular witness supporting its case. He appeals against sentence on the basis it was excessive.
The prosecution alleged that Mr Colley drove a motor car into a particular street and when the police arrived (I do…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Collie v Police No. Scciv-02-27 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SASC 109
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in the appeal were whether Mr Collie was properly advised about his plea, if he could have had a defence to count 1, and if he could be guilty of count 2 as a matter of law. Additionally, the appeal argued that the sentence was excessive. The Court considered whether there was a risk of a miscarriage of justice due to the lack of representation and the absence of a statement from a particular witness when Mr Collie pleaded guilty. The Court also examined whether the sentence imposed was appropriate for the nature of the offences.
The Court found that there was no basis for a finding that Mr Collie did not appreciate the nature of the charges or did not intend to admit guilt. While the submission that there was a risk of a miscarriage of justice due to the lack of a statement from Ms Barker was accepted, it did not provide a basis for allowing the appeal against conviction in relation to count 1. The appeal against conviction in relation to count 2 was not pursued as there was no argument that Mr Collie’s conduct could not amount to hindering the police officer in the execution of his duty. The Court found the sentence of six months’ imprisonment to be excessive and allowed the appeal against sentence.
Accordingly, the orders were that the appeal against conviction be dismissed, the appeal against sentence be allowed, the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court on count 1 and count 2 be set aside but the sentence imposed on count 3 stand, and Mr Collie be sentenced on count 1 and count 2 to imprisonment for two months. The sentence was suspended upon Mr Collie entering into a bond for a period of twelve months in the sum of $500, with conditions of good behaviour, supervision by a community corrections officer, and reporting to the Department for Correctional Services.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 25 October 2001, Mr Collie was arrested on a warrant issued by the Parole Board, based on alleged breaches of parole conditions. He was in custody when he appeared before the court on 26 October 2001, where he pleaded guilty to three charges: being on premises without lawful excuse, hindering a police constable in the execution of his duty, and driving a motor vehicle while not holding an appropriate licence. He was remanded in custody, and a pre-sentence report was ordered. On 9 October 2001, Mr Collie appeared again in court, still in custody. The Magistrate recorded convictions on counts 1 and 2 and imposed a penalty of imprisonment for six months, which terminated his parole under section 75 of the Correctional Services Act 1982. The total head sentence was two years eight months five days, with a non-parole period of one year eight months. On count 3, Mr Collie was convicted without further penalty.
Mr Collie appealed against his convictions and the sentence on several grounds. He claimed that he was unrepresented and not properly advised about his plea, and suggested that he might have had a defence to count 1. He also argued that he could not be guilty of count 2 as a matter of law. Additionally, he contended that the sentence was excessive, given the relatively minor nature of the offences. The prosecution alleged that Mr Collie's actions warranted the penalties imposed, considering his criminal history and the recent release from parole. The court considered the appeal and re-sentenced Mr Collie, taking into account his circumstances and prospects for rehabilitation.
This case, Collie v Police, is an appeal against convictions and sentences imposed by the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The appellant, Mr Collie, was charged with being on premises without lawful excuse, hindering a police officer in the execution of their duty, and driving a motor vehicle without holding an appropriate licence. Mr Collie pleaded guilty to all counts on 26 October 2001, and was subsequently convicted and sentenced to a total of six months imprisonment for the first two counts, with the sentence to run cumulatively on the balance of his parole term, terminating his parole under the Correctional Services Act 1982. No further penalty was imposed for the third count. The appeal against the convictions and sentences was lodged on the grounds that Mr Collie was unrepresented and not properly advised about his plea, potentially leading to a miscarriage of justice, and that the sentence was excessive. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, with the primary focus being on whether the appeal against conviction and sentence should be allowed, and if so, what appropriate sentence should be imposed. The Court found that while the appeal against conviction should be dismissed, the appeal against sentence should be allowed, and a new sentence of two months imprisonment, suspended upon Mr Collie entering into a bond for twelve months, was imposed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the appellant adequately advised about his plea, and did he appreciate the nature and consequences of pleading guilty without legal representation?
2. Did the appellant have a possible defence to the charge of being on premises without lawful excuse (count 1)?
3. Could the appellant be guilty of hindering a police constable in the execution of his duty (count 2) as a matter of law?
4. Was the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court excessive, warranting reconsideration by the higher court?
Held
1. The court held that the appellant was adequately advised about his plea and appreciated the nature and consequences of pleading guilty without legal representation. As a result, the appeal against conviction was dismissed.
2. The court found that the appellant did not have a possible defence to the charge of being on premises without lawful excuse (count 1), as the circumstances did not provide a basis for allowing the appeal against conviction in this regard.
3. Regarding count 2, the court concluded that the appellant could be guilty of hindering a police constable in the execution of his duty as a matter of law. Consequently, the appeal against conviction for this count was dismissed.
4. The court held that the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court was excessive and warranted reconsideration by the higher court. The appeal against sentence was allowed, and a new sentence of imprisonment for two months was imposed, suspended upon the appellant entering into a bond for twelve months with certain conditions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Supreme Court of South Australia in Collie v Police [2002] SASC 109 examined the appeal of Mr. Collie against his convictions and the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court. The court first considered whether Mr. Collie was adequately advised about his plea and whether he appreciated the nature and consequences of pleading guilty without legal representation. The court found that there was no basis for concluding that Mr. Collie did not appreciate the nature of the charges against him or did not intend to admit guilt. The court noted that there was no suggestion by Mr. Collie that he was not informed of his right to be represented or of the possibility of a custodial sentence. The duty solicitor did not recall advising Mr. Collie about a plea of guilty, but the court held that the absence of such advice did not warrant setting aside the conviction.
The court next assessed whether Mr. Collie had a possible defence to the charge of being on premises without lawful excuse (count 1). The submission that Mr. Collie had a possible defence was tenuous, particularly given the absence of any relevant claim in his affidavit. Even if a defence had been made, the court would have regarded it sceptically considering the circumstances under which Mr. Collie entered the property. The court concluded that the risk of a miscarriage of justice due to the prosecutor's lack of a particular witness statement at the time of the plea was insufficient to allow the appeal against the conviction for count 1.
Regarding count 2, the court examined whether Mr. Collie could be guilty of hindering a police constable in the execution of his duty as a matter of law. The appeal against this conviction was not pursued, and the court found that Mr. Collie’s conduct in running away from the police officer could legally amount to hindering the officer. Consequently, the appeal against conviction for count 2 was dismissed.
Lastly, the court considered whether the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court was excessive. The court determined that a sentence of six months' imprisonment was excessive for the relatively minor nature of the offences. Despite Mr. Collie's poor criminal record and recent release on parole, the court concluded that the offences did not warrant such a severe punishment. The appeal against the sentence was allowed, and the court re-sentenced Mr. Collie to a two-month imprisonment, suspended upon certain conditions.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Supreme Court will allow an appeal against a guilty plea conviction if there has been a miscarriage of justice, but this requires clear evidence of misunderstanding or lack of intent to plead guilty, or a legal impossibility of conviction. The court also emphasized the need for a proportionate sentence that aligns with the seriousness of the offences, taking into account the defendant’s criminal history and circumstances.