Collie v Motor Accident Commission No. DCCIV-96-540 Judgment No. D77

Link copied
Case Copied 90 min read

COLLIE  v  MOTOR ACCIDENT COMMISSION
[1999] SADC 77

Judge Muecke
Civil

  1. In this action the plaintiff claims damages for injuries he suffered in an accident when his motorcycle crashed at about 6pm on Saturday 15 May 1993 near a railway crossing at the entrance to Kadina in the mid-north of South Australia.  I have referred to the motorcycle involved as the plaintiff’s motorcycle although at the time of the accident the motorcycle was not registered in the plaintiff’s name.  The plaintiff said that he had purchased the motorcycle from the registered owner but the registration had not been transferred to him at the time of the accident.  However, the plaintiff regarded the motorcycle as his, it was referred to as the plaintiff’s motorcycle throughout the trial, and I shall refer to it in that way in these reasons.

  2. As one approaches Kadina on the main sealed bitumen highway from Adelaide, one comes to a right-hand sweeping bend, after which there is a short straight portion of road, and then one comes to a sweeping left-hand bend before entering Kadina on a more or less straight section of road.  At the time of the accident, in the short straight portion of road in the middle of the S-bend, a railway line crossed the highway.  An aerial photograph of the accident site as it was at the time of the plaintiff’s accident shows what I have just described, which is a not uncommon feature of railway crossings in country areas in South Australia.  The design is similar to a chicane in a race-track, the purpose being to slow vehicles using the roadway in that area.  There was an  80 kilometres per hour speed restriction sign erected before the right-hand sweeping bend approaching Kadina, and there was a 60 kilometres per hour speed restriction sign just after the railway line.  That sign also announced that the road user was about to enter the township of Kadina.

  3. By summons dated 3 May 1996 the plaintiff sued John William Atherton (“Mr Atherton”) as defendant and alleged that Mr Atherton was the driver of a Harley Davidson motorcycle whilst he, the plaintiff, was a pillion passenger on that motorcycle.  In the Statement of Claim the plaintiff alleged that the “motorcycle was travelling north along the main road into Kadina...when at approximately two kilometres from Kadina whilst approaching a railway crossing the defendant lost control of the motorcycle, causing the plaintiff to be thrown from the motorcycle”.  No greater detail of the accident was given in the Statement of Claim.

  4. At some time prior to trial the Motor Accident Commission was joined as a defendant to the action pursuant to s125a of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1959. I was told that (pursuant to sub-section (3)(b) of s125a) the insured person Mr Atherton ceased to be a party to the action.

  5. The case the plaintiff presented at trial was that on Saturday 15 May 1993 (which was the Saturday of the Adelaide Cup long weekend in 1993) he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collie v Motor Accident Commission No. DCCIV-96-540 Judgment... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SADC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff sued Mr Atherton for damages for injuries he suffered in a motorcycle accident when his motorcycle crashed at about 6pm on Saturday 15 May 1993 near a railway crossing at the entrance to Kadina in the mid-north of South Australia. The plaintiff alleged that Mr Atherton lost control of the motorcycle causing the plaintiff to be thrown from the motorcycle. The plaintiff further alleged that the accident was caused by Mr Atherton’s negligent management of the plaintiff’s motorcycle. The defendant’s case was that the plaintiff rode his own motorcycle from Paskeville to the area of the railway crossing where he lost control of his motorcycle and crashed into a barrier positioned to the left of the roadway, and that the plaintiff’s injuries were caused solely by his own negligence. The only issue that the court had to determine to decide liability was one of fact. That is, whether it was the plaintiff or Mr Atherton who was riding the plaintiff’s motorcycle at the time of the accident. The court found that Mr Atherton was not riding the plaintiff’s motorcycle when it crashed on 15 May 1993. The court found the plaintiff was. The plaintiff had chosen not to exercise any earning capacity he had before trial, and he would have so chosen even had the accident in May 1993 not occurred. The plaintiff would not have exercised any earning capacity he had pre-trial even if the accident of May 1993 had not occurred. The plaintiff has suffered no economic loss pre-trial as a result of the injuries he received in the motorcycle accident of 15 May 1993. The court awarded the plaintiff $27,800 for non-economic detriments, $2,500 for the possibility of future surgery on the plaintiff’s shoulder, and a lump sum of $500 for future medication and for possible future attendances on general practitioners and physiotherapists for treatment of his left shoulder.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established