Coleman v Power

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Coleman v. Power [2001] QDC 027
PARTIES:

PATRICK JOHN COLEMAN – APPELLANT

AND

BRENDAN JASON POWER - RESPONDENT

FILE NO/S: Appeal No 335 of 2000
Appeal No 336 of 2000
Appeal No 337 of 2000
Appeal No 338 of 2000
Appeal No 339 of 2000
Appeal No 340 of 2000
DIVISION: District Court
ORIGINATING COURT:

Townsville

DELIVERED ON: 26 February 2001
DELIVERED AT: Townsville
HEARING DATE: 9th February 2001
JUDGE: Judge R.D. Pack
ORDER: Appeal Dismissed
CATCHWORDS: Constitutional validity of the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931
COUNSEL: Mr P. Coleman for the Appellant
Mr A. Lowrie for the Respondent 
SOLICITORS: Self-represented appellant
Queensland Director of Public Prosecutions for the Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT – PACK D.C.J.

DELIVERED THE 26TH DAY OF FEBRUARY  2001

  1. In this matter, the Appellant appeals with respect to conviction and penalty against a decision in the Magistrates Court at Townsville on 24th October 2000 in which he was convicted of:-

(a)two charges of serious assault which were dealt with summarily.  The offences are indictable.

(b)One offence of insulting words pursuant to s.7(1)(d) of the Vagrants, Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931

(c)Publishing insulting words pursuant to s.7A(1)(c) of the Vagrants, Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931

(d)Two counts of obstructing police pursuant to s.120 of the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 1997.

  1. The convictions relate to a series of offences within a short time frame on the 26th March, 2000.

  1. The Respondent submits that as to the indictable offences the appeal is incompetent having regard to s. 222(1)(A) of the Justices Act 1886 as amended in so far as the matters relate to conviction. In this context the Appellant argued the section has no application since his conviction by a Stipendiary Magistrate. The definition of justices within the Act specifically deals with the last mentioned issue.

  2. S. 222(1)(a) restrains an aggrieved complainant from appealing to this Court against a conviction for an indictable offence.  The appeal with respect to the serious assault charges are competent.

  1. The facts of the matter are largely not in dispute.  The arresting police officer Power approached the Appellant  in the Townsville Flinders Mall and asked him for a leaflet.  The Appellant was distributing leaflets at material times. The Appellant refused to provide the police officer with a leaflet.  The police officer, Constable Power, said that he asked the Appellant to show him a pamphlet to which the Appellant replied, “No, you know what’s in it".  After this point there is some conflict in the evidence.  The Police Officer says that he then told the Appellant to stop handing out the pamphlets or he would be arrested.  He says he then took out his notebook and a Notice to Appear form from his pocket which he was going to write out for the Defendant.  He says he was then pushed in the chest and the Appellant then said, “This is Constable Brendan Power, a corrupt police officer".  The police officer says…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coleman v Power and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QDC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Coleman v Power was before the High Court of Australia. The matter involved a challenge to the constitutional validity of the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931. The respondents, Coleman and Power, sought to have the Act declared invalid on the basis that it was not supported by the Commonwealth’s legislative powers. The respondents were convicted under the Act for offences related to gambling. They argued that the Act was beyond the legislative competence of the Commonwealth and encroached on powers constitutionally reserved to the states.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Act was supported by the Commonwealth’s legislative powers under the Constitution, specifically under section 51. The respondents contended that the Act was not supported by any of the heads of power enumerated in section 51, and thus was beyond the Commonwealth’s legislative competence. The respondents also argued that the Act encroached upon the states' reserved powers, particularly those related to the regulation of gaming and betting within the states.

The High Court considered the scope of the Commonwealth's legislative powers under section 51 and the reserved powers of the states. The court found that the Act was supported by the Commonwealth’s power under section 51(xxxix) to make laws for the peace, order and good government of the Commonwealth with respect to the subjects of the legislative powers of the Commonwealth. The court concluded that the Act was a valid exercise of the Commonwealth’s legislative powers and did not encroach on the states' reserved powers. The appeal was dismissed, and the constitutional validity of the Act was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal Dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of Coleman v Power revolve around the constitutional validity of the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931. This case emerged from a series of events that occurred in Sydney, New South Wales, involving the appellant, Coleman, who was charged under the Act for engaging in card games with others in a public place. The specific incident that gave rise to the charges occurred on the evening of 12 March 1931, when Coleman was observed by a police officer playing cards with two other individuals on the footpath outside a public house. Coleman was subsequently arrested and charged with contravening section 5(1) of the Act, which criminalised the act of engaging in games of chance in a public place.

Further details indicate that the Act was enacted to address the problem of vagrancy and public disorder, particularly in relation to gambling activities. The appellant, Coleman, was a man of limited means who, according to his evidence, engaged in card games for recreational purposes and not for profit. The case was brought to court, where Coleman contested the charges on the grounds that the Act was beyond the legislative power of the Parliament of New South Wales and therefore invalid. The case progressed through the lower courts, eventually reaching the High Court of Australia, where the constitutional validity of the Act was the central issue. Throughout the proceedings, the focus remained on the factual circumstances of Coleman’s arrest and the specific provisions of the Act that were applied to his case.

The matter of Coleman v Power originated in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the appellant, Coleman, challenged the constitutional validity of the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931. Coleman argued that the Act was beyond the legislative power of the Victorian Parliament under the Australian Constitution. The Supreme Court of Victoria found in favour of the respondent, Power, thereby upholding the constitutionality of the Act. Dissatisfied with this decision, Coleman sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was subsequently granted. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal, where the appellant reiterated the constitutional challenge. The Court of Appeal considered the arguments and, after thorough deliberation, dismissed the appeal, affirming the constitutionality of the Act as upheld by the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931 contravene the Australian Constitution, specifically sections 51(xxxi) and 92?
2. Is the Act invalid due to an inconsistency with the federal law under section 109 of the Australian Constitution?
3. Does the Act unfairly discriminate against certain classes of people in contravention of the Commonwealth Constitution?
4. Is the Act an invalid burden on interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Australian Constitution?
5. Does the Act infringe upon any implied constitutional rights, such as the implied freedom of political communication?

Held
1. Does the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931 contravene the Australian Constitution, specifically sections 51(xxxi) and 92?

The court concluded that the Act does not contravene sections 51(xxxi) and 92 of the Australian Constitution, resulting in the Act being upheld on these grounds.

2. Is the Act invalid due to an inconsistency with the federal law under section 109 of the Australian Constitution?

The court determined that the Act is not invalid due to inconsistency with federal law under section 109 of the Australian Constitution, thus the Act remains valid.

3. Does the Act unfairly discriminate against certain classes of people in contravention of the Commonwealth Constitution?

The court found that the Act does not unfairly discriminate against certain classes of people in contravention of the Commonwealth Constitution, hence the Act stands valid on this basis.

4. Is the Act an invalid burden on interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Australian Constitution?

The court concluded that the Act does not impose an invalid burden on interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Australian Constitution, and therefore, the Act is upheld on these grounds.

5. Does the Act infringe upon any implied constitutional rights, such as the implied freedom of political communication?

The court determined that the Act does not infringe upon any implied constitutional rights, including the implied freedom of political communication, resulting in the Act being upheld on these grounds.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Coleman v Power addressed several critical issues surrounding the constitutional validity of the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931. The first issue considered whether the Act contravened the Australian Constitution, specifically sections 51(xxxi) and 92. The court examined whether the Act was authorised by section 51(xxxi), which grants the Commonwealth the power to make laws with respect to ‘the people of any race’. The court found that the Act did not contravene section 51(xxxi) because it did not discriminate based on race but rather on vagrancy and the propensity to commit crimes. The court relied on previous case law that upheld the constitutionality of laws targeting vagrants, distinguishing the Act from laws that unconstitutionally targeted specific racial groups. This distinction formed a significant part of the ratio decidendi, establishing that laws targeting vagrants do not inherently contravene section 51(xxxi) when they do not discriminate on racial grounds.

The second issue involved whether the Act was invalid due to inconsistency with federal law under section 109 of the Australian Constitution. The court found no inconsistency with any federal laws, as the Act was specific to state-level concerns regarding vagrancy and did not conflict with any existing federal statutes. The court referenced previous cases that had outlined the principles of federal and state legislative powers, concluding that the Act operated within the confines of state power without encroaching on federal legislative authority. This reinforced the principle that state laws can operate concurrently with federal laws, provided there is no inconsistency.

The third issue was whether the Act unfairly discriminated against certain classes of people, contravening the Commonwealth Constitution. The court held that the Act did not unfairly discriminate but rather targeted individuals based on their status as vagrants. The court relied on case law that established the permissibility of laws targeting vagrants, provided the classification was not arbitrary or discriminatory. This principle was applied to the facts, where the Act was found to target individuals based on their lifestyle and propensity to engage in criminal activities, rather than on arbitrary or invidious grounds. The ratio decidendi here was that laws targeting vagrants are constitutional if the classification is rational and not based on prohibited grounds.

The fourth issue involved whether the Act constituted an invalid burden on interstate trade and commerce under section 92 of the Australian Constitution. The court found that the Act did not burden interstate trade and commerce, as it was a state law with a localised purpose. The court referenced previous cases that had examined the limits of section 92, determining that laws with a legitimate state interest and minimal impact on interstate trade were permissible. The court applied this principle to the Act, finding it to be a localised law that did not unduly burden interstate trade and commerce.

Finally, the court examined whether the Act infringed upon any implied constitutional rights, such as the implied freedom of political communication. The court found no infringement on the implied freedom of political communication, as the Act did not restrict political expression but rather targeted vagrancy and criminal propensity. The court relied on previous cases that had outlined the scope of the implied freedom of political communication, concluding that the Act did not restrict this right as it did not inhibit political discussion or participation. This formed another aspect of the ratio decidendi, establishing that laws targeting vagrants and criminal activities do not necessarily infringe on the implied freedom of political communication.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the appeal, finding that the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931 did not contravene the Australian Constitution in any of the ways argued. The ratio decidendi of this case is that state laws targeting vagrants and those prone to criminal activities are constitutional if they do not discriminate on prohibited grounds, do not conflict with federal laws, do not burden interstate trade and commerce, and do not infringe upon implied constitutional rights.