Colebatch and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

Colebatch and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (Compensation) [2020] AATA 34 (16 January 2020)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL               )

)  No: 2017/0038

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION  )

Re: Samuel Colebatch

Applicant

And: Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:  Dr I Alexander, Senior Member

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM:            18 February 2020

PLACE:  Sydney

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), to alter the text of the decision in this application such that:

1.    the wording of the decision is changed to:

During Mr Colebatch’s defence service from 7 December 2012 to 5 March 2013 he suffered a mental health condition diagnosed as an Adjustment Disorder.

2.    the wording in paragraph [223](i) of the reasons for decision is changed to:

During Mr Colebatch’s defence service from 7 December 2012 to 5 March 2013 he suffered a mental health condition diagnosed as an Adjustment Disorder.

.................... [sgd]......................

Dr I Alexander, Senior Member

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/0038

Re:Samuel Colebatch

APPLICANT

AndMilitary Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr I Alexander, Senior Member

Date:16 January 2020

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision of 18 November 2016 should be set aside and, in substitution, the decision is as follows:

i) During Mr Colebatch’s defence service from 7 December 2012 to 3 March 2013 he suffered a mental health condition diagnosed as an Adjustment Disorder.

ii) The Adjustment Disorder was an injury that out arose out of his defence service, in respect of which the Respondent is liable to pay compensation pursuant to section 23(1) of the MRC Act.

iii) During Mr Colebatch’s defence service, he suffered a mental health condition that was diagnosed as schizophrenia.

iv) The schizophrenia was not contributed to, to a material degree, by Mr Colebatch’s defence service and, therefore, in respect of this condition, the Respondent is not liable to pay compensation pursuant to section 23(1) of the MRC Act.

v) The Respondent is to pay Mr Colebatch’s reasonable costs of these proceedings, as agreed or taxed, with a rider that such costs do not include the costs incurred by reason of the vacation of the hearing on 27 June 2019.

..........................[sgd]..........................................

Dr I Alexander, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Military rehabilitation and compensation – Liability for schizophrenia and adjustment disorder – whether conditions arose out of defence service – whether material contribution – consideration of Statements of Principles – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) ss 5, 23, 27, 319, 323-324, 333, 335, 337, 339, 341

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Statement of Principles concerning SCHIZOPHRENIA (Balance of Probabilities), No. 84 of 2016

Statement of Principles concerning anxiety disorder, No. 103 of 2014

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr I Alexander, Senior Member

16 January 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Colebatch, who is now 37 years old, enlisted in the Australian Army on 23 August 2011 and was medically discharged on 7 September 2016.

  2. Mr Colebatch presented with left…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colebatch and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Colebatch against a decision of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission regarding his claims for compensation for schizophrenia and adjustment disorder. The dispute centred on whether these conditions arose out of his defence service, and specifically, whether his schizophrenia was materially contributed to or aggravated by his defence service after its onset. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine the date of clinical onset of Mr Colebatch's schizophrenia, whether he suffered a significant mental health disorder at the time of clinical worsening of the schizophrenia, whether his defence service materially contributed to or aggravated his schizophrenia, and whether he was unable to obtain appropriate clinical management for his schizophrenia.

The Tribunal found that Mr Colebatch suffered an Adjustment Disorder, which arose out of his defence service, with an agreed date of onset of 7 December 2012. It was also agreed that his symptoms for this disorder had subsided by 5 March 2013, and the Respondent was liable to pay compensation for this condition. However, the primary dispute concerned Mr Colebatch's schizophrenia. While there was no dispute that the active phase of his schizophrenia commenced in early February 2015, the parties disagreed on the onset of its prodromal phase. The Tribunal considered evidence suggesting psychological symptoms and behavioural changes in the second half of 2014, which were attributed by experts to the prodromal phase of schizophrenia.

Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Colebatch's defence service materially contributed to his schizophrenia. Consequently, the Respondent was not liable to pay compensation in respect of this condition. The Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and substituted its own, finding that Mr Colebatch suffered an Adjustment Disorder arising out of his defence service for which compensation was payable, but that his schizophrenia was not materially contributed to by his defence service. The Respondent was ordered to pay Mr Colebatch's reasonable costs of the proceedings, excluding costs related to a vacated hearing date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Therefore, the definitive issues in this matter are:(i)What is the date of clinical onset of Mr Colebatch’s condition of schizophrenia?(ii)Did Mr Colebatch suffer a significantly mental health disorder, that is, an unspecified anxiety disorder at the time of the clinical worsening of the schizophrenia? If so;(iii)Was Mr Colebatch’s schizophrenia contributed to in a material degree by, or was aggravated by, any defence service rendered by him after he contracted the condition?(iv)Was Mr Colebatch unable to obtain appropriate clinical management for his schizophrenia?Mr Colebatch’s evidence A significantly redacted version of Mr Colebatch written statement, dated 25 April 2017, was provided to the Tribunal at the hearing; Relevant extracts from the document are as follows:Over the first 6-7 months of my service during my training to be a SIG at Simpson Barracks in Victoria I became depressed and anxious as a result of distressing bullying and harassment which occurred. This occurred from 2011 to well into 2012 and into 2013… I became and was emotionally distressed at that time. My sleep and concentration was affected. I was edgy, anxious and unhappy.I had a psych assessment which was the end for me in that course on Friday 27/04/2012… Following that assessment in April 2012 I believe it was determined that I was found not to be suitable to continue the language training…I think I started the Information Systems Technician (Geek) course around July 2012. From around the middle of 2012 I underwent further training. I continued to have difficulty with the training as a result of how I had been and was being treated. In the second half of 2012 I was referred to an Education Officer to assist me and I advised them of the bullying and harassment… I don’t know what action was taken in relation to my complaint.Around December 2012 I was referred for a psychiatric or psychological examination. I believe that this was a result of me failing parts of my assessments… I was feeling very stressed and anxious at this time… I was unable to sleep very well… I had some gastro around this time and I think this was caused by how I was feeling as a result of the bullying and harassment… during the assessment I mentioned the bullying and harassment… I do not know what action was taken… I believe that it was recommended that I should receive and would benefit from specialist assessment and advice in relation to my personal and professional issues. I do not recall that the specialist assessment or assistance was provided. During that time as above both verbal and physical harassment, some of it was mental harassment just evil stares in class… I myself and others complained about the incidences to staff which then caused an investigation… around November 2012… I understand SIG Boag and Champion got a verbal / written heavy warning… I was, due to peer pressure, forced to sign an apology document with SIG B… It was false because soon after he started acting up again…Around February 2013 I was removed from IET course and moved to DFSS Transport Yard… During this time, they could tell I enjoyed the work better, and put me on the next available RACT Driving Course… I enjoyed the Transport however I was angry and annoyed of my removal from the IET course.When I first enlisted I was a bit out of my depth and wasn’t making the grades… I felt like I was being treated differently, not part of the team… I was treated differently, bullied and harassed… the more I was bullied and harassed the more it impacted on my ability to pass the courses. As a result of the bullying I felt pretty angry and depressed. Around March 2013 I was referred for another psychological assessment… In Transport I seemed to fit and it felt alright… Around August 2013 I suffered an injury to my left knee whilst on a field exercise… my knee injury caused me stress as I could not participate in all activities to the best of my ability. In November 2013 I moved to Darwin… I went on a couple of courses and started a driver’s course… I recall going on a G-Wagon course which I believe was in November 2013 for 4-6 weeks… I recall a field exercise in early 2014 for 1-2 weeks… I went on a Hallmark Trailer course. I believe that this was in November/December 2014 after the G-Wagon course. 2013 or 2014… In July 2014 I undertook a LR2 course. The LR course was with manual vehicles … during the LR2 course I felt all the past events catch up with me. I was having issues and became extremely anxious as I felt my performance was being scrutinised and even during testing… I felt extremely anxious in testing and training situations and would have flashbacks of how I had been treated in the past… I was irritable, sensitive and had difficulty sleeping and relaxing. In August 2014 I was referred to a psychologist for assessment in relation to my stress and anxiety… I think I saw VVCS a few times for counselling however I did not receive much in the way of treatment [emphasis added] Around August 2014 I injured my left knee again whilst participating in battle PT and playing AFL[1]. I had an operation on my knee in October 2014… As a result of the knee injury in August 2014 I was unable to run, jump squat, press weights or do any fitness testing… The knee injury and the symptoms added to my stress, anxiety and depression. In February 2015 I was referred for a psychological assessment. This was the first of many doctors’ appointments and hospitalisations due to Schizophrenia. Whilst seeing the doctors the bullying was still happening I was discharged from Defence around August 2016. [1] This was clearly a new acute injury as Mr Colebatch appeared to have been fit enough to attend battle PT and play AFL. This is not consistent with inferences below that he was suffering chronic left knee pain prior to August 2014.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that, on the balance of probabilities, I am satisfied that Mr Colebatch’s defence service did not contribute, to material degree, to his schizophrenia and, therefore, the Respondent is not liable to pay compensation in respect of this condition.DECISION For reasons set out above the Tribunal finds that the reviewable decision of 18 November 2016 should be set aside and, in substitution, the decision is as follows:i)During Mr Colebatch’s defence service from 7 December 2012 to 3 March 2013 he suffered a mental health condition diagnosed as an Adjustment Disorder.ii)The Adjustment Disorder was an injury that out arose out of his defence service, in respect of which the Respondent is liable to pay compensation pursuant to section 23(1) of the MRC Act.iii)During Mr Colebatch’s defence service, he suffered a mental health condition that was diagnosed as schizophrenia. iv)The schizophrenia was not contributed to, to a material degree, by Mr Colebatch’s defence service and, therefore, in respect of this condition, the Respondent is not liable to pay compensation pursuant to section 23(1) of the MRC Act. v)The Respondent is to pay Mr Colebatch’s reasonable costs of these proceedings, as agreed or taxed, with a rider that such costs do not include the costs incurred by reason of the vacation of the hearing on 27 June 2019.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my view, the correspondence from Dr Jayalath does not address the specific issues before the Tribunal and, therefore, is of little value for present purposes.CONSIDERATION It is agreed, that Mr Colebatch suffered an Adjustment Disorder, being an injury that arose out of his defence service, with a date of onset of 7 December 2012. Therefore, the respondent is liable to pay compensation to Mr Colebatch pursuant to section 23(1) of the MRC Act in respect of this disorder. It is also agreed, that Mr Colebatch’s symptoms had subsided and that, by 5 March 2013, he had fully recovered from the Adjustment Disorder. It is agreed that, during his defence service, Mr Colebatch was also diagnosed as suffering from schizophrenia. Schizophrenia is a severe mental health disorder that persists throughout life with variable clinical presentation and treatment response. Signs and symptoms are variable and include “changes in perception, emotion, cognition thinking and behaviour”[25]. [25] B J Sadock, V A Sadock, P Ruiz; Synopsis of Psychiatry; 11th Edition 2015. The psychotic features of schizophrenia “typically emerge between the late teens and the mid-30’s”[26]. The onset may be “abrupt or insidious, but the majority of individuals manifest a slow and gradual development of a variety of clinically significant signs and symptoms”[27]. Half of these individuals “complain of depressive symptoms”[28]. [26] DSM-V p 102. [27] Ibid. [28] Ibid. The characteristic symptoms of schizophrenia involve “a range of cognitive, behavioural and emotional dysfunctions, but no single symptom is pathognomonic of the disorder”[29].[29] Ibid p 100. Prodromal symptoms “often precede the active phase”[30] and negative symptoms “are common in the prodromal phase”[31]. Individuals who had been “socially active may become withdrawn from previous routines” and this is often the first sign of the disorder[32].[30] Ibid p 101. [31] Ibid. [32] Ibid. There appears to be no dispute that the onset of the active phase of Mr Colebatch’s schizophrenia, was in or about early February 2015. What is in dispute, is the time of onset of the prodromal phase of Mr Colebatch‘s schizophrenia. The evidence before the Tribunal clearly indicates that, in the second half of 2014, Mr Colebatch began to suffer psychological symptoms and some changes in his behaviour. Professor Arya suggested that Mr Colebatch “had started getting a bit unwell in the second half of 2014”. I note that Prof. Arya was the first psychiatrist to assess Mr Colebatch after he had been successfully treated for his psychotic episode, and I have no reason to doubt that he was referring to the onset of the prodromal phase of Mr Colebatch’s schizophrenia. Dr Parmegiani attributed Mr Colebatch’s symptoms and behavioural changes to the prodromal phase of Mr Colebatch’s schizophrenia. It is submitted for Mr Colebatch, that the onset of the prodromal phase of his schizophrenia was at some time between the end of October 2014 and onset of the active phase in early February 2015, and that, between July and the end of October 2014, he also suffered a discrete co-morbid “significant disorder of mental health” as specified in SOP Schizophrenia 2016.