Colasante v Pharmacy Board of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Miscellaneous Appeal: Civil)

COLASANTE v PHARMACY BOARD OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray

10 June 2005

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - POWERS OF COURT

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - POWERS OF COURTS UNDER JUDICIAL REVIEW LEGISLATION - GENERALLY

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - MEDICAL AND RELATED PROFESSIONS - PHARMACEUTICAL CHEMISTS

Appeal from decision of Pharmacy Board of South Australia - review of decision of Board not to approve appellants to trade under name, Chemist Warehouse Kilburn.

Discussion of powers of court to review decision pursuant to Pharmacists Act 1991 (SA) and Supreme Court Rules - consideration of comparable interstate legislation.

Held - appeal allowed - court empowered to substitute its decision for that of the Board - fresh decision on appellant's application for approval of trading name made - trading name approved.

Pharmacists Act 1991 (SA) s 32, s 15 and s 49; Pharmacists Regulations 1991 (SA) r 11, r 27; Supreme Court Rules r 97; Pharmacy (General) Regulations 1998 (NSW) r 16; Pharmacists Registration Act 2001 (Tas) s 12; Pharmacists Registration Act 2001 (Qld) s 130, referred to.
Shrimpton v The Commonwealth (1945) 69 CLR 613; Wigg v Architects Board of South Australia (1984) 26 SASR 111; Thompkins v South Australian Health Commission [2001] SASC 147; Westmite Pty Ltd v Law Society of South Australia (1999) 73 SASR 454; Builders Licensing Board v Sperway Constructions (Syd) Pty Ltd (1976) 135 CLR 616; Re Coldham & Ors; Ex parte Brideson (No 2) (1990) 170 CLR 267, considered.

COLASANTE v PHARMACY BOARD OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2005] SASC 207

Appeal from the Pharmacy Board of South Australia

GRAY J

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of the Pharmacy Board of South Australia. 

  2. The Court was asked to review a decision of the Board not to approve the appellants’ proposed trading name, “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn”, in respect of a retail pharmacy located at shop 7, 398-400 Prospect Road Kilburn.  The appellants contended that the Court should hear the matter de novo, and if the appellants’ contention were accepted, the Court should substitute its decision for that of the Board.  The appellants submitted that the Court should set aside the decision of the Board and permit the registration of the proposed trading name.

  3. The appellants, Philip Colasante, Mario Verrocchi and Sam Gance, are in partnership.  Together, they own the retail pharmacy on Prospect Road at Kilburn.  Mr Colasante is a registered pharmacist. 

  4. Mr Colasante made application to the Board in accordance with section 32 of the Pharmacists Act 1991 (SA) for registration of the premises at Prospect Road Kilburn and approval to trade under the name, “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn”. That section provides:

    (1)A person must not carry on a business consisting of or involving pharmacy except at premises registered under this section in relation to that business.

    Penalty:     Division 7 fine.

    (2)The Board may register premises if satisfied that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colasante v Pharmacy Board of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 207
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Colasante v Pharmacy Board of South Australia involved a dispute between Philip Colasante, a pharmacist, and the Pharmacy Board of South Australia regarding the approval of a trading name for a pharmacy located in Kilburn. The Board had denied Colasante’s request to use the trading name “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn Pharmacy” due to concerns about invidious comparisons and the advertising of medicines as a commercial product. The primary legal issues in the case revolved around whether the Board had an absolute discretion in approving trading names for pharmacies, and if it had misapplied certain guidelines and regulations in making its decision.

The court found that the Board did not possess an absolute discretion in approving trading names. Instead, its decision-making process must align with the requirements set out in the Pharmacists Act. The Board’s assertion of having an absolute discretion indicated a misunderstanding of its statutory duties and powers. Furthermore, the court noted that while the Guidelines for Pharmaceutical Practice in South Australia were not legally binding, they should not be applied as if they were strict legislative proscriptions. The court found that the Board had improperly relied on these guidelines in making its decision.

Regulation 27(2) of the Pharmacists Regulations, which pertains to advertising practices, was also considered by the Board. The court determined that this regulation had only an indirect relevance to the approval of trading names, as it primarily concerns the manner of advertising after a trading name has been approved. The court sided with the appellants, concluding that regulation 27(2) did not apply to the decision on the trading name approval.

The court’s decision highlighted that the Board’s reliance on certain guidelines and regulations was inappropriate and misapplied. This led to the conclusion that the Board’s decision to deny the trading name approval was flawed. The case underscored the importance of the Board adhering strictly to the legislative framework when making decisions regarding the approval of trading names for pharmacies.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The regulation of the practice of pharmacy includes the specific requirement that: [a] person must not practice pharmacy under a business or trading name unless that name has been approved by the Board.[1] [1] Regulation 11, Pharmacists Act Regulations 1991 (SA).The Decision of the Pharmacy Board On 6 December 2004, the Board met and considered all of the matters raised in Mr Colasante’s letter of 10 November 2004. The Board decided not to approve the trading name “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn”. Present at the meeting were Mr Gilbert, Mr Dollman, Mr Draysey, Ms Pluck, Ms Rowett, Mr Wilmot, Mr Halstead and Mr Gross. The official minutes of the meeting included the following passage:Letter from Mr Philip ColasanteThe Registrar tabled a letter from Mr Philip Colasante requesting the Board consider and approve the name “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn Pharmacy (Philip Colasante, Sam Gance, Mario Verrocchi) for premises located at 400 Prospect Road, Kilburn.The Board raised their concerns regarding invidious comparison and that medicines should not be advertised as an ordinary term of commerce. The Board believed the term Chemist Warehouse did not support either of these considerationsMotion: That the Board not approve the name Chemist Warehouse Kilburn Pharmacy (Philip Colasante, Sam Gance, Mario Verrocchi) (BW/BD). Motion carried. The Board gave reasons for its decision in a letter sent to the appellants on 6 December 2004. The letter read:Dear PhilipThank you for the letter dated 10 November 2004. The Pharmacy Board of South Australia was, at is regular monthly meeting of 6 December, able to consider the concerns outlined in the letter.Regulation 27(2) of the Pharmacist Act 1991 states that: “A person must not advertise in respect of the practice of pharmacy – (a) in a manner that is likely to bring discredit on the profession of pharmacy;(b)in a manner that draws invidious comparisons between pharmacists or group of pharmacistsor(c) in a manner that is likely to mislead”.The Pharmacy Board of South Australia supplies to each registered pharmacist “Guidelines for Pharmacy Practice in South Australia”. These guidelines make reference to business or trading names. The guidelines note the Board is expressly given power to approve trading or business names under Regulation 11 of the Pharmacists Act 1991.The guidelines make it clear that approval of trading names is at the absolute discretion of the Board and that trading names are not acceptable if they:- imply a comparison with, or superiority to, another pharmacist-imply the practice of any profession other than pharmacy, unless the pharmacist is registered by law to practise that other profession- offend standards of accepted ethical and professional behaviour and- do not comply with any other legal requirements.The Pharmacy Board of South Australia is required to act in the public interest and in any decision the Board makes it considers the implications of the National Medicines Policy that has as a basic tenant that medicines “are not to be treated as a norm item of commerce”.With this information as background the Pharmacy Board of South Australia considered the application to use the trading name “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn” for the pharmacy situated at 400 Prospect Rd Kilburn.The unanimous decision of the Pharmacy Board of South Australia was not to approve the trading name “Chemist Warehouse Kilburn”.The Board strongly believes that the word “warehouse” has the potential to be widely interpreted in the community as a pharmacy where medicines are able to be accessed cheaply and in bulk. The Board believes this is an invidious comparison between this pharmacy and other pharmacies.The Board, having confirmed its decision again in relation to this matter, and aware that significant signage is currently displayed using the word warehouse expects all signage to display the approved trading name of Kilburn Community Pharmacy by close of business 24 December 2004.The Pharmacy board of South Australia wishes to make it clear that it has no concerns as to the likelihood that high quality pharmaceutical services will be provided by well trained and appropriately supervised staff at the Kilburn site.Should you have any further questions or concerns please do not hesitate to contact the Board.Yours sincerelyPeter HalsteadRegistrar

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There is substance to the appellant’s submission. The Board did not have an absolute discretion. Its function was to reach a decision in accordance with the requirements of the Pharmacists Act. The Board’s reference to an absolute discretion suggests that it misunderstood its duties and powers.Irrelevant ConsiderationsGuidelines for Pharmaceutical Practice in South Australia The Board produces the Guidelines for Pharmaceutical Practice in South Australia bi-annually and makes these available to every registered pharmacist. According to Mr Halstead’s affidavit of 25 February 2005, the Guidelines are intended to assist pharmacists in understanding the legislative and policy considerations that are taken into account by the Board in fulfilling its functions under the Pharmacists Act. The appellants submitted that the Board relied inappropriately and too heavily on the Guidelines in reaching its decision. Although the Guidelines have no force in law, the Board’s letter of 6 December 2004 indicates that the Board applied the Guidelines as if they were legislative proscriptions. The appellants further submitted that, even if the Board was entitled to have regard to the Guidelines, it was not entitled to apply them as if they were inviolable standards for pharmacy practice. Counsel for the Board refuted the assertion that the Board had applied the Guidelines as though they were a strict code of pharmacy practice. There is substance to the appellants’ submission. The Guidelines are no more than that. They do not replace the legislation. They do not dictate the result. In any event, in a number of respects they mistake the legislative and policy positions.Regulation 27 The Board considered the application of regulation 27(2) of the Pharmacists Regulations in reaching its decision. Regulation 27(2) provides:(2) A person must not advertise in respect of the practice of pharmacy—(a)in a manner that is likely to bring discredit on the profession of pharmacy;(b)in a manner that draws invidious comparison between pharmacists or groups of pharmacists;or(c)in a manner that is likely to mislead.Penalty: Division 7 fine. The appellants submitted that regulation 27(2) relates to the manner in which a pharmacist conducts his or her advertising. They said that the regulation does not, nor is it intended to, speak to matters relevant to an application for use of a name. Rather, they said, the purpose of regulation 27(2) was to regulate the manner of practice after approval of a trading name. Counsel for the Board submitted that the Board was correct to consider the impact of regulation 27(2) when making its decision, given the close association between a trading name of a business and the advertising of a business. Regulation 27(2) of the Pharmacists Regulations has only an indirect relevance to the approval of a trading name. The appellants were correct to submit that the regulation was related to a different activity – that is, the act of advertising.National Medicines Policy