Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Cohen v Double Bay Bowling Club (No 3) [2021] NSWSC 295 Hearing dates: On the papers Date of orders: 26 March 2021 Decision date: 26 March 2021 Jurisdiction: Equity - Technology and Construction List Before: Stevenson J Decision: Leave to amend Technology and Construction List Statement refused
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – Pleadings – Amendment –Application to amend Technology and Construction List Statement – Whether contentions as to duty and breach of duty were made with sufficient particularity
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)
Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW)
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW)
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Gregory Clive Cohen (First Plaintiff)
Mariela Sverdloff (Second Plaintiff)
Double Bay Bowling Club (First Defendant)
Brianda Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)
CF Group Piling Pty Ltd (Third Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
D Weinberger (Plaintiffs)
J Lazarus SC with M Sheldon (First Defendant)
D Macfarlane (Third Defendant)
Crisp Law (Plaintiffs)
Lazarus Legal Group (First Defendant)
McCabe Curwood (Second Defendant)
Kennedys Law (Third Defendant)
File Number(s): 2019/170616
Judgment
-
The plaintiffs, Mr Gregory Cohen and Ms Mariela Sverdloff, own and occupy a residential property in Double Bay.
-
The first defendant (“the Club”) owns an adjoining property. The plaintiffs allege that the Club engaged the second defendant (“the Builder”) to construct a dual occupancy on the Club’s land and that the Builder engaged the third defendant (“the Piling Contractor”) to carry out excavation and piling works.
-
The plaintiffs allege that these works have removed support to their land and caused damage to their home.
-
The proceedings were commenced almost two years ago on 31 May 2019 and have had what the plaintiffs’ counsel accepted as being a “long and tortured history”.
-
Now, by notice of motion filed on 26 February 2021, the plaintiffs seek leave to amend their Technology and Construction List Statement.
-
I have received submissions on behalf of the plaintiffs, the Club and the Piling Contractor. The Builder has indicated it adopts those of the Club and Piling Contractor.
-
The plaintiffs, the Club and the Piling Contractor agreed that I may deal with the matter on the papers.
-
In their submissions, counsel for the Club and the Piling Contractor made detailed criticism of the manner in which the proposed amendments were formulated and, in particular, of the lack of particularity of many of the allegations made.
-
That lack of particularity is said to be compounded by the plaintiffs’ alleged failure, through their solicitors, to respond adequately to requests for particulars made in respect of earlier iterations of the plaintiffs’ List Statement.
-
Counsel for the Club and Piling Contractor complained that the matter has been further exacerbated by the fact that counsel for the plaintiffs has, in the course of his submissions, sought further to particularise the claim made and, on a number of occasions, stated that certain proposed amendments are not pressed.
-
I am not prepared to grant the plaintiffs leave to amend the List Statement in the form proposed.
-
It is important in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cohen v Double Bay Bowling Club (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWSC 295
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the proposed amendments were necessary to determine and clarify the specific allegations against the club, and whether they complied with the procedural requirements for amendments on the Technology and Construction List. The court also had to consider whether the amendments would cause an unjust delay in the proceedings or prejudice to the other party.
In assessing the application, the court considered the particulars already set out in Cohen's Statement of Claim and the evidence provided. The court found that the amendments were not made with sufficient particularity, as they failed to clearly outline the specific duty of care owed by the club and how it was breached. The court further found that the proposed amendments did not comply with the procedural rules, as they were not made within the required timeframe and had the potential to cause prejudice to the club. Consequently, the court dismissed the application to amend the Statement of Claim.
The court ordered that Cohen pay the costs of the application incurred by the club. The court emphasised the importance of providing particulars in any pleadings to ensure that the parties are fully informed of the issues in the case and to avoid unnecessary delays in the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
In his initial Statement of Claim, Mr Cohen generally alleged that the club was negligent in maintaining the premises. However, the club filed an Application to Strike Out the Statement of Claim, arguing that the Statement of Claim did not provide sufficient particulars of the alleged negligence, specifically in relation to the duty and breach of duty. The primary focus of the Application was on whether Mr Cohen had sufficiently pleaded the contentions regarding the club's duty and breach of duty. The matter was subsequently remitted to the Technology and Construction List for further amendments to the pleadings.
The matter initially came before the court when Mr Cohen filed his Statement of Claim against the Double Bay Bowling Club, seeking damages for injuries sustained due to the alleged negligence of the club. The club responded by filing an Application to Strike Out the Statement of Claim, arguing that it did not provide sufficient particulars of the alleged negligence. The Application to Strike Out was heard by the court, which found that the Statement of Claim did not sufficiently particularise the club's duty and breach of duty. The court granted leave for Mr Cohen to amend his pleadings to address these deficiencies. The matter was then remitted back to the Technology and Construction List to allow for the amendment of the Statement of Claim.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the contentions as to duty and breach of duty were made with sufficient particularity in the original Statement of Claim.
2. Whether the amendments to the Statement of Claim sufficiently address the deficiencies identified by the court.
3. Whether the amended pleadings comply with the requirements of the Technology and Construction List for particularity in pleadings.
Held
1. The court held that the contentions as to duty and breach of duty were not made with sufficient particularity in the original Statement of Claim.
2. The court held that the amendments to the Statement of Claim sufficiently addressed the deficiencies identified by the court.
3. The court held that the amended pleadings comply with the requirements of the Technology and Construction List for particularity in pleadings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In assessing the sufficiency of the particulars in the original Statement of Claim, the court noted that the plaintiff's contentions regarding duty and breach of duty lacked the necessary detail to adequately inform the defendant of the claims being made. This failure to provide sufficient particulars meant that the defendant could not effectively respond to the claims, thereby impeding the just resolution of the dispute. Consequently, the court ruled that the original Statement of Claim did not meet the standard required under the Technology and Construction List for particularity in pleadings.
Upon reviewing the amendments, the court found that they had been sufficiently detailed to address the deficiencies previously noted. The amended Statement of Claim provided specific instances and explanations regarding the alleged duty and breaches, enabling the defendant to adequately respond to the claims. The court was satisfied that the amendments had remedied the shortcomings of the original Statement of Claim, thereby fulfilling the requirements for particularity.
The court further determined that the amended pleadings complied with the requirements of the Technology and Construction List. The amendments provided the necessary detail to inform the defendant of the precise nature of the claims, ensuring that the case could proceed without unnecessary delays or further amendments. The court emphasized the importance of particularity in pleadings to promote efficient and fair litigation processes, particularly under the Technology and Construction List. The amendments achieved this by clearly outlining the facts and legal grounds upon which the plaintiff's claims were based. The court's decision in this regard reinforces the importance of meeting the particularity requirements set out in the Technology and Construction List.